Benchmade 581 Barrage (some large-ish photos)

Corpus

BANNED
Joined
Aug 18, 2005
Messages
295
Preface: Never saw much talk about the 581 on the general board, so I had intended to take some outdoor photos (cuz indoor photos be fugly) for those who hadn't seen it yet. Not realizing (till now) there's already been a couple reviews of it on here already. Decisions, decisions. But I decided, "aah, what the hell, more the merrier"

Have had the knife a few days now. It arrived with a weird grind (edge wise) I didn't like. Sharp on one side, dull on the other. So I re-profiled it with the Edge Pro system to 15º per side. Factory edge was something weird like 20/25 - took awhile to get both edges on par and to 15º. After I got it scary sharp I took it outside and annihilated some branches I found on the ground. Taking great pains to essentially ruin my freshly scraped and polished scary sharp edge. It held up ok. But after I was done molesting the hell out of the edge with multiple hard old dried out branches and softer wet branches, It wouldn't shave my arm hair much at all. Few quick passes on my Sharpmaker it shaves hair with ease. So given the ease at which my edge was restored to more than adequate sharpness, I'm far from being malcontent. I'm absolutely fine with the steel's performance.

Fit and finish, I'll be honest. It's not quite up to Spyderco's Taiwan level. The spine of the blade had a small nicks (more felt then seen) that surprised me. But we're talking on a nit picky level here, not like poor QC or anything. The blade is also not perfectly centered. But again, it's about 1-1.5 thickness of a human hair off. Nothing to cry about, just something noticeable. Bottom line, the little FnF imperfections are not a big deal. On the other hand, you have to look at the overall cost of 205 dollars. I expect a little better then this from BM. I'd still rate the 581 a 9/10 for FnF tho.

Unlike Nutnfancy, when I test for blade play I hold closer to the tip of the blade, not as close to the tang as possible. Pretty useless, imo. That being said, there was a little side to side blade play. After tightening the pivot a bit the blade did lose a little smoothness, but that's the tradeoff when you want zero blade play on a folder. And truth be told, for how much I tightened the pivot, it should have been a lot less smoother opening then it is. So that deserves a bit of praise. The spring being used for the assisted opening mechanism is no pansy either. That's for damn sure. I literally keep checking the stop pin for dents, it slams into it so hard. Out of the box it had the biggest "wow!" factor of all assisted openers I've tried to date. Impressive.

I love G10, especially the wood grain looking stuff. Albeit subtle in this instance, it's still very attractive looking. Love it. My father complained it was too smooth, but I like it just fine.

I wish the bolsters were a little less "aluminum" looking, perhaps anodized with a smokey or bluish look. Or hey how about Titanium bolsters ??? Not sure why a knife in this price range lacks titanium bolsters. Then again, do I really care all that much ? Naah.

That's about all I have to say about the BM 581. Other than, it's a solid knife and well worth checkin out.
Unfortunately, I never thought to photograph the wood I was carving the other day, so if you were expecting "in use" photos, I apologize. These are clear, nice photos. But admittedly, a bit boring. If it's warmer outside tomorrow ( yeah yeah, what a wuss) I'll take some photos of the knife being used for those who prefer those types over the "poser" ones below.

dsc0010fp.jpg


dsc0008ac.jpg


dsc0017ov.jpg


dsc0021sl.jpg


dsc0015gp.jpg


dsc0019m.jpg
 
Last edited:
Cool review, I'd like to see some use photos when you get around to it. Also, if you have any other knives you can photograph it with to show a size comparison, that would be cool. But nice review, I like the points you made.
 
Good review and the poser pics are very clear :thumbup: As stated, the only thing missing are some comparison shots next to some other common knives.

How was it sharpening the M390 steel?
 
Thanks for the kind words. AND because you guys asked for it. Ive got 39 photos to upload. It was cold and shitty outside too! But I couldn't ignore my BOTB's kind requests.

How was it sharpening the M390 steel?

I'd say it's not quite as annoying to work with as D2. Perhaps slightly harder to profile/sharpen than S30V. Once the angle is set tho, touch ups are as quick 'n easy as spitting.
 
The Usual Suspects line up.
dsc0010s.jpg


EDC LED Comparison.
dsc0011cm.jpg


Oh look an 'ol 2x4 - what could possibly happen next ??
dsc0015riq.jpg


This can't be good....
dsc0016vx.jpg


It's gonna feel that in the mornin....
dsc0020up.jpg


"Just call me Chainsaw!"
dsc0022d.jpg


Ooooh pointys...
dsc0023y.jpg


This lady bug demanded to be apart of the shot. I obliged. Yes, yes she survived the encounter. For the most part.....
dsc0026x.jpg


Some more shredding
dsc0027fm.jpg


El poseur freakazoid
dsc0032fn.jpg


El Poseur featherstickwannabe
dsc0035k.jpg


The damage is done...
dsc0037b.jpg


Now we're just showing off......
dsc0039y.jpg


Shoulda seen the other guy!
dsc0043tf.jpg


The other guy....
dsc0046ui.jpg


Don't look at me, I'm hideous!
dsc0049uf.jpg


Yeah, it's a branch.....
dsc0058j.jpg


Soon became a sharpened stick....
dsc0059yb.jpg


Sharpened stick violence...
dsc0067je.jpg


Sharpened stick violence money shot
dsc0069o.jpg


The aftermath...
dsc0076k.jpg


Rest of the branch didn't do too well either....Dissection.
dsc0066w.jpg


Stab me into something else!
dsc0078db.jpg


581 sez, Me too!
dsc0081up.jpg


MEDIC!
dsc0082kg.jpg


" Wait, I know CPR "
dsc0083d.jpg


Big block 'O 2x4 wants a turn... but first a sexy pose
dsc0086c.jpg


Followed by another sexy pose.... as gluttonous for the camera as the BM!
dsc0087sa.jpg


THUD! *cough FAIL cough*
dsc0090o.jpg


Yeah, THAT was reeeal difficult
dsc0092v.jpg


sharpened stick kung-fu toss - sticks into board - the grace, oh the grace.
dsc0093yj.jpg


Scene of the crime
dsc0095cbg.jpg


Hapless victims litter the ground
dsc0096si.jpg


Boker, " May I TOO pose with the 581 ? "
dsc0104mt.jpg


"NO!, I can't whore myself like this!, CLOTHE ME!"
dsc0106vf.jpg


"Tree shot!"
dsc0111cp.jpg


"Let them see my ass too"
dsc0116p.jpg


"Hey ladies" (slutty pose)
dsc0120fr.jpg
 
Last edited:
Close up of the blade displaying all the scratches from the carving. Photo got downsized upon posting.

Direct link: http://img232.imageshack.us/f/dsc0049uf.jpg/

I also want to retouch upon the edge retention of the 581. The entire time I was carving up branches and part of a 2x4, the knife never lost it's working edge at all. It developed a little bit of a burr, thus losing it's ability to shave arm hair smoothly (meaning it could shave, but it was painful). But never felt less sharp on the wood. At least, I never noticed any difference. Just now, I ran a few passes on my leather strop and it's back to shaving arm hair well and slices newspaper with ghost-like resistance. That being said, I never did all THAT much carving that it should have destroyed the edge anyway. So take that into consideration. I think what impressed me the most about this steel is how easily the edge is restored to very sharp levels. But you could say that about many other steels too. So, I must digress.

Something else I forgot to mention. I used this knife like a fixed blade - meaning, pretty hard. Slicing deeply into wood. I have to say, it was quite painful. The liners would dig into my hands and it wasn't fun at all. Do I care ? No. Why ? Because I have around 40 knives, so if I needed a blade for the same tasks I was using the 581 for, I'd choose a different knife altogether. One better suited and designed for hard use. The 581 Barrage I'd use for simple EDC-like tasks. Maybe that's just me. Now if I HAD to use the 581 in a hard use way, no problem. I'd just put my tactical gloves on - whal-la. Looking at the ever popular Spyderco Gayle Bradley, I can't imagine those liners not being just as painful, used in the same way.

30 minutes ago (out into the cold), I took the Boker (Special Ops Blade) in the above photos out and used that on the same 2x4 I was using the 581 on, and the 581 puts the Boker to shame. The Boker is a cool little knife and all, but it's no dream slicer. Not even sure what I'd use it for, TBH.
 
Last edited:
Great photos, and that's a really good looking knife. Thank for the review. Does that lock require thumb and forefinger to operate or is it either/or?
 
Nice clear pics. Did you use a DSLR for those?

Yep. Nikon D90 and an old Nikkor AF 28-70mm lens I purchased off ebay for 100 bucks.

Great photos, and that's a really good looking knife. Thank for the review. Does that lock require thumb and forefinger to operate or is it either/or?

Technically, you could use 1 finger. But I can't see anyone closing it one handed and with 1 finger due to the resistance the springs put out when closing the blade. There's no weenie springs being used in this knife. If I were to close the knife with only one hand (I use 2 with this knife), I'd 2-finger the lock and press the spine of the knife against my leg to close it. I did close it once using just my right hand, but it was more than a little awkward, and a tad disconcerting.
 
Yep. Nikon D90 and an old Nikkor AF 28-70mm lens I purchased off ebay for 100 bucks.



Technically, you could use 1 finger. But I can't see anyone closing it one handed and with 1 finger due to the resistance the springs put out when closing the blade. There's no weenie springs being used in this knife. If I were to close the knife with only one hand (I use 2 with this knife), I'd 2-finger the lock and press the spine of the knife against my leg to close it. I did close it once using just my right hand, but it was more than a little awkward, and a tad disconcerting.

Thanks, that's what I was thinking about...the pushing the spine against my leg. I only ask about the lock thinking how easily and how often fingers and hands are injured and was just wanting to make sure the lock could be released using one digit if necessary. I really do like that blade geometry.
 
Technically, you could use 1 finger. But I can't see anyone closing it one handed and with 1 finger due to the resistance the springs put out when closing the blade. There's no weenie springs being used in this knife. If I were to close the knife with only one hand (I use 2 with this knife), I'd 2-finger the lock and press the spine of the knife against my leg to close it. I did close it once using just my right hand, but it was more than a little awkward, and a tad disconcerting.
Really? I haven't had much trouble opening and closing mine with one hand. I just disengage the lock with my thumb and push the spine with my forefinger. To be honest, the spring doesn't seem as powerful as my ZT 0301, and it seems to have lost some tension after use, as it no longer feels like it wants to shoot out of my hand when opening:thumbup:.

This knife makes me twice as eager to receive my 890-101, which should be much slimmer and lighter in comparison.
 
Really? I haven't had much trouble opening and closing mine with one hand. I just disengage the lock with my thumb and push the spine with my forefinger. To be honest, the spring doesn't seem as powerful as my ZT 0301, and it seems to have lost some tension after use, as it no longer feels like it wants to shoot out of my hand when opening:thumbup:.

This knife makes me twice as eager to receive my 890-101, which should be much slimmer and lighter in comparison.

I tried it the way you do it, I agree it's doable. However, it takes me longer to close the knife because I'm being careful not to slip off the spine and potentially cut myself. I've stabbed myself in the finger once already (unrelated). 2 handed closing is substantially faster (which, coincidentally was how I stabbed my finger -lol). Just my experience.

I do find the springs to be pretty snappy on my 581, TBH.
This may come across (unintentionally) sounding a bit contradictory towards you, but my ZT300 has one of the least intimidating springs I've seen on an assisted opener. I actually thought it was a tad too weak for that size of blade. It does the job tho, and that's fine with me.
 
Again, it could be because I'm used to the 0301, but I find there to be less risk of my finger slipping off the spine because of the sharp 90 degree corners on the spine as opposed to the somewhat angular spine of my 0301. Though I did cut myself in the manner you described on my 0301, as my finger slipped and followed the blade open, right into the edge:eek:. The spring doesn't seem as strong because the blade is heavier, but pushing the knife closed will immediately show which spring is stronger.
 
Again, it could be because I'm used to the 0301, but I find there to be less risk of my finger slipping off the spine because of the sharp 90 degree corners on the spine as opposed to the somewhat angular spine of my 0301. Though I did cut myself in the manner you described on my 0301, as my finger slipped and followed the blade open, right into the edge:eek:. The spring doesn't seem as strong because the blade is heavier, but pushing the knife closed will immediately show which spring is stronger.

Was continually closing both my ZT300 and the BM581 last night. What makes the 581 a PITA to close is that there's no slack in the spring like there is with my ZT300 - meaning, after disengaging the lock on the ZT300, there's no spring tension till about the 25% closed point. Whereas the 581 has tension from 25% open to all the way to the locked position. That makes it a bit more superfluous to close, as I have to pull the blade all the way down with my index finger until I am able to reach the spine with my thumb, instead of being able to use my thumb immediately after unlocking the blade. As I'm able to do with the ZT300. Hope that made sense.

Comparatively speaking, the spring tension on the 581 seems a bit stronger (to me) when closing than the ZT300. I have to wonder if your ZT301 possesses an upgraded spring ? Certainly sounds like it.
 
Bizarre that it now looks centered. Interesting.
dsc0026p.jpg


Drilled out liners.
dsc0032tl.jpg


I took this shot because of how perfect it looks.
dsc0028jv.jpg


Spacer view.
dsc0033d.jpg
 
Last edited:
Thanks :D

I can attest the 581 Barrage can be a bit temperamental. Clearing away some debris so I could take some bracketed shots of a tree, the Barrage feeling insulted it was being used for such menial labor did this to me. Yeah, that's right, the little $#*! BIT me!
dsc0036du.jpg


All because of this (I agree, it's kinda " bleh ") :
dsc003789tonemapped.jpg
 
Nice review - awesome pictures. Honestly the 581 never really did much for me (aesthetically) but it seems like a very capable knife. That M390 sounds like pretty good stuff!
 
Back
Top