Benchmade Lifesharp.... disappointed.

I bought a "like new" Benchmade 906 SBK Stryker Nitrous a while back.
Well, it wasn't exactly "like new."
The seller made some price adjustments and I sent it to BM for a new blade.
They found a blade in inventory like I wanted and the lady mentioned that I could keep my old blade if I wanted.

I had a blade replaced on my 9500 SBT Mini Stryker years back, again stellar service and on a couple of occasions I have used the Life Sharp program.

What ever "issues" BM is having these days, Customer Service is not one of them in my opinion.

As an Aside: I would dearly love to find a replacement base for that 9500 Mini Stryker as BM is out.
 
I agree. They’ve always taken care of me. I just wish I didn’t have to contact them so much about issues
Jeeze if that was me I couldn't be arsed complaining and move elsewhere.
Just me mind:thumbsup:,I sure would give up ,there again I'm not that fussy over a production knife .
 
I cant think of one knife from any manufacturer that I've owned that doesn't have some flaw and that's a really big list from $40 dollar cheapie blades to $900 mostly handmade knives but I'm not picky and don't ever expect perfect because they are tools and I use the hell out of them though and I always reprofile the edge at some point anyway. I understand why people get aggravated when people pay good money for things and they don't live up to the expectations but production is production and as long as it's not handmade don't expect to be blown away.
 
That doesn't look that bad, really. At least the rest of the edge looks pretty even.
 
I see you have discovered Benchmade's propensity for "Left Beef"

Nearly all of the Benchmades I've purchased over the last several years have had a left-side bias on their edges. Benchmade even acknowledged it on this forum about a year ago and said they would look into it. Here's my Adamas from last year: View attachment 931227
Interesting I now noticed this on one of my knives...
 
UPDATE: Benchmade had me call them about the problem. Spoke with a nice woman on the phone about said issue. They asked me to send pictures of the grind. I sent them the ones in the original post. They promptly responded sending me a pre-paid shipping label and said they would Lifesharp RUSH my knife and get it back to me as soon as possible.

So far, their reputation of customer service has been has been what i expected... top-notch.... I'll ship the knife back and will update with the returned blade.
 
UPDATE: Benchmade had me call them about the problem. Spoke with a nice woman on the phone about said issue. They asked me to send pictures of the grind. I sent them the ones in the original post. They promptly responded sending me a pre-paid shipping label and said they would Lifesharp RUSH my knife and get it back to me as soon as possible.

So far, their reputation of customer service has been has been what i expected... top-notch.... I'll ship the knife back and will update with the returned blade.
This whole situation just reinforces my previous statement... Please see below, but please note section "D" onward. Due to that portion being evidenced by the post above, the entire post would apply.
-----
I have posted the text below in the "Benchmade falling behind" thread, but I feel that in this thread, it is directly applicable.
-----
Now, I am going to pick this number out of thin air, but say 1 out of every 100 have a flaw significant enough that ZT, Spyderco, (insert brand here) does mark them as such, and prices them accordingly to cover manufacturing costs, and make their profit from the "correct" models.

Which means that a few things are possible, regarding Benchmade, they include things like they;
A) are some form of mass production mega-machine that the likes of which has not been seen, within the confines of the knife industry. And they just don't have the employee volume to check the massive volume they produce.
B) have a smaller second production plant or at the very least, a productions shift worth of personnel thats entire job revolves around the disassembly and reassembly of QC rejected knives.
--The next one is (hopefully) less likely, though it does have the most circumstantial evidence backing it--
C) QC was directly told to be more lenient with what passes their standards.
D) Item "C" would be backed up by a higher warranty likelihood, and would result in the company being more lax when it comes to denials of warranty replacment/repair due to acknowledgement of "C" and their requirement to do so, otherwise risk reputation.
E) Item "D" would then make the company look better in the publics eye; since the general public would view this as the company having a "Good Warranty" when all it Could Be is (not definitive) the company hoping that knives with issues are bought by customers that;
F1) don't know better
F2) don't care enough
F3) care but don't want the hassle
F4) are willing to accept the knife as QC Passed, therefore it must be OK.
F5) won't purchase from the brand again.
G) this would result in more knives making it out of the plant that are sub-par by our standards, and (unfortunately) considered OK by company standards.
H) All of this second portion would result in us knife nuts saying that Benchmade has to make up ground for a lesser than expected (at this price point) F&F standard.
------
I know that this is all conjecture, but it all seems to be a bit too convenient...
 
This whole situation just reinforces my previous statement... Please see below, but please note section "D" onward. Due to that portion being evidenced by the post above, the entire post would apply.

Interesting theory. Definitely wouldn't rule out any of these possibilities.

But does Benchmade really think its acceptable to have people thrashing their reputation on the forum to begin with? KAI and Hinderer certainly didn't.... Hence their abrupt exits from this forum.
 
Interesting theory. Definitely wouldn't rule out any of these possibilities.

But does Benchmade really think its acceptable to have people thrashing their reputation on the forum to begin with? KAI and Hinderer certainly didn't.... Hence their abrupt exits from this forum.
We are but a Very small portion of Benchmades sales. Mind you we can be a fairly vocal minority, but we are a minority nonetheless.

This is why we so not see more M390/20CV/204P, M4 or even CPM154. The folks on here are clamoring for upgraded alloys, but we often have to spend over $200 to get these alloys from Benchmade when other brands offer these alloys for much less.

The bulk of the folks that buy Benchmade are "content" with S30V being dubbed a "Premium Steel" and M390 as a "Super Premium Steel"...

Take their own literature for example, we all know that M390/20CV/204P are basically the same, aside from how they are formed due to different spray particulate distribution. According to Benchmade, they are entirely different, and are not analogous to one another which is entirely false... On top of that, how can we guage anything without a scale for measurement along side the vertical bars used for the graph...
Benchmade-Details-Page.jpg
How could they act so differently when the recipe used to make them is so closely tethered?
See below:
Screenshot_2018-06-28-13-44-25.png

They do not cater to us, and we demand more then what they figure into their profit margin. They make special runs and dealer exclusives to cover our bases while asking a premium for it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mo2
They make special runs and dealer exclusives to cover our bases while asking a premium for it...
Do not take this as my saying that we should get upgraded materials for free... But under the custom knife generator, the upgrade from S30V to M4 is $5 and to M390 is $10... This is why I say that the difference in materials isn't that drastic. Especially when one factors in the break in price the manufacturer would get from volume purchasing due to using M390 and M4 exclusively...

I would not be opposed to a lower end branch still using 154CM or CPM154, think along the lines of Spyderco and their Byrd line...
 
I've had pretty good luck with grinds on re-blades. Conversely though, I bought this 940-1801 new from a dealer and it had the same issue as the original poster.

tsjC05r.jpg
 
All I can say is my personal experience has been great with Benchmade. I sent in my 940 to get a new blade and asked them to replace it with the clip point 943. I was told through email they couldn’t do it but they did it anyway and I have a hybrid 940/943 straight from the factory.

Just bought a 698 foray and it’s grind is perfect or as close to it as it gets. My mini onslaught also has a symmetrical grind. I’m thinking any high volume production will have some glitches now and then.
 
All I can say is my personal experience has been great with Benchmade. I sent in my 940 to get a new blade and asked them to replace it with the clip point 943. I was told through email they couldn’t do it but they did it anyway and I have a hybrid 940/943 straight from the factory.

Just bought a 698 foray and it’s grind is perfect or as close to it as it gets. My mini onslaught also has a symmetrical grind. I’m thinking any high volume production will have some glitches now and then.

Thats pretty cool that they did that for you.

So far they've handled this whole ordeal nicely. They currently have my knife and paid for the return shipping... just waiting to get it back and if the knife is up to par, I'll be another happy customer.
 
I have always had really good experiences with Benchmades and their CS. I have not ever had to get a blade replaced though.
 
As the OP I'm going to conclude my experience with with Benchmade on this issue as I finally received my 940 back today.

I sent the knife out on 6/28 with a prepaid label from benchmade with "rush" service. Getting it back today makes that a 5 week turn-around. A little slow for "rush" but whatever, I finally got it back.

The knife is perfect. I'm not going to post any pictures as it looks like a 940 should look. The centering and grind are both spot on.

So I guess to wrap it up, this whole thing was pretty much a big headache but it was made right in the end. I was without my go-to EDC knife for about 9 weeks total. Being a knife guy I had plenty of replacements during that time, but it did make me appreciate my 940 a little bit more and reminded me why its my favorite all-around knife.
 
I wouldn't say there's been tons, but there's been more than a few stories, at least here on Bladeforums, where owners of new Benchmades were less than happy with the product they paid for. However, every story I've seen (ymmv) that's started off with a less than satisfied or disgruntled customer has ended like yours has - with someone who is happy with how things turned out in the end and is happy with Benchmade's customer service!

Sorry to hear you were without your 940 for a little over 2 months, but I'm happy to hear that they rectified your situation and took care of you!
 
I just sent in a 477 Emmisary for a re-sharpen and to have the assist springs replaced. The knife arrived back in 3 weeks from the date I sent it out and was very satisfactorily repaired. The blade had been re-profile sharpened very evenly on both sides and the assist was working perfectly again. I can't say enough good things about Benchmade's customer services. They have always treated me with courtesy and took of the problem very promptly and usually without charge.
 
I just sent in a 477 Emmisary for a re-sharpen and to have the assist springs replaced. The knife arrived back in 3 weeks from the date I sent it out and was very satisfactorily repaired. The blade had been re-profile sharpened very evenly on both sides and the assist was working perfectly again. I can't say enough good things about Benchmade's customer services. They have always treated me with courtesy and took of the problem very promptly and usually without charge.
I'm with you on this vwb563 vwb563 , I sent in my well used 750 and received it back in useable condition, sharp, even bevels, new screws and clip. Turnaround time approx 4 weeks. Now I have a presidio with broken omega springs in, can't wait to see what they do to it!
 
What is nice about Benchmade is that they will take care of you. There are stories of them putting together knives in parts that owners sent in after not being able to get them back together, they send out free clips, replace parts, and offer blade replacement for a nice price.
 
Back
Top