I haven't read through all of these posts but just skimming through I get the vibe that Kershaw does a great job. So I'm sure that I'm one of few to say that I'm disappointed in my dealings. I'll preface this with saying that they did do exactly what they were supposed to and fixed my knife. Here's my story:
I purchased a Blur a couple of months ago, but was hesitant about the standard version because of the steel. I had no experience with it. So I called and talked to an employee who was very helpful in assuring me that the 14C28N Stainless(I think?) was a great steel and that he never has problems with it. I usually stick with steels like S30V, VG-10, AUS8, namely those that are well reviewed and commonly known. But after the assurance I was convinced that I didn't need to spend the extra $20 for the S30V model.(knowing what I know now I would have happily paid the $20 premium)
I purchased the knife from Amazon and carried it for roughly a month with VERY little use. One afternoon at a friends I grabbed a stick about the size of my thumb and just started to skim the bark off of it. About four or five strokes in the tip just snaps off about 3/4 of an inch down the blade. There was no hacking, no twisting, no prying, no bending, just shaving bark from a stick. I have two others that can validate this. Needless to say I was thoroughly disappointed.
Instead of just sending it to Kershaw to be repaired I took the time to type up a letter (saying essentially what I said here) to explain my situation and that I would like to upgrade to the S30V blade steel even if it cost me. I also explicitly wrote to call me if that would be a problem/to get billing information/just because. I called a few times after I got my delivery confirmation to try to relay this message to whomever was repairing my knife but I kept getting a response along the lines of, "We just got your knife in a few days ago, it's going to be a while before we get to it"; so I'd wait another couple days and call again, same response.
I called again yesterday for an update and they said that it was on the pallet to be shipped out, and that is all they knew. I asked to speak with a manager and I got Cheryl (she was polite through the whole situation). She explained to me that they just replaced the blade and sent it back out....seriously? This is exactly what I did not want, I'm not saying that I'm entitled to anything whatsoever, but that is the exact reason that I took the time to write a letter with my contact information; and I know they read it because that is where my return shipping address was located. Talking with Cheryl, she did confirm that upgrading would have been an option but it was already sent out and that if I still wanted to upgrade I'l have to pay the $45 upgrade fee and go through the whole warranty process again. Including shipping (again) this would have come out to a little over $55, and another month of not having a knife that I already paid $55 for. Note that the S30V model can be purchased for $70 at multiple locations.
Again, yes, the warranty was upheld; but I feel slighted. I honestly get the feeling of, "We don't want/need your money and our time is too valuable for a customers requested phone call".
So now I have a knife (in the mail) that I'm either just going to end up selling or will have a permanent spot in (the back of) my case, because I'm terrified that if I use it it's just going to break again.
I'm not saying that Kershaw makes bad products or anything like that (I own several Zero tolerance and Shun knives) but to say that I'm disappointed with the whole process is an understatement. Disappointed enough that I think I'm finished dealing with KAI for at least the time being, not only because of what they did, but what they didn't do. Again, no one was rude or mean just extremely neglectful. I hope (and it seems to be that way) that I'm the only one with an experience like this.