Benchmade 940 Broke TWICE!

WOW! Thanks for all the replies! I'll defiantly be giving benchmade a call as really like the knife. I do tend to flick open the knife periodically because the lock is just so easy and fun to play with compared to my lock back. I do realize it is a far more complicated lock compared to my lockback, I just though something was up when my slings broke twice. Thanks y'all!
 
Sorry to hear about your bad experience with benchmade. I've owned 4 benchmades including a 940-2 and never had any issues with them like that.
 
WOW! Thanks for all the replies! I'll defiantly be giving benchmade a call as really like the knife. I do tend to flick open the knife periodically because the lock is just so easy and fun to play with compared to my lock back. I do realize it is a far more complicated lock compared to my lockback, I just though something was up when my slings broke twice. Thanks y'all!
 
Don't sweat the obsessive flicking Antonio. It is VERY rare that I am not flicking away on one BM or another!
If anyone should have a bunch of busted O springs it would definitely be me........hasn't happened yet!
All are perfectly, or extremely close, to center.
Call them, send it in and use it however you want.
Good luck and let us know how it works out.
Joe
 
Thanks joe! I'll give them a call Monday since their closed on the weekends. I'll defiantly tell them this is the 4th time it's been sent.
 
I'll only buy a benchmade if i can handle it first. They're QC is just too lacking to trust buying one site unseen. My first benchmade was a fairly expensive exclusive that I was really excited for but unfortunately had terrible blade play that despite sending it back was never really fixed. About a year later I was buying a griptilian in a store and I opened the box to check the knife and this one again had massive blade play. The salesman let me go through a couple to find a solid one. But yet my 25 dollar rat 1 is rock solid and has a great action. I simply got a paramilitary 2 and never looked back.
 
Benchmade has terrible quality for the price. Don't buy site unseen. Or be prepared to send it back to fix it.

They recently stopped doing other brands like HK and Dr so maybe they will put more focus on quality in 2017... But it's doubtful.
 
Last two Benchmades I bought were spot on. Only problem I've had out of any before that, was the edge.
 
I see lots of threads stating how horrible BM is.
I bought my first in July '15. I now have about 20. I had issues with 2 of them bought second hand for great prices. Sent both in and they are fine.
The ones I bought new had no issues and the most recent, 5, were as good as they could be. No play, centered with great edges.
Being an obsessive flipper I expected to break at least 64 O springs........none have broken and all are still going strong.
Not a fan boy in the least, but I've been happy with every one.
JMO.
Joe
 
I currently own 18 Benchmades, all of them AXIS models. Three others I sold, two of them being AXIS knives. I have never had an omega spring break and, like Joe, am an habitual knife flicker. (Joe, is that you flicking off again?)

As to centering and other issues, each brand has its proclivities. It has been my impression and sometime experience that centering has historically been an issue with Benchmade knives. A few of my older models--a 705, a 710, and an AFCK--can't be brought back to center by the usual methods without impairing the action, but aren't that far off and it really doesn't bother me. My M390 Barrage and a couple others were patiently tweaked back to dead-on. I couldn't get my 940-1 to center for the life of me, but had read that their S90V blades sometimes warped during heat-treat and indeed that appeared to be the case with mine. I really didn't care for the blade shape or the steel and sold the knife on the Exchange with full disclosure.

BM seemed to have some QC issues a few years ago as well as some really pretty piss-poor sharpening. Any BM I've bought either new or that was made in the last couple years has been dead-on centered and well sharpened, as the company seems to have tackled whatever QC issues they've had and are putting out a more consistently well-finished product lately.

I've often compared Benchmade knives to older Jaguar automobiles--classic design, good execution, but something you've got to love and be willing to keep tweaking to keep running they way they should. I'm happy with the ones I have at what I paid for them. Seems like the OP just had some bad luck and others just don't care enough for the knives to put up with their idiosyncrasies. Your mileage--and expectations--may vary.
 
Benchmade's quality is going low these days. I recommend solid ZT knives

As I mentioned above, Benchmades made in the last couple years seem to have been subjected to a much higher level of QC than those made in the preceding few. Your post got me up, out of my chair, and across the room to my knife boxes. I counted the 8 Benchmade knives that I know have been manufactured in the last two years that are without significant flaw in fit, finish, grind, sharpening, lock, etc. I almost always make allowance for break-in and tweaking the action in any knife I obtain, so adjusting the pivot or waiting for AXIS lock stick to wear in are beyond consideration.

I have several ZTs as well and their quality is outstanding. I like both brands but would not buy one over the other based on someone else's notion that one is better quality than the other. Each brand has its own models that differ greatly from the other in style, blade shape, handle, lock, opening mechanism, pivot, etc. Apples and oranges.

You're certainly entitled to your opinion, unsubstantiated as it may be.
 
It's a shame my $90 spyderco is more reliable than a $180 benchmade. !

Well, I've owned quite a few BM's and admired some I've never owned, but I'm a big Spydie fan. It seems like most folks hold to one maker or the other...
 
Well, I've owned quite a few BM's and admired some I've never owned, but I'm a big Spydie fan. It seems like most folks hold to one maker or the other...

I've got about equal numbers of Spydies and BMs. The two brands couldn't be much different and I like 'em both, but the BMs get way more carry and play time. I haven't bought a Spyderco in quite a while. It's funny, too, as I haven't had to screw around with the Spydies or tweak 'em and haven't modded any either. The opposite is true for the BMs and I've changed out a lot of scales, de-assisted a couple, changed out back-spacers for stand-offs, and changed lots of clips and screws.

Maybe it's the squeaky wheel thing. :confused:
 
Also I am in no way trying to be biased towards another company. It's only that my experience has been better with spyderco. We will see when I get the benchmade fixed which I'll like better. I'll tell you the benchmade felt a lot more premium and smoother than my spydie!
 
And also I forgot to mention, the knife will still lock in place and is still usable with the one working spring. It's really soft when pulled back but it works!
 
Back
Top