Been a slow morning for me (no new snow to clear since Thursday/Friday!). This thread got me to thinking. One thing I never really understood is why some folks, when buying a knife on the exchange, find that if a knife has been sharpened by the owner ... it's a no sale for them (regardless of the overall condition of the knife or how well the knife was sharpened). Now I can understand if the sharpening job had been really butchered or a significant amount of steel had been removed ... but heck, the knife was originally sharpened by the maker! While I personally would be turned away from a butchered sharpening job (or one where way too much steel had been removed) the fact that a knife had been sharpened is no problem for me. When I get a knife from a maker that is not as sharp, bevel not as even, or edge not as good looking as I would like, first thing I normally do is touch up the edge, trying to keep the makers bevel as close (in dps) as possible so that I remove minimal blade material. Would be interested in your thoughts. Oh, as for removing too much steel .... this is what my 40-yr-old Buck 110 looks like after decades of sharpening!