Does anyone prefer stainless steel over cv steel?

Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
163
My first and only case peanut is a stainless steel, and although I didn't know anything about blades, patina and everything else when I bought it, I'm actually very happy with my stainless steel pocket knife. I don't have any experience with the cv steel and patina forming but so far I really like the low maintenance involved.
 
Personally, I like the CV, just because of the patina, but your knife has to please YOU - so if you're liking the stainless :thumbup:
 
To each their own, a good friend of mine loves traditionals and spends a good amount of time popping off squirrels which he has a dedicated copperlock for.
 
I go back and forth.

My only custom slipjoint was ordered in CPM 154. I had the option of 01, and decided to go stainless. My favorite food knife (S&M file and wire grandad barlow) has Ats34. Which I have enjoyed.

Most of my slipjoints are carbon steel, and I enjoy the ever changing look.

I do reach for my stainless for apples and fruit more though!
 
Last edited:
I like carbon in my pocket for EDC use.
Generally carry it hiking in wet New England, but really see the case to be made for stainless there.
I like stainless for toolbox and "in the car" knives that won't be touched for prolonged periods of time.
I like stainless for in the kitchen, but that's not hard and fast as I grew up with carbon kitchen knives.

Happiness and peace of mind are all that matter in this choice. IMO, one of the primary effects of internet forums is to destroy peace of mind with what you have. Sort of like crowd-sourced advertising that creates consumer dissatisfaction.
 
I try to go stainless whenever I can but I do carry carbon blades once in a while. I won't not carry a knife just because it isn't stainless. Sometimes it depends on the knife. If I like the knife and can only get it in carbon steel then that is fine with me but I do prefer stainless steel.

The TC Barlows are a good example. I like mine a lot and it's in my EDC rotation. Fantastic little pocket knife and I enjoy it very much. Having said that, if it would have been available in both carbon and stainless, I would have opted for stainless.
 
I like stainless and non-stainless steels. I prefer stainless in the hot, humid summers simply for ease of maintenance.
 
Let me be Frank:




... Nah, can't pull it off, and won't try. But the answer to your question is,

Frank.



(Me, I prefer CV/1095/O1.)

~ P.
 
Not me. I'll take simple carbon steel over low end stainless every time.

- Christian
 
Grew up with carbon blades and still like them over stainless. No matter what the blade steel, carbon or stainless, a good slicer is what I like to carry.
 
I like knives and tools in general. The steel should be tailored to the application. I prefer good old fashion 1095 in my EDC knives mainly because when I grew up my elders knives were always grey. I own quite a few stainless knives and appreciate not having to do as much maintenance or worry as much about them rusting if I don't get them out for a while ( I have knives that sometimes don't get handled for years at a time) for the most part though carbon is the way I go if the choice is available. My brother on the other hand is younger and really likes his knives to be shiny. He gave me a really nice boker copperhead not to long ago because after he carried it for about a week the blade started to patina. It was ruined as far as he was concerned. I keep a stainless blade in the toolbox, in my jeep,and in the wife's glovebox ect...
 
It depends on the manufacturer with me. I like Buck's 420HC, but then again I'm not too crazy about Case's Tru-Sharp, I know there isn't a ton of difference, but still Buck is were I try to draw the line in a Traditional, in regards to stainless and edge retention, with the exception of the SAK. Everything else is Carbon, or tool steel, or higher hardness/wear resistant stainless. I love patinas, and enjoy forcing and experimenting with them.
 
I prefer carbon steels, but stainless has their place. If you want a knife to look new forever.... SS is the way to go. Also, it's good in corrosive environments.
 
I, too, prefer stainless for the easier maintenance. But carbon steel never dissuaded me from buying a knife I like.
 
I like them both. The "Tru-Sharp" and 420 (probably the same thing) are okay. I prefer 440C or better, but if I find a knife I like in 420 or Tru-Sharp, well, it will be mine. I carry both and use both and don't stress myself over the finer points of performance. Keep it sharp and use it wisely and they will all work. Sometimes you will find a knife with a bad heat treat that just gets dull sitting on the shelf or in the pocket, but it is an exception.

Just as in my other hobbies, sometimes one comes along that is just special and it's sweet when you find one like that. And occasionaly a real dog will come along. Might look good and all, but just won't sharpen or won't hold an edge for anything but spreading jelly on toast. But, by and large, most will fall into the decent performance category.

As an example, I had a Great Planes Spectra that started off as an electric powered plane and was a decent flyer. I took the motor out and put on a tow hook and flew it as a pure sailplane. What an easy plane it was to fly. You could bank it up on one wing and thermal out with 15' diameter circles and at higher altitudes you could put a tiny bit of right or left turn trim in it and a smidgen of up elevator and it would circle and climb out without you doing anything but watching it. My son crashed it and I rebuilt it, but it never flew worth a hoot again. Anyway, knives are like that sometimes as well.

Ed J
 
Back
Top