I heat treated eight AEB-L kitchen knife blanks yesterday and out of the eight, only one came out straight and the rest were warped to varying degrees. Four of them did not just warp side-to-side, but picked up a curve along the spine, like sori on a katana. I cannot think of anything I did differently compared to my last batch, where all the blades came out perfectly straight.
My process is as follows: 1,950°F for 15 minutes, aluminum quench plates for about 90 seconds, then dry ice/alcohol slurry. Prior to that, I used @DevinT's prequench followed by a subcritical anneal. These last two steps were done on separate days for four of the blanks each time. I tempered the blades at 325°F for a couple hours last night and left it at that.
Does anybody have any ideas what I might be doing wrong that would create the sori? I have another batch of knives I want to heat treat next week and would really like to avoid this problem.
The knives are all hidden tang and I can take a lot of the curvature out of the tang and nobody will ever know, so I am not too worried about that. But I have to figure out how to get rid of the side-to-side warp first. There has been some discussion recently about chisels and hammers with carbide inserts for straightening in this thread about straightening high-speed steels. How well do these tools work on AEB-L and how much of a warp can one expect to correct with them? Some of the blades I did yesterday have pretty minor warps, but a couple of the 0.06" thick blades have about a 1mm gap when I put them on the surface plate and they are only short little petty knives. Can a warp that bad be corrected with a carbide tipped hammer or a chisel? I've straightened minor warps with a sandblaster in the past, but I am pretty certain it will not work to correct some of the blades I did yesterday.
Are there any other methods for straightening AEB-L? I have tried straightening during tempering by overcorrecting the curvature in a jig a couple of times without success, so I don't think I'm going to bother trying that again. This method seems to only work on carbon steel knives for me. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
My process is as follows: 1,950°F for 15 minutes, aluminum quench plates for about 90 seconds, then dry ice/alcohol slurry. Prior to that, I used @DevinT's prequench followed by a subcritical anneal. These last two steps were done on separate days for four of the blanks each time. I tempered the blades at 325°F for a couple hours last night and left it at that.
Does anybody have any ideas what I might be doing wrong that would create the sori? I have another batch of knives I want to heat treat next week and would really like to avoid this problem.
The knives are all hidden tang and I can take a lot of the curvature out of the tang and nobody will ever know, so I am not too worried about that. But I have to figure out how to get rid of the side-to-side warp first. There has been some discussion recently about chisels and hammers with carbide inserts for straightening in this thread about straightening high-speed steels. How well do these tools work on AEB-L and how much of a warp can one expect to correct with them? Some of the blades I did yesterday have pretty minor warps, but a couple of the 0.06" thick blades have about a 1mm gap when I put them on the surface plate and they are only short little petty knives. Can a warp that bad be corrected with a carbide tipped hammer or a chisel? I've straightened minor warps with a sandblaster in the past, but I am pretty certain it will not work to correct some of the blades I did yesterday.
Are there any other methods for straightening AEB-L? I have tried straightening during tempering by overcorrecting the curvature in a jig a couple of times without success, so I don't think I'm going to bother trying that again. This method seems to only work on carbon steel knives for me. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.