I enjoy this forum and all of the participants. It saddens me when I see personality clashes rise, without cause, and derail the giving nature or intent of the thread.
I will eventually know most of you folks at a personal level as I start attending the meets so I have a vested interest in seeing harmony within this group of talented individuals.
Kevins post was interesting but it wasnt a scientific presentation nor was it meant to be. The statement was clear and the visuals had a great impact. That simple post had me backtracking on many old posts and it will change the way I approach heat treating AND it will throw me into my scientific mode of analyzing past studies for their methodology, set up, controls and conclusions. This is fascinating material.
Tai, another talented participant, made a simple non threatening statement that essentially supported the concepts well known limitations and what happens? A group of people gang up on Tai as if he had written something offensive. Well good people, this is an example of personality clash, style clash and or bad interpersonal history. None of this belongs on this type of a thread and frankly it shouldnt be part of any forum. On the other hand, disagreements, right or wrong should be a component to a forum if people want to see growth and provocative ideas that can help a field or individuals to flourish. These two facets that are inherently part of this genre can have similar origins but are quite different.
So I ask politely. As a member of this big family, will you all try to restrain your hostility and if necessary let loose in a private manner?
As to the Kevin's post...Thanks Kevin. The graphic (with bias or not) sent me on a delightful path that lead back to old posts of yours on high temp and low tem salt baths. I have ideas about creating a safer working bath via ultrasonic agitation (to prevent big nasty bubbles of explosive molten salt).