Mr. Mattis,
Further to your point, Massachusetts has NO laws specifically regarding fixed-blades, but does prohibit the carry of "a device or case which enables a knife with a locking blade to be drawn at a locked position." So carrying an open folder is actually illegal here, while carrying a fixed-blade is not (provided it meets our ban on ALL double-edged knives). Odd, right? Well, that's what Mass. laws are known for...
Also, I'm not a martial artist, but I am well-practiced in the opening technique that you mentioned (actually called the "Spyder-drop" at one time). It works well on any largish blade-hole knife, not just the Military (though linerlocks make it much easier than lockbacks) and it gives draw-to-strike times that I feel far outstrip studs, discs, and other methods, at least by comparison with folks I know who are practiced with those types of knives. I would like to shift my grip for hard thrusting, but for slashes it works fine.
I feel this fixed-blade discussion may be a moot point. No folder will ever be as fast or as strong as a fixed-blade in a good sheath, but when you think about it, if we could carry fixed-blades then there would be literally no place for a folding knife, ever. They are by nature inferior in all functional respects except ease of carry and social acceptability. Those are critical concerns, however, and I'm not trying to downplay the role of folders. So lets limit this discussion to folders.
------------------
-Corduroy
(Why else would a bear want a pocket?)
Further to your point, Massachusetts has NO laws specifically regarding fixed-blades, but does prohibit the carry of "a device or case which enables a knife with a locking blade to be drawn at a locked position." So carrying an open folder is actually illegal here, while carrying a fixed-blade is not (provided it meets our ban on ALL double-edged knives). Odd, right? Well, that's what Mass. laws are known for...
Also, I'm not a martial artist, but I am well-practiced in the opening technique that you mentioned (actually called the "Spyder-drop" at one time). It works well on any largish blade-hole knife, not just the Military (though linerlocks make it much easier than lockbacks) and it gives draw-to-strike times that I feel far outstrip studs, discs, and other methods, at least by comparison with folks I know who are practiced with those types of knives. I would like to shift my grip for hard thrusting, but for slashes it works fine.
I feel this fixed-blade discussion may be a moot point. No folder will ever be as fast or as strong as a fixed-blade in a good sheath, but when you think about it, if we could carry fixed-blades then there would be literally no place for a folding knife, ever. They are by nature inferior in all functional respects except ease of carry and social acceptability. Those are critical concerns, however, and I'm not trying to downplay the role of folders. So lets limit this discussion to folders.
------------------
-Corduroy
(Why else would a bear want a pocket?)