Best build quality electric guitar for a $1K - $1.5K (or less) budget?

Google Robin guitars handmade from Texas, you might know their Rio grande pickups. I had a Robin Ranger standard for about 15 years. I traded out of it as I wanted to try a schecter tempest with split coils. Mistake... One of the best guitars I've ever played that Robin.
 
PRS. The new mid range line is very good. I have a McCarty which I purchased used for $1500 and it's awesome. For strat or tele style I have a couple of Bob Logan customs that have excellent fret work and fit and finish. He usually does not do high gloss finishes. Also check out Hanson guitars. Unique styles and good prices. I have their Chicagoan semi hollow model. The Hanson brothers have these manufactured overseas, but every guitar goes through their shop and they will set it up to your specs. They changed the pickups on mine to P-90s for no extra cost. Excellent customer service. Gibson has been known to have some QC issues. I've been happy with the Fenders I've owned.
 
Google Robin guitars handmade from Texas, you might know their Rio grande pickups. I had a Robin Ranger standard for about 15 years. I traded out of it as I wanted to try a schecter tempest with split coils. Mistake... One of the best guitars I've ever played that Robin.

Never heard of them before, so I looked it up. Sorry to see this at their website:

12-1-2010

Dear All Robin Fans...

After 28 years Robin Guitars has ceased taking orders and producing instruments....
 
Never heard of them before, so I looked it up. Sorry to see this at their website:

Yes its unfortunate. You can find them on the secondary market though. There's a video of SRV playing one on youtube. Its got a hot Texas wound at the bridge, a traditional start in the middle and the neck has a paf humbucker in it with a nice wide neck. Great guitar and unique.
 
That confirms what I read in other places. I went to a store here with a number of PRS and ESP. They are at different price & quality level. The ESP seem to be a great value in the $500-$1,000 range. The PRS range overlaps a bit but seems to have a lot more in the over-$1,000 mark. The nicest guitar I saw was a PRS McCarty, but to be able to fit it into my budget I would have to find a used one.

The cool thing for ESP (for a seasoned player) is the possibility to get something built to specs.

At that price ESP/LTD, some Gibsons, and the new PRS line get my attention.

I can't seem to like Fender above their base model, just me though.

Ibanez, depending on style, is very nice at that price but generally they're not a fit for people spending that money.
 
It sounds as though you are looking for the highest quality you can get for your money, which is of course the way to go. I am suggesting that if you want a guitar as a musical instrument, to play, then quality means sound and playability. If the look, or image, is what you are concerned with, that is another matter. Especially if you play with effects/distortion, as I expect you do, you can prolly get the sound you want cheaper than you think.
 
Sound and playability is subjective - I wouldn't ask about that here. Obviously I will play them. The question here is about f&f, materials, etc. What's so hard to understand?
 
As a musical instrument, sound and playability are the prime considerations, everything else comes far lower on the priorities list. And the reason i had been trying to get some idea how you would use it is i would answer differently based on what you are actually going to use it for. Im not trying to give you a hard time, i thought i could help you. I do not believe you can properly say one tool is superior to another, unless you consider its intended use. A tool is better, or higher quality, if you prefer, based on how it fulfills its function. Is that not obvious?
Kind of like, "whats the best knife." The answer depends on what you plan to do with it.
 
Last edited:
I'm not asking "what's the best knife" (or best guitar). I'm asking "what brands have the best f&f, quality control, and materials".
 
Just wanted to give a shout-out to Jackson guitars. A co-worker of mine really likes them because of the durability for heavy playing. He buys them very inexpensively and swaps out the pickups. They are known for their "V" style guitars and rugged thru-body necks.
Like every other brand they have a wide range of prices based on country of origin, features, and finishes. The models with through-neck bodies start at around $700, and the USA models start around $2600. Even the lower-price models have very nice finishes. Like Ibanez, Jackson is one of the brands I cannot distinguish between a $400 model and a $2000 model (but experts undoubtedly can).

One thing that really affects the price and may not be visible, the wood. For starters, some wood species cost more. And guitar bodies fitted together from multiple pieces are much less expensive than bodies constructed from a single block. The thing is, you often can't tell from looking.
 
I'm not asking "what's the best knife" (or best guitar). I'm asking "what brands have the best f&f, quality control, and materials".

I understand. But lets consider what best quality materials means. Perhaps you mean something different than I do by "best materials." Does it mean prettiest? Most expensive? Most durable? Are we talking about how the materials effect the sound?
 
I love my Paul Reed Smith's! I sold all my Ibanez, Jackson, and Gibson guitars after I acquired 3 PRS's two summers ago. The only other brand I still have are a couple Brian Moore i8P models (also very nice).
 
I wanted to add another thing, an unfortunate fact of the guitar industry . . . just like knives, I suppose. Companies that built their reputations on quality workmanship at "player" prices are no longer what they once were. I look at my `90s USA Jacksons and recognize that I couldn't buy an equal instrument today for less than triple what I paid. That's not to say that they can't build a good guitar at a fair price, but it will no longer be American made, or even Japanese (like their "cheap" imports of that era) and certainly not with the heavy-duty hardware that have kept mine gig-worthy for many years. I bought a Fender Squier when I was in high school in the early `90s, and for the low price of $200 earned flipping burgers, I was the envy of my friends and bandmates. That guitar could stand up to a "real" Fender made nowadays, which I doubt would be the case of a current Squier. I doubt any could identify what kind of wood is used to build a current one. The greatest travesty might be the demise of Hamer. I don't mean the latter-day, high-dollar Gibson and PRS copies they cranked out, but the beauties they were building for the rock and metal guys 20+ years ago. Those were some amazing guitars, with incredible finishes and top-notch hardware superior even to the nicest Jacksons and ESPs of the day. I was lucky enough to score a used one for dirt cheap, which is one of only two guitars that I absolutely won't gig with in the interest of keeping it in the best condition possible. They simply aren't available on the used market in that condition anymore.

But enough "good ol' days" crap out of me. If you haven't already, check out Carvin. They do the build-to-order thing the way few other American makers can in this day and age. Not what I would consider true custom builds, but close enough for most players to get what they want without selling organs on the black market.
 
I wanted to add another thing, an unfortunate fact of the guitar industry . . . just like knives, I suppose. Companies that built their reputations on quality workmanship at "player" prices are no longer what they once were. I look at my `90s USA Jacksons and recognize that I couldn't buy an equal instrument today for less than triple what I paid. That's not to say that they can't build a good guitar at a fair price, but it will no longer be American made, or even Japanese (like their "cheap" imports of that era) and certainly not with the heavy-duty hardware that have kept mine gig-worthy for many years. I bought a Fender Squier when I was in high school in the early `90s, and for the low price of $200 earned flipping burgers, I was the envy of my friends and bandmates. That guitar could stand up to a "real" Fender made nowadays, which I doubt would be the case of a current Squier. I doubt any could identify what kind of wood is used to build a current one. The greatest travesty might be the demise of Hamer. I don't mean the latter-day, high-dollar Gibson and PRS copies they cranked out, but the beauties they were building for the rock and metal guys 20+ years ago. Those were some amazing guitars, with incredible finishes and top-notch hardware superior even to the nicest Jacksons and ESPs of the day. I was lucky enough to score a used one for dirt cheap, which is one of only two guitars that I absolutely won't gig with in the interest of keeping it in the best condition possible. They simply aren't available on the used market in that condition anymore.

But enough "good ol' days" crap out of me. If you haven't already, check out Carvin. They do the build-to-order thing the way few other American makers can in this day and age. Not what I would consider true custom builds, but close enough for most players to get what they want without selling organs on the black market.
I've wanted a Hamer duo-tone for a loooong time.
 
If you haven't already, check out Carvin. They do the build-to-order thing the way few other American makers can in this day and age. Not what I would consider true custom builds, but close enough for most players to get what they want without selling organs on the black market.

Just checked 'em out. I wish I knew about those when I was shopping! Beautiful, uncommon, and priced right.
 
Joss,

How have your in-person investigations gone? Been to some guitar / music stores yet? Have you noticed any brands or specific instruments with flaws? Have any brands or models stood out to you as being exemplary in your price range?

Just curious.
 
Joss,

How have your in-person investigations gone? Been to some guitar / music stores yet? Have you noticed any brands or specific instruments with flaws? Have any brands or models stood out to you as being exemplary in your price range?

Just curious.

Yes, I went to a place with a pretty good inventory of ESP and PRS. The ESP seem to be a great value in the $500-$1,000 range, with typical Fender look (as you'd expect). The PRS range has a lot more in the over-$1,000 mark, and were by far nicer than the ESPs. The nicest guitar I played was a PRS Korina McCarty. It's actually over $2,000. I have seen a couple used ones for around $1,600. The nice thing about the Korina is that it's a plain wood design, without a fancy maple top & dye job. I also want to try a Gybson SG (I actually like the design, believe it or not) and a PRS SE Zach Myers, which is hard to find anywhere right now.
 
Robin guitars. Fit, finish and tone and an awesome neck all in one package.

A guy tried to trade me a vintage sg for it once and like an idiot I passed. 5 years later I sold it for a profit and picked up a schecter tempest. By then the robin appreciated 100% in prices...
 
Back
Top