CRKT/Knifecenter Hootenanny: Not actually S30V

Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
1,941
UPDATE 10/24/16: CRKT has confirmed these ARE NOT S30V blades and Knifecenter is requesting all buyers return them. See post #86 for a statement from both companies. In addition, check out page 2 for further evidence from me of their dubious steel.

On Friday I received the Knifecenter exclusive CRKT Hootenanny, which is done in a titanium bolsterlock with CF scales and an S30V blade. For $130, it's been pretty good so far. However, last night I cut up an apple and was stunned at how quickly the highly polished satin finish stained. I'm not kidding, it was faster than any of the M4 blades I've ever used.

So I ask, is this normal? From my experience with S30V, it isn't. But I want to see how people feel about this. This picture, which is lightly edited to show the amount of staining, was take probably 10 minutes after I cut the apple. What you can't see is the total discoloring on the secondary bevel:

crkt_zpsm3wmt8h5.png


I should clarify that I'm not trying to level any JDavis level accusations here at CRKT, it's been a while since I've had an S30V (have tons of S35VN blades) and maybe it's just a lack of experience that is causing me to be so surprised.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
26,518
In 10 minutes? I've never experienced such a thing with s30v. I've had some light rust spots after forgetting to clean a military and PM2 after a day or two but nothing like that.
 

TravisH

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2014
Messages
2,930
Apples will stain (patina) carbon blades that fast.

But S30V is a stainless steel and shouldn't that.
 

The_Iron_Joe

Knifemaker, Jeweller
Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
880
Yes, this really doesn't seem like how S30V should behave... but then, I usually clean my S30V knives fairly quickly after getting them wet with anything...
 
Joined
May 5, 2013
Messages
3,618
Never seen any "stainless" steel stain that fast, not even some of the cheap "stainless" kitchen knives that I have had for years....

Not really sure where you go with that?

Of all the things I can complain about when it comes to S30V, this isn't one of them....
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2005
Messages
19,385
This throws into question anything CRKT sells as being represented properly. Maybe you all can tell one steel from another on sight, but I can't.
 

dkb45

Gold Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
4,435
Only stainless I have had stain like that is ZDP. Somehow a pretzel roll, of all things, gave it an ugly stain on the blade from cutting pieces off. That said, I have cut acidic or mildly corrosive things numerous times with steels less corrosion resistant than S30V without a lick of spotting or staining. I have even had better performance than that from high polish satin D2. You definitely got a bum knife, it looks. I would definitely call the seller and CRKT. Also good for posting this here, a couple more reports like this and CRKT has some explaining to do (one report could be a bum heat treat, even some highly corrosion resistant steels can corrode easily with just the wrong HT).
 

sabre cat

Basic Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2014
Messages
6,077
I have some stainless knives that have done that but I have really bad water where I live. Flitz polish has always taken care of the problem.
 
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
1,941
Update: It was relatively easy to polish it off. I'm going to try and reproduce this to make sure this wasn't some sort of fluke. If it happens again, I'll probably get in touch with Knifecenter. Can heat treatment affect stain-resistance?
 
Joined
Nov 22, 2013
Messages
5,140
I just cut a lemon and apple with 3 s30v from different brands and did not experience this at all.
 
Joined
Nov 22, 2013
Messages
5,140
This throws into question anything CRKT sells as being represented properly. Maybe you all can tell one steel from another on sight, but I can't.

I don't think crkt would lie about materials

I think a more likely scenario is a botched heat treat.

less likely but plausible is somewhere down the line, steels got mixed up. supplier could've sent the wrong material or crkt got it mixed up in their warehouse
 
Joined
May 5, 2013
Messages
3,618
Update: It was relatively easy to polish it off. I'm going to try and reproduce this to make sure this wasn't some sort of fluke. If it happens again, I'll probably get in touch with Knifecenter. Can heat treatment affect stain-resistance?

Not HT, but (I am really stretching here) it could be a poorly composed batch of the steel, so the properties aren't exactly what they should be...
Thing is, to make S30V act like 1095 would be an error I can't see happening.

I would subject it to a bit of testing as you I am sure you are going to, and see what happens...

Cut up a lemon and post some pics.
 
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
1,941
Okay, so I gave this test a try again. After using some Simichrome, this is what the blade looked like before I cut the new apple:

20161017_185346_zpsqz6laasw.jpg


Here is it mid-cut, with the apple culprit pictured:

20161017_185640_zpshqqpuhpg.jpg


And here is waiting about 7 minutes, without wiping the blade off (still apple juice on it):

20161017_185920_zps9p0cptgn.jpg


And here is the blade after wiping it down:

20161017_190147_zpsmmfla3aq.jpg


20161017_190150_zps77oei72y.jpg


And here is a video that hopefully shows it a little better, including the brown (oxidized) juice from the apple (it will be in 1080p once it's processed fully by YouTube):

[video=youtube;BU99x8dBGKo]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BU99x8dBGKo[/video]

As I say in the video, it is behaving exactly like a carbon steel knife, and is actually making the apple taste like it was cut with a carbon steel knife. This is really bizarre.
 
Top