99% Collector and 1% user. Am I strange?

I like the idea of only buying knives you actually use, and having to trade or sell two for every new one you acquire, but that goes away after awhile.

I think this about sums it up for me. But for now I can’t afford collecting so if I want a new knife I have to sell another first. But as far as the OP is concerned, I think that’s pretty par for the course. Most seem to have a preference for the styles they actually use but like to own others because they have a look, feature, or steel. If I had the money, I’d probably be out of control in my collecting lol
 
I have been doing the knife thing a long time, but I want to relate the beginnings of buying fixed bladed knives in my case. I grew up with folders and used folders (traditional knives) for everything. If something was too big for my knife, I used a hatchet, axe or saw. The world was much simpler for me and it still is for many. My brother in law showed me a couple Randall's (as well as some custom knives) that he owned. I was taken by the Randall's as they captured what I thought was a woods "knife" in the classic sense. It was an all around use choice with an emphasis on hunting applications (dressing game, clearing some limbs, skinnng, etc.) and camping. It was a simple time for me.

I had started going to gun shows during the mid to late 80's. The shows were pretty good; bargains, lots of choices, old stuff, new stuff, interesting conversation, and knives. This all changed by 2000-2005 and the internet. Dealers were pricing things to sell nationally (as on Gun Broker) and not for the local gun show market area. Prices shot up on many older guns and dealers were less willing to haggle. Knives were sold and I purchased my first fixed blade knives either directly or by trading. Then there were the knife only shows like BLADE..... things got interesting for knife knuts!

The Rambo movies had a tremendous influence on my knife interest. I didn't run out and buy a Rambo knife immediately. But I can honestly say that I handled many of them at gun shows, show after show I would pick them up and look at them. Just never spent the money as I knew they were "cheap" reproductions. Some were better than others obviously. I wanted a tactical survival knife! I got a couple Randall's and an EK..... those were in essence my first fairly useless but interesting knives I purchased. I was seriously considering some of the high priced Randall bowies that I knew I would never use for anything... I must re-enforce the concept that I still really didn't use fixed blades even though I was buying them. This is where the knife accumulation (pile) really started to grow.

So, this thread pretty much reflects my interest in knives. Call it what you want, collecting or accumulating, need or want, special purpose or general purpose, edc or just "too fancy or costly to carry".... It's a fun hobby.
 
My Brother David asked me to go to the Blade Show back in 2006..and that started me collecting Buck 112's. The Buck collectors club (BCCI) was and is the nicest group of people I have ever met in the knife world. Chuck and CJ along with Joe Houser and every Buck employee I met welcomed and encouraged me right from the start! That's how I started collecting and it's been extremely rewarding! Out of the ~100 rare,odd, 1 of 1 and prototype and sample 112's I own I actually have used around 2 dozen and right now I have about 7 or so in rotation..since I really like the size. I use various blade steels and handles as the mood strikes me and only a few in my collection would never be used at all mainly because I consider myself a caretaker of Bucks history.
I think the best part of collecting is the thrill of the hunt! I'm a disabled USN veteran and live on a tight budget so when I find a 112 at a bargain price I really get a big kick out of it! I also consider my collection as my 401 Buck just like I do for my guns and Silver...
I display my 112's occasionally at BCCI events and really enjoy that immensely! Its the friends I make and the people I meet that is the real bonus of knife collecting..it's not just about cutting stuff
.
 
That’s why we have this forum. Lately I find myself carrying just a SAK spartan.
Haha. I started out with SAKs, went on to "accumulate" Spydies & Benchmades in all sorts of designs & "super steels", and for the past few years also find myself carrying just a plain old Victorinox Spartan most of the time...
 
Haha. I started out with SAKs, went on to "accumulate" Spydies & Benchmades in all sorts of designs & "super steels", and for the past few years also find myself carrying just a plain old Victorinox Spartan most of the time...
That's the kicker for me.... I love all the knife options these days. I spend hours when I visit the big knife store in Sevierville TN. (Most of us know which one I speak of.;)) I try not to visit too often and now I have KSF to visit. But ultimately, it's a SAK that gets carried day in and day out.

I could pretty easily cut the knife inventory down to 10 knives and be perfectly comfortable in terms of knife use. Thing is.... I like knives and that's where all the others come into play.
 
Personally, I try to be a user of knives and not a collector, but I end up "collecting" more knives then I use. My goal at least is to use what I have other then the few owned/purchased as collectors.
 
The best evidence most of us are collectors rather than users is the price hit on carried knives. If a knife has one little scratch that doesn’t affect usability at all, it still plummets in value. Enjoy your collection!
 
The best evidence most of us are collectors rather than users is the price hit on carried knives. If a knife has one little scratch that doesn’t affect usability at all, it still plummets in value. Enjoy your collection!
It plummets in value the moment you buy it or sharpen it also (or most do). But I don't worry about value with knives. It is a black hole money-wise and that is fine with me.
 
Back
Top