- Joined
- Sep 7, 2017
- Messages
- 149
That China D2.
So many knives now in this steel from China who knows what mystery steel it is.
So many knives now in this steel from China who knows what mystery steel it is.
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
I understand skepticism about a lot of things, but why D2?That China D2.
So many knives now in this steel from China who knows what mystery steel it is.
I understand skepticism about a lot of things, but why D2?
When an American designer/vendor/"maker" advertises "China D2" to distinguish his offshore-produced inventory, that's funny.
But why would we be skeptical of a manufacturer using a readily-available tool steel? Maybe they could save some money ripping people off by making blades out of "cheaper" steel, but at a certain point it costs more to buy cheap barstock of mystery metal than it does to buy actual D2. (Especially if you have high enough standards to throw away blades with inclusions that show up mid-grind.)
One of the reasons tool steels are popular in knives is that they're usually easy to find in bar form. It's not worth "faking" an easy-to-find steel.
You could save money cutting/grinding blades from mild steel, or by not hardening them... But the distinction in manufacturing quality is a lot more murky that that.
Blades coming from these factories are probably made from D2, just like they're using "real" G10 and "real" ball bearings. The issue isn't that a manufacturer of cheap knives doesn't have access to "good" materials; it's that if you pick one off the line it could have major issues with heat treat, lockup, detent, fasteners, edge grind, or a number of other things. These companies source millions of dollars worth of materials for large American knife companies. Fake D2 is not the problem.
...if you pick one off the line it could have major issues with heat treat, lockup, detent, fasteners, edge grind, or a number of other things.
I would hardly equate purchasing a Chinese manufactured knife to mugging old lady, most people shop at Walmart and buy Chinese products so I don't think it's really that dramatic. I completely understand your point though.I would like to mug an old lady, but I don’t want to do it in a dark alley where I might get mugged. What do?
I'm finding this to be completely true.This & lack of warranty...I give em two thumbs down.
To try & answer the question; trying to find any truthful information on these knives is dern near impossible.
I appreciate all the input from everyone. You all have valid points. A big reason I don't spend &$100.00 or $200.00 dollars on a pocket knife is that I'm almost afraid to use it, or possibly lose it. I can forgive myself for losing a fifteen dollar knife a lot more easily... which really has nothing to do with the manufacturer.
Why not go with spydercos budget line, or even kershaw? They make quality products at the lower end of the price spectrum. You'll not only have a quality product from companies that will stand behind their product, but you also won't be supporting companies that are dishonest to you. If $30 is your budget, I can't imagine why you don't have a spyderco or kershaw
I have an Esee Avispa, it's a great knife. I guess I just enjoy variety, but please understand that I really do appreciate quality.
I understand skepticism about a lot of things, but why D2?
When an American designer/vendor/"maker" advertises "China D2" to distinguish his offshore-produced inventory, that's funny.
But why would we be skeptical of a manufacturer using a readily-available tool steel? Maybe they could save some money ripping people off by making blades out of "cheaper" steel, but at a certain point it costs more to buy cheap barstock of mystery metal than it does to buy actual D2. (Especially if you have high enough standards to throw away blades with inclusions that show up mid-grind.)
One of the reasons tool steels are popular in knives is that they're usually easy to find in bar form. It's not worth "faking" an easy-to-find steel.
You could save money cutting/grinding blades from mild steel, or by not hardening them... But the distinction in manufacturing quality is a lot more murky that that.
Blades coming from these factories are probably made from D2, just like they're using "real" G10 and "real" ball bearings. The issue isn't that a manufacturer of cheap knives doesn't have access to "good" materials; it's that if you pick one off the line it could have major issues with heat treat, lockup, detent, fasteners, edge grind, or a number of other things. These companies source millions of dollars worth of materials for large American knife companies. Fake D2 is not the problem.
Ive heard excellent things about civivi, WEs budget line. https://www.bladehq.com/cat--CIVIVI--3293I have an Esee Avispa, it's a great knife. I guess I just enjoy variety, but please understand that I really do appreciate quality.
Ive heard excellent things about civivi, WEs budget line. https://www.bladehq.com/cat--CIVIVI--3293
Kizer s budget line looks promising also. They can found on BHQ aswell
Utilitac II as well. There are endless budget options that are far better than supporting thieves...... and don’t forget the Rat Model 1 and 2!
Exactly. Getting a warranty has real value, even in $20 knife. It shows that the company cares enough to stand behind their product. And when it comes to a cutting tool that folds where your fingers are placed, that is important.Why not go with spydercos budget line, or even kershaw? They make quality products at the lower end of the price spectrum. You'll not only have a quality product from companies that will stand behind their product, but you also won't be supporting companies that are dishonest to you. If $30 is your budget, I can't imagine why you don't have a spyderco or kershaw
Check out the Ruike 801. Excellent knife for the money. Also check out the Steel Will Cutjack D2 for a slightly more expensive knife, but one good enough that it could last your life. There’s also the Harnds Talisman which is very cheap but from what I hear a good quality knife.
Doesn’t Sanrenmu make both Ruike and Real Steel knives? I believe both brands are owned by Fenix, but I was under the assumption that Sanrenmu produced the knives. I could be totally wrong.
Also, I have a Ruike P128-SF that’s one HELLUVA knife for $50. Also just picked up a Civivi Aquila to check out and I love it. Both knives are outstanding quality—not just ‘for the money’ either—just good quality stuff that doesn’t break the bank.
View attachment 1000115
Not a single original design.I have a Ganzo. Not a bad knife but I wasn't trying to find a "poor man's Benchmade" either. I was looking for a knife that if I lost or broke it I wouldn't be like "Well, it was $16. Who cares?."
This is an internet grab but mine is the same model (I think) as the orange handled one:
![]()
In short I bought it because of what it is (a halfway decent knife at a cheap price) not for what it was pretending to be. Honestly I had no idea it was a ripoff of the Benchmade until well after I got it.
Which vendor on the supporting vendors list sells Ganzo?Not sure about PSRK but ganzo knives are sold by dealers on here.
S SmartCastle7 , welcome to Blade Forums and thanks for sharing your question. You picked a very divisive topic to introduce yourself to the community, but I think you deserve the best answers that we can offer.I have a Ganzo. Not a bad knife but I wasn't trying to find a "poor man's Benchmade" either. I was looking for a knife that if I lost or broke it I wouldn't be like "Well, it was $16. Who cares?."
This is an internet grab but mine is the same model (I think) as the orange handled one:
![]()
In short I bought it because of what it is (a halfway decent knife at a cheap price) not for what it was pretending to be. Honestly I had no idea it was a ripoff of the Benchmade until well after I got it.