Best single edged tool for survival.

Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
240
What is your idea of the most practical and useful edged tool for survival, or just having with you in the wilderness.
The couple I have in mind are the ATAX and the tracker knife, but maybe you think a hatchet would be the best tool.
But are either of these just too much gimmick and not enough usefulness?
I'm very interested in what you guys have to say. thanks.
 
I like the concept of the ATAX, but it seems like too much thought went into the engineering of it. Your location has a lot of influence on the "best" edged tool. A machete would be a top pick in jungle type environments; a good 19" axe such as GB's SFA or Wetterling's would be the single pick for many in more coniferous zones in the north. I just don't like the "one" or "single" tool choices...everything has advantages and disadvantages. Regardless of the design, that "single" sharp edge will excel at some tasks and do others poorly however a lot of practice and skill will mitigate the less than ideal uses of the edge.

I like the diversity of some of the unique designs such as the ATAX and even the WSK-styled blade. Vector's Eco-Hawk is another very good looking edged tool that can do several different tasks, but I still don't like the idea of a single edged tool to do everything...if I can help it, I'll have a few different tools that will be more efficient for certain tasks.

ROCK6
 
Yeah I'm gonna be a little biased but for me it's my Knatchet.Chops like a small hatchet/axe or a 7"-8" blade and yet cuts as good as the sharpest knife.Choked up for finer tasks it's just like ya using a 4" blade.

P4060003.jpg


P4060001.jpg
 
Probably the Busse BWM. It will chop trees and split firewood almost as well as my 2lb. hatchet, slashes away brush and vines much better. Would be a lot more useful for camp kitchen chores and is more comfortable to carry. Thin enough to filet a fish but thick enough it won't break on you during any reasonable hard use.
DSC_0806.jpg
 
I'd pick my Cincinnatti Machax (bottom).

CAKwithMachax.jpg


Failing that, it would be a Bolo Machete, which I've used for years when canoe camping, and this was in Northern Ontario, not a jungle.

I have to say, though, your Knatchet looks pretty interesting, Pitdog.

Doc
 
I think the atax and the Tracker are not the best choices...... while the guys who designe them know a hell of allot more about he woods than me..I think those tolls are more over priced marketing ploys than they are useful... i like thin knives for most things but if I had to choose one edged tool for surival (not including saks I assume?) than it would be my bk-7 or my rc- 6 I just got the 6 it;s a solid sharp blade..But I;ve had the 7 out as my main blade on several trips including winter trips with no axe... It changes the way I approach things, but did everything I needed it to.
 
Like others, I don't believe that there is any one tool that can do it all.

If I had to take just one, though, it would be a simple BK-2. It does all that I ask, and I'm very familiar with it. There's a lot to be said for familiarity with a tool.
 
Even though I feel this is just mental masturbation, I can not think of a single situation that I would not have a pocket knife in addition to other things I am carrying. But for the purpose of this argument, I would probably chose a simple fixed blade knife with a fairly thin blade, 5" long or a bit less.

I said probably because I also might chose my cold steel norse hawk, the blade is easily removed and can be used as an ulu type knife, and as a hawk it makes short work chopping. Chris
 
My Estwing Hatchet. I always have a folder. If I didn't have the hatchet then the Bog Dog would do it all as would most any of my JK knives.

I have several Condor combo tools like the Aztec Cleaver that would work as well as anything out there.
 
an H.I. M-43 kukri is one

Estwing hatchet another

Just depends. Best in my opinion is whatever gives one the most versatility for the weight. That is why the kukri rates so highly.

My g.L. Drew 5" bladed knife also rates very highly. IMO
 
Yeah I'm gonna be a little biased but for me it's my Knatchet.Chops like a small hatchet/axe or a 7"-8" blade and yet cuts as good as the sharpest knife.Choked up for finer tasks it's just like ya using a 4" blade.

P4060003.jpg


P4060001.jpg


Seeing that piece in hand it looks pretty good.

The handle seems stouter than the "Knaxe" that Graham might sell again someday. Maybe their design uses the knob at the end more for chopping. Here's a link for those who may not remember the Knaxe http://gknives.info/archive.htm .

Tom Brown was on to something with his original design before it flew of to being the partial answer to everything.
 
a machete and a tomahawk.

the Tracker and the ATAX are both great tools in my eyes, but they are made to miniaturize and minimize your tool load-out, just like some of the tools i have designed personally.

after all, it doesn't matter how good your tool of choice is, if it it isn't realistic to keep it with you when you might require it, i reckon.

Tom Brown may have claimed that the Tracker is the best single tool for the wilderness (i don't know if he did or not, but i seem to remember him alluding to such a thing once), but Ron Hood never said anything of the sort about the ATAX in all my time around him. - it is a minimalist tool by design. i like my ATAX on a good haft, especially inverted, with the curved part of the blade pointing down. i've been meaning to make a composite handle for it, and am just about ready.

i carried an ECO Hawk and a Fast Axe 2 (which is much like brother pitdog's knatchet) on my desert trip last week and was very happy with them, because they took up very little room and weight, and folks never saw them, while my favored set-up of a proper long hawk and machete would've drawn unwanted attention if i didn't hide them wrapped in my blanket or something.
gear01.JPG


........

whatever the choice of the most useful tool is for the individual user, you can bet it is going to be fast to handle for their common tasks.

- for me, that involves a lot of gleaning-type activities (like butchering fresh road-killed antelope and deer on walkabout), movement (like pulling spiney branches out of the way instead of breaking them, which a proper hawk allows one to do quickly and fluidly, especially with the other hand full of rifle or shotgun) and small diameter wood collection (which a machete is perfect for). - the ECO and Fast Axe 2 do this adequately in a smaller package than i preferrably carry, with the machete and proper long hawk.

i tend to want blades that have a lot of defensive capabilities too, and the ECOs and Fast Axe 2's are not too shabby in that department, concerning how small they are, before improvisation with hafts, etc. - this is also why i love bowies so much.

if i was killing bears regularly, my favorite edged tool would probably be a boar spear... you see what i mean; we all do things differently, hence our tools differ accordingly, all other factors equal....

HTH.

vec
 
What is your idea of the most practical and useful edged tool for survival, or just having with you in the wilderness.
The couple I have in mind are the ATAX and the tracker knife, but maybe you think a hatchet would be the best tool.
But are either of these just too much gimmick and not enough usefulness?
I'm very interested in what you guys have to say. thanks.

Granfors Bruk Small Forest ax
 
Back
Top