Case quality (recent)

The last Case I purchased, run-of-the-mill Humpback Stockman w/ synthetic scales, had perfect A+ f&f .

The last Queen I purchased, Dan Burke Barlow which was supposed to be a limited run of superior quality, had amazingly terrible f&f... Though the steel was D2. ;)

qdb_1.jpg


qdb_3.jpg


qdb_2.jpg


Sometimes ya never can tell. :thumbup:
 
What about GEC? They make a mighty fine knife...their patterns are on the large side though.

I have a Northfield White Owl and love it. Excellent fit-and-finish, and the features are outstanding.
It was about twice as expensive as a standard Case, Queen, or Boker though.
 
I hold my current collection of Case knives in the same regard as my Queen made knives, and my oldest Case knives are no newer then late 90s most are 2000 or after...
003-18.jpg
 
Last edited:
I have said this many times before, but I think it bears repeating. Buy your knives from a reputable dealer that stands behind his product and your fear of getting a poor quality (or even substandard) is greatly reduced. (Hey Mike.... talking about you!)

About 4 - 5 years ago I started seeing a CASE dealer routinely show up at our local monthly gun show. A great guy, we had a frank conversation about the quality of CASE knives as his table was full of hit and miss examples. He has been selling CASE and a few others for many years and he has watched their quality go up and down. He told me (take it for what it is worth) that CASE's newer offerings were much better quality than some of the older models for the simple reason that they required new tooling and dies to make them. According to him (claims to have toured part of the CASE operation) some of the manufacturing machinery was ancient and after decades of use has fallen out of tolerance. The examples he showed me on his table certainly supported that. It was his opinion that the reason CASE was spotty on QC was they need a major machinery upgrade. Still, some of the knives I saw were pretty and would no doubt be great working knives. And they were very reasonably priced.

Right now I am sold on Queen, though. Love the D2 and their bone treatment. Twenty/twenty five years ago I remember their knives not being good. But I found one I liked at a gun show and it nagged at me until I bought one online about 4-5 years ago. I have bought a few since, and love them all. Their caramel bone treatment (not sure what they call the color) is beautiful in person. The overall fit and finish has been great, no nail breakers or bad gaps. The only one I had to send back was the Dan Burke Barlow as the scale and backspring pins were too rustic; they looked like they had simply cut them with a pair of electrician's dykes.

I am not sure that you could lose with either knife. But the D2 from Queen suits my purposes much better than the 1095 of CASE, and I have never like CASE stainless. I have a couple of their stainless offerings and it just isn't serviceable enough for me. On the other hand, I sure like some of those CASE patterns and wouldn't hesitate to buy one in 1095 if I "needed" it.

Your mileage may vary.

Robert
 
I've bought about one or two Case knives a year for the last ten years. Various patterns, usually bought as gifts. Not one fit/finish issue worthy of a complaint, a return or factory repair. However, I don't expect a perfect knife for $40. I do expect it to be "gift quality" and they all were.

For myselft, I've bought four Case Bose and one large toothpick in the last 6 years. I use every one. The Bose collaborations were vitually perfect. The large toothpick blade was even centered :) The only problem I've ever had was a Case Bose AK hunter with an ebony scale that came unglued after a couple of hours of wet use in the kitchen. Case fixed it the day it was recieved at the factory and returned it the next day by FedEx.
 
I have purchased two Case knives, Mini Trapper and a Slim single blade Trapper, within the last year. F&F very good, springs just about right and decent edges. No matter whose edge it is I always re-do to suite me. It's always best to check them out if possible. Mass production and you will sometimes get one that is not quite up to snuff.
 
I recently purchased a few Case knives to commemorate the 1911 pistol's 100th anniversary; a Kodiak, Bowie, Trapper & Hunter? Other than an occasional less than perfectly polished blade, I've been seriously impressed. In fact, seeing and holding them makes me wonder why I didn't start buying them years ago, plus they function so well and the action on them is perfect. Not to mention that their weight is solid enough to feel like a quality tool, vice a cyber-ninja belt pack accessory.

Funny thing happened on the way to the knife store...it's hard to admit, but my recently acquired Case knives actually makes me dislike, or should I say, not be so impressed with some of my tacticool folders (many of which cost significantly more than my Cases).

This is one of my favorites recent Case knives; not that it has or will have any collectibility, but it represents 2 great American companies from the 1800's that is still thriving today and that warms my heart. Additionally, I love how similar the "C" is in their logo names. Oh, did I mention, it's one heck of a quality tool too.:)

 
Last edited:
One of the features of my recent production Case knives that I really appreciate can be seen in this 22087 Texas jack I carried today. For a mass-produced, relatively inexpensive knife it comes very close to having completely sunk joints (as does my 6220 peanut, 32087 pen, and 62109W mini copperhead).

CaseTexasJackc.jpg


Notice the difference between the Case and my Colonial barlow, another inexpensive knife in its day.

CaseTexasJackbarlowjoints.jpg
 
Last edited:
i picked up a chestnut bone peanut and tiny toothpick. they're as well-made as i can imagine slippies to be. and they're the first knives non-knife people in the office looked positively to:

"beautiful."
"cute"
"can i have that one?"
"hey, my father had one like that."
"i'll look for the one our grandfather had. sure looks like that one."

if non-knife people can admire them like that, they must be good. can't say the same about my titanium military (public admiration, that is.)
 
My most recent purchases of Case knives have been totally satisfactory. I would not hesitate to buy more. You should inspect your knife carefully in the store if you are buying at a brick and mortar store or as soon as you receive it if it is an internet purchase. Case has let some stuff get out that should not have, but so has Queen and others.

Ed J
 
I have some good news to report. I had a few extra minutes on the road today to stop at [name of very large Case dealer in Missouri] to check out a few models and handle materials that were on my list.

First was the medium stockman, the pattern I really like with the rounded bolsters, in "amber bone rancher" handles. From a distance, and in photos, the handles look plastic-y so I wanted to see them in person before buying. No worries, up close the bone has an incredible level of detail from the sawcut pattern and dye. I even like the laser "Case" logo and "USA." Fit and finish on this knife is pretty good. No blade play, appropriate spring tension, and liners/springs/scales are a near-perfect fit. The blade edge isn't quite smooth, it seems to have a burr, and the edge is slightly jagged. Not perfect, but a huge improvement over the jagged mess from a couple of years ago. I bought this one.

Second knife was a slimline stockman. I checked out one variation, the CV steel and red bone handle. Wasn't hugely fond of the red on that pattern, but it was the only one in CV. The blade was a bit loose, so I sent it back into the cabinet.

Third knife was a surprise, something that caught my eye and screamed out from the display glass. It's another medium stockman with rounded bolsters and smooth brown handles. No CV on this one, stainless only. The effect of the bone polished smooth and stained brown is stunning. No blade play whatsoever, and the blade edge is finished nicely. Naturally, I bought this one too. :)

I'm on the road and don't drag around my photo studio gear, so you'll have to settle for this factory pictures:

28701.jpg


The color on mine is more of a reddish-brown, and mine are more mottled than this example. One side of mine is mottled really nicely, orange-brown and white and dark brown, that gives it a depth and level of interest way beyond seen in the factory example.
 
It's always nice to be able to pick through a few. Can't wait to see some REAL pics!
 
Well, here's my stag rancher Texas jack and my stag rancher wharncliffe trapper:

StagRancherMiniTrapper002.jpg


Both are very well put together.

Ed J
 
I saw those models on display too. Very tasteful. I might have bought one, but I have to fly home in a few days, and the TSA don't deserve anything that nice. :D
 
@ Bob - Glad to see that you found a couple. Looking foreward to the pics and have a safe journey.

@ Ed - Those knives are beautiful and I have been eyeing that combo myself. Great photo.
 
Well, here's my stag rancher Texas jack and my stag rancher wharncliffe trapper:

StagRancherMiniTrapper002.jpg


Both are very well put together.

Ed J

Is it just me or has Case's stag really improved in the last few years??? I just acquired a very nice Case whittler with beautiful stag scales and almost perfect overall f&f. Beautiful knives you've got there TLARbb!
 
A Queen will never be a Case.

Get the one that puts the biggest smile on your face.

I recently bought a Slimline Trapper from SMKW. I returned it for a proud backspring when open. After ignoring me for several weeks, I asked how things were going, and they mailed me back the exact same knife.. No help at all.

I then mailed the knife to Case. 8 weeks later it, or one with the same proud backspring, came back to me. I contacted case and was given a contact person who managed my 3rd return. The replacement arrived about 3 weeks later and is perfect. No proud backspring.

Moral of the story, if you get a Case you dont think is up to par, and are patient, and willing to return things multiple times and wait months, you will eventually end up with a well fitted Case.

I was so happy with the final outcome, I got a Case Toothpick. The blade wobbled, I sent it back, they tightened the blade, and again I am very happy.

I then bought my Damascus Stag Peanut, which I love, online. It could stand being sent in to Case to have the blades centered, but I have not been willing to part with it.

None of my Case knives were bought in person, they were ordered online and I got whatever they sent. My recourse is to return for refund, or deal with warranty service.

My suggestion on choosing a knife, pick the steel you want first, and go from there. If after that you still wish it was a Case, then you have learned that branding is a high priority for your purchases. It is for me. I did not want a Queen, I wanted a Case.

Do share what you end up with, and Enjoy it!
 
grrr.... i just discovered it. both my new peanit and tiny toothpick have "mashed" choils right at the "kick" where they hit the spring on closing. pity as they close really hard. now i have to apply gentle touch each time i close. dos this mean the spring is harder than the cv blade?
 
i picked up a chestnut bone peanut and tiny toothpick. they're as well-made as i can imagine slippies to be. and they're the first knives non-knife people in the office looked positively to:

"beautiful."
"cute"
"can i have that one?"
"hey, my father had one like that."
"i'll look for the one our grandfather had. sure looks like that one."

if non-knife people can admire them like that, they must be good. can't say the same about my titanium military (public admiration, that is.)

That's cool, here are some probable public responses for your Military.
"Why do you even need something that big?"
"Is that even legal?"
"Are you planning on sticking someone today?"
Mutters,"what a weirdo, probably has an underground bunker at home":D

My only Case (from 2001) had weak, mushy snap on the blades, and the backspring on the main blade wasn't flush when it was open.
 
I just picked up a Case medium (3.5") trapper in redbone. It's nice and made in 2001 just like the son that's getting it for Christmas.
It's a solid slipjoint. I do admit however that my view (correct or not) I've consigned Case to the rank of a $40 knife. If I'm going to pay more I get a GEC or S&M.

Case has addressed the ONE warranty claim I made to my perfect satisfaction. Maybe it really is down to machinery tolerances, because as a customer of Case directly I'm perfectly happy with their service.

Mark
 
Back
Top