I agree something seems “off” on this whole thing.
As to the complaint of Buck keeping the original box, as per Bucks website and their instructions to return for warranty, it clearly states:
Step #2- Package your knife securely in a shipping box. Be sure the knife cannot move or shift while inside the package and that there are no loose blades that will fall out and harm a technician. You do not need to include your original box or your receipt.
DO NOT ship your knife in its original packaging (it will not be returned), a padded envelope, a regular paper envelope, or use popcorn foam.
Regardless the OP should read the whole warranty section. It’s very possible they were NOT able to repair. I am sure there was paperwork associated with the return explaining next steps/options.
As to the complaint of Buck keeping the original box, as per Bucks website and their instructions to return for warranty, it clearly states:
Step #2- Package your knife securely in a shipping box. Be sure the knife cannot move or shift while inside the package and that there are no loose blades that will fall out and harm a technician. You do not need to include your original box or your receipt.
DO NOT ship your knife in its original packaging (it will not be returned), a padded envelope, a regular paper envelope, or use popcorn foam.
Regardless the OP should read the whole warranty section. It’s very possible they were NOT able to repair. I am sure there was paperwork associated with the return explaining next steps/options.