Scott, After all the praise and atta boys, I started not to post at all, but since I have a "non-binding" opinion, I'll share it with you.
Your knife is what it is and if it suits you and your customer, then that's it.
When I hear one of the guys I'm teaching sheath work say "it's good enough", then I assume it's perfect, because anything less is not good enough, and that's just what I tell them. You probably have already used this knife as a very, very valuable learning experience and that's really good. The fact that it looks neo-tribal makes the asymmetry acceptable and, in fact adds to the charm, but if that is not what you were trying for, then you quit before you were finished.
I am not a knife maker, so you can blow my opinion off if you like, but the next time you make one that looks that good just don't advertise the mistakes that happened getting there. Had you done that I would be saying atta boy! great knife!.....but if you knew it wasn't what you were trying for, then it should never have seen the light of day.
I hope you accept this in the spirit in which I meant it, 'cause I'm really on your side.
Pul
:thumbup: 
