I just skimmed over this thread again and I don't see how spydusse can possibly have known that the edge was out of spec. in the 3 days it was used at the nursery.
I mean what are we supposed to do when we get a new knife, other that give it a good inspection. It obviously looked fine as it's never mentioned until he attempted to sharpen it and found a spot that he claims was larger than the 40* setting on the Sharpmaker.
At that point according to CRK, the knife has already been altered and isn't liable for replacement of the blade. This makes me curious as it's kind of a Catch 22. Knife has a spot near the tip that's over 40* inclusive, owner finds this out while sharpening the blade and encounters this spot - then the blade is no longer warranteed because it's been on the sharpmaker.
How is someone supposed to spot a problem like this in advance of the touching up process? Just wondering? Is there some tool that the rest of the forum knows about beside me, that gives this information in advance so that the warranty can be used?