I just went and looked at all the logos in the original thread, there were well over 250 submissions. But some have been taken down (maybe out of frustration over the amount of time this has taken). In my opinion more than half are solid designs, half of those are better than the old logo (and more portable) and there are at least 25 that are really fantastic. I would have to say it would be a damn hard choice to make at this time for anyone with so many entries and so much effort by so many people.
Spark, honestly, I wouldn't want to have to make the choice myself, but dude, you started this almost 6 months ago and closed the contest 4 months ago. I hope you can make the choice soon. Sure, there will be some disappointed people but this has gone on too long "In My Humble Yet Brutally Honest Opinion". If you have to put the logos that you don't hate in a hat and draw one out and live with it.
.
Even if you decide that you want to keep the old logo you might want to award somebody something for the efforts we all put in.
Look at all the visits to the original thread (48,000 there, +2900 hits in this thread!), Just Sayin that 50,000 hits is a boat load of interest that has gone unanswered.
Respectfully Yours
Scott
(and so what if 5,000 of those views are mine
)
and now for a brief interlude
[video=youtube;i6yLRmo7CjU]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6yLRmo7CjU&feature=player_detailpage[/video]