- Joined
- Feb 6, 2000
- Messages
- 45
Wow. A spirited debate.
For what it's worth, I prefer to do everything myself. This includes heat treating in a vacuum-nitrogen inert gas furnace that I built myself.
Why?
Several reasons.
One is never sure of work done off-site. Do you KNOW for instance, that your heat treater does a stress-relief soak to prevent stress risers in highly sculpted blades? How do you know he double-tempers for certain?
And are laser cut blades overheated on the edges of the profile, leading to advanced decarburization?
By sole authorship, I guarantee everything I do for my lifetime. How's that? No excuses. Being a responsible artist is answering to my patrons. (and believe me they are particular. Try making a museum piece...
The other main consideration is artistic interpretation. When one hand makes, another hand engraves, one scrims, and another one sheaths or stands, each individual component may be fine, but they often do not follow a precise artistic thread that sole authorship demonstrates.
And Hell, making is about doing it ALL, isn't it???
------------------
Read, Study, Learn, Grow
-DO-
Jay
www.gilanet.com/JayFisher/index.htm
For what it's worth, I prefer to do everything myself. This includes heat treating in a vacuum-nitrogen inert gas furnace that I built myself.
Why?
Several reasons.
One is never sure of work done off-site. Do you KNOW for instance, that your heat treater does a stress-relief soak to prevent stress risers in highly sculpted blades? How do you know he double-tempers for certain?
And are laser cut blades overheated on the edges of the profile, leading to advanced decarburization?
By sole authorship, I guarantee everything I do for my lifetime. How's that? No excuses. Being a responsible artist is answering to my patrons. (and believe me they are particular. Try making a museum piece...
The other main consideration is artistic interpretation. When one hand makes, another hand engraves, one scrims, and another one sheaths or stands, each individual component may be fine, but they often do not follow a precise artistic thread that sole authorship demonstrates.
And Hell, making is about doing it ALL, isn't it???
------------------
Read, Study, Learn, Grow
-DO-
Jay
www.gilanet.com/JayFisher/index.htm