CRKT M16-SF got run over by a Strider SnG?

BAfarmer: I asked why at the boker forum. The response I got was that it was designed for quick deployment, the user would have time to close it later.
Ratfinkelstein: No mention of the double flipper design.
Boker: I have to agree with our critics that the result is getting us very close to the Strider handle design.

I thought we were discussing the design - which is precisely what was copied. I did not express any approval of copying designs, but others have in this thread and admit doing so if you give credit where it is due. After 200 years of ingenuity, if anything is hard to do in making a knife, it's coming up with an original design. That's why I bought the Buck Strider - to find out how it worked in real life.

It's not unusual for two people to see different issues in the same discussion. My comment was based on the obvious overuse of grip grooves to change the visual interpretation and lamely disguise its origins, which is admitted. Grip grooves themselves aren't necessarily bad - grab the closest Kabar. Executed in leather, they are a positive contribution. In titanium, G10, or FRN, they can play hell and cause blistering. I'm disposing the Buck Strider on another forum for less than I paid, NIB because I believe it is a design taken from Kabar and poorly executed in the functional world.

It's NIB because Buck replaced it - the Walker type liner lock had no engagement.
 
Boker lost credibility with me sometime ago when the TJT claimed their cera-titan blades killed germs, yet was unwilling and unable to actually provide any proof of this.

I see this as just continuing down thats ame path.
 
Looks like an ugly amalgamation of some of the ugliest knives ever hit the market. I amazed that any of the progenitors sell either.

However, the problem of copying is multifaceted and only going to get worse over time.

First off, there is precious little territory to come up with something fresh that is sharp on one end and handle on the other, sometimes broken in the middle. Increasingly, especially with all of the pictoral storage capacity of the internet these days, somebody's new design is always going to look, to some folks, derivative of someone elses'. That problem will be increasingly "political" in nature.

Second, faddishness is reaching a fever pitch. Tigerstriping? I've seen that for a long time before Strider seemingly popularized it. It used to be something of a joke if a dude got overzealous with the gun-kote and painted up his hunting knife. Now it is a selling point getting "ripped off" left and right. The Americanized tanto has always been a rather amusing evolution to follow, about as useful and authentic as an American ninja.

These so-called "tactical" knives almost beg the question--who buys this overstudded, impractically recurved, or chisel ground, or hyper-reinforced point, no belly, unergonomic stuff that sometimes sports a bad paint job the equivalent of one on a 1/48th scale Tiger II put together by a nine-year old?
 
What about this?

RY884.jpg


ks1620ol.jpg
 
Bwhahah, I'm sure it was an accident. :jerkit:

I just noticed all their bags look like copies too.
 
Back
Top