- Joined
- Oct 25, 2004
- Messages
- 3,178
The steel case shouldn't harm a chamber -- the case is very soft and usually coated with laquer or something. If it breaks an extractor, that extractor was garbage and needed to be replaced anyway.
There is nothing weird about steel cases. The US government has used them for small arms ammunition in the past with no real problems. (In fact, it has certain advantages.) It's still used routinely for aircraft ammunition today by those who can't, or won't, make aluminum work. You'll see it used a lot in the big guns as well -- training ammunition aside, I never saw any 40mm or 25mm that was not steel-cased.
What worries me is not what the Russians use for cases, but the rest of the ammunition. I've noticed troubling inconsistancies -- first, a worn out Glock barrel (which most folks tell me shouldn't have happened), and now minor pitting of a Fulton Armory AR-15 barrel which had seen a few thousand rounds of Wolf and little else, discovered after its annual decoppering session last night. The lands are unmarked and the rifling is sharp, and as far as I know accuracy hasn't been affected, but it shouldn't have happened.
I still have some laying around and I still intend to shoot it, but I've made up my mind to look at other options when my budget permits. I now have doubts that I didn't have in the past.
In light of this, I'm reluctant to try it out in my Carbie, which seems to be quite collectible -- especially not when less questionable ammunition is available for only a little more.
There is nothing weird about steel cases. The US government has used them for small arms ammunition in the past with no real problems. (In fact, it has certain advantages.) It's still used routinely for aircraft ammunition today by those who can't, or won't, make aluminum work. You'll see it used a lot in the big guns as well -- training ammunition aside, I never saw any 40mm or 25mm that was not steel-cased.
What worries me is not what the Russians use for cases, but the rest of the ammunition. I've noticed troubling inconsistancies -- first, a worn out Glock barrel (which most folks tell me shouldn't have happened), and now minor pitting of a Fulton Armory AR-15 barrel which had seen a few thousand rounds of Wolf and little else, discovered after its annual decoppering session last night. The lands are unmarked and the rifling is sharp, and as far as I know accuracy hasn't been affected, but it shouldn't have happened.
I still have some laying around and I still intend to shoot it, but I've made up my mind to look at other options when my budget permits. I now have doubts that I didn't have in the past.
In light of this, I'm reluctant to try it out in my Carbie, which seems to be quite collectible -- especially not when less questionable ammunition is available for only a little more.