A first look at the Natchez Bowie

Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Messages
513
A few things I'll admit to up front. I don't collect or own any customs, due to the cost, but I do have a small collection of high end production knives that have caught my fancy. I have been partial to Cold Steel knives for over a decade. Also, I'm very partial to big bowies. So, yes, I'm predisposed to liking this thing--guilty as charged--but that said, this is one hell of a knife.

IMG_0609.jpg


Out of the box the Natchez is a very impresssive, massive knife at 17 1/4" in length. The blade is 11 3/4" long, almost 3/8" thick, and 2" broad before the sweep of the false edge. Cold Steel describes the VG-1 San Mai III laminated blade as being "virtually indestructable". Hyperbole aside, the factory edge is razor sharp and shaved an nice bit of the hair off my left forearm with no effort. My prior experience with San Mai knives has been very good -- they offer excellent edge retention and seem highly resistant to oxidation or damage, though I'll admit to not torture testing them.


IMG_0607.jpg


The Natchez weighs in at a hefty 19.9 ounces, but the balance is perfect, sitting forward of the guard just an inch or so, and feels very much at home in my hand. The black linen micarta handle is sleek and graceful to look at and hold. The double guard and pommel are polished 330 stainless steel.


IMG_0610.jpg


Unfortunately there are a few issues that make this knife less than perfect in my opinion. This knife features a partial tang. The false edge is not factory sharpened, as it is with the Laredo bowie, one of Cold Steel's other big bowies. Like the Laredo, the sheath is of excellent quality leather, thick and well stitched with a sturdy silver/brass belt peg, but has no loop or clip to otherwise affix to a belt.

Overall, my initial impression of the Natchez Bowie is very positive. Aesthetically, the blade and handle are very attractive. While I have yet to put this knife through it's paces, I imagine the cutting, slashing and piecing potential to be just enormous with the mass, balance, sharpness and reach of the Natchez. The fit and finish of this knife is outstanding; this is a really solidly put together item. Having owned and used various big bowies including the Camillus OVB Fisk SouthWestern Bowie, the Boker Western Bowie and Cold Steel's Laredo and Recon Scout Bowies, I can say this is my favorite of the bunch so far. Fans of this sort of knife should consider it for their collections.

See other my reviews on the Rajah I, Hatamoto, Black Sable, Voyager and the Large Espada.
 
Last edited:
I don't care for the slickness of the handle. It could use some grip tape, or at least texture.
 
I like the Natchez as well. I've made Southern Comforts for at least ten of these beasts, and all the clips have been slightly different. Last time I talked with Lynn Thompson about it, he told me all the false edges were done by hand. I've got one in the shop now, that the owner had professionally sharpened, and it's at least as sharp as a Laredo's false edge. Impressive!!
 
You know I really like the looks of this knife it has really nice lines. I just wish CS had gone the extra and gave it a full tang :( .
 
I understand that the knife was created to simulate a fighting/martial blade not a chopping tool but still I agree with the half tang thing specially for the price.
 
Damn! That is a huge bowie. It's very nice. Are you sure it's not a sword? LOL!
 
the tang may be plenty strong enough for chopping, just depends on the demensions and method of attachment.
 
I'm sorry if this is a silly question, but how does the half-tang assist in the "fighting/martial arts" world and how does it hurt in the "chopping world?"
Actually, what do you mean by "chopping?"
Nicholas
 
I'm sorry if this is a silly question, but how does the half-tang assist in the "fighting/martial arts" world and how does it hurt in the "chopping world?"
Actually, what do you mean by "chopping?"
Nicholas

I don't think it assists the fighting aspect in anything, except that the weight distribution or balance maybe better. The knife as the author states feels light for such a large knife, being a full tang (with more material towards the handle) may feel handle-heavy and ruin it's role as a small sword.

Chopping or hacking for example at a branch or piece of wood places enormous stress on the entire length of any blade, it is accepted that a full tang knife is better suited to receive all the force created by striking repetitively. A partial tang knife receives a lot of stress on the portion where the steel ends and the handle is not reinforced anymore by the steel underneath the handle, it basically can crack or break the handle right there.
There are other ways to balance a knife than doing that (slimmer tang all the way back of the handle for example), most people will see this as a cheap effort. I'm not poking ill at CS as I like their knives but the point is valid.
 
Unfortunately there are a few issues that make this knife less than perfect in my opinion. This knife features a partial tang. The false edge is not factory sharpened, as it is with the Laredo bowie, one of Cold Steel's other big bowies. Like the Laredo, the sheath is of excellent quality leather, thick and well stitched with a sturdy silver/brass belt peg, but has no loop or clip to otherwise affix to a belt.
.

BTW how do you know is partial tang? Did you remove the handle? or asked Cold Steel?
Great review thanks!:thumbup:
 
Thanks for the feedback. This is my first review for you guys and I was wondering how it would go over.

I actually learned about the the partial tang construction here on bladeforums!
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=527104

Someone apparently called Cold Steel and asked and was told it was some sort of partial tang with a cable and a nut (like the Laredo), and that it was done that way to increase strength.
 
I did a LOT of chopping with both a Carbon V and SK-5 Laredo, which have the partial tang construction, and I see no sign of handle failure in either. Originally tested the Carbon V because somebody was crybabying about the handle construction and I wanted to see for myself. Tested the SK-5 to see how it compared to the Carbon V version in actual use since list price was cut in half. Performance was NOT cut in half - Carbon V holds edge a little longer, that's about it for performance difference.
 
Last edited:
I did a LOT of chopping with both a Carbon V and SK-5 Laredo, which have the partial tang construction, and I see no sign of handle failure in either. Originally tested the Carbon V because somebody was crybabying about the handle construction and I wanted to see for myself. Tested the SK-5 to see how it compared to the Carbon V version in actual use since list price was cut in half. Performance was NOT cut in half - Carbon V holds edge a little longer, that's about it for performance difference.

I was wondering about the SK-5 Switch. SOG has used it for years. Glad to hear not much was lost. Is the partial tang construction similar to the Natchez? Can somebody explain how is the thingy with the wire???:confused:
 
I’ve been outspoken regarding partial tangs on swords and big knive's for quite some time. Quality of production knife construction pretty much runs the full spectrum. Some companies sacrifice quality of materials and construction in order to enhance appearance. Many knives are made to “look” the part rather than “live” the part.

For the majority of people this construction method on big knives is probably not an issue however, for those who tend to push things a bit harder it “could” be an issue depending upon who makes it and where it’s made.

Most US makers of knives these days use full tang or a through tang construction method for there large knives. CS is not a maker and there for is somewhat at the mercy of who they choose. Many of there knives are made over seas and quality can be a bit spotty although it is getting better.

A great many reproduction swords used to be made with short tangs. One reason it’s cheaper and the they were bought mainly for costume pieces however, today fewer are made this way because more and more swords are being used for live steel combat, martial arts and competitive cutting which demands high strength and solid construction. And just as with swords we are now seeing a trend of increased use of big knives in competition cutting, martial arts, and general wood craft. Issues of handles failing on some of CS swords (which are made overseas) have surfaced which raises questions regarding quality and durability of construction.

I’m disappointed that CS has chosen this way to construct there handles however, because it’s CS it’s probably not an issue at least for the vast majority of those who buy it.

I really like the Natchez Bowie’s lines it is a beautiful knife. But as to whether it merely looks the part or lives the part only time will tell.
 
does anyone have an actual photo of the tang??

I've tried to find one no luck so far. A few Laredos have been re handled but no one has any pics.


Response from CS regarding Laredo bowie handle constructiion.

Hello,

The tang is only about half way full.
Then at the butt of the handle is the washer which is attached to a wire which is attached to a hole in the tang.
The wire is tightened therefor holding the hangle together with the blade. I do not have any pictures at this time.

Regards,
Kristi
---------- Original Message ----------------------------------
From: Mike Luke <borsofblackheath@yahoo.com>
Date: Mon, 17 Jul 2006 17:33:34 -0700 (PDT)

>Is the tang of the Laredo Bowie the same size as the
>Trailmaster with a very short piece welded on the end
>for the nut like your tantos? Is it possible to see a
>picture of a laredo bowie without the handle?
>
>Best regards
>Mike



________________________________________________________________

Sent via the WebMail system at coldsteel.com





Mon, 05 Feb 2007 09:44:40 -0800
To: <mgw906@yahoo.com>
From: "Michele" <customerservice@coldsteel.com> Add to Address BookAdd to Address Book Add Mobile Alert
Subject: Re: Natchez Bowie question
Dear Mr. Luke,

The Natchez Bowie and the Laredo Bowie share the same tang style.

Michele
 
Looks like someone has traded some emails with customer service on this, so I guess it's settled. Hopefully the construction is solid enough that the partial tang set up won't be an issue.

A in-depth review of both the Natchez and Laredo can be found on expeditionexchange (scroll down).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top