- Joined
- Nov 16, 2006
- Messages
- 6
I Carp, indeed!
good start on the book!
just found this forum, and i can say that that was the most interesting thread i have read in a long time. given the somewhat touchy climate of the entire thread, i found Mr Lyle's approach to the request, and subsequent testing to be well thought out, informative,entertaining and professional.
I wish my competition spoke of me with that much respect when i was unable (or able for that matter) to respond directly!
I have long been a believer that whether or not a knife will ever used it be capable of performing the task (and many others it was designed for. only side by side field testing can truly determine whether one knife (or edge) is better suited to a certain job.
The only thing that could have made the testing more fair would have been for Mr. Ki to have personally attended and been able to write a review of his own. I understand this wasn't possible.
If Mr. Lyle had written this review about my product under the circumstances here, i would be more than satisfied.
(insert disclaimer here)
Thanks for a great read!
Eric B
P.S. Does that get me a free knife Jimmy? P.M me for shipping address!
just kidding! 
good start on the book!

just found this forum, and i can say that that was the most interesting thread i have read in a long time. given the somewhat touchy climate of the entire thread, i found Mr Lyle's approach to the request, and subsequent testing to be well thought out, informative,entertaining and professional.
I wish my competition spoke of me with that much respect when i was unable (or able for that matter) to respond directly!
I have long been a believer that whether or not a knife will ever used it be capable of performing the task (and many others it was designed for. only side by side field testing can truly determine whether one knife (or edge) is better suited to a certain job.
The only thing that could have made the testing more fair would have been for Mr. Ki to have personally attended and been able to write a review of his own. I understand this wasn't possible.
If Mr. Lyle had written this review about my product under the circumstances here, i would be more than satisfied.
(insert disclaimer here)
Thanks for a great read!
Eric B
P.S. Does that get me a free knife Jimmy? P.M me for shipping address!

