Fallkniven A1 Video Test...No Destruction....Yet

Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
1,009
I was always interested in the Cold Steel SRK knife and I heard good things about it.
I am going on a short term hiking trip to get away for a few days and have some knife fun in the wilderness.

I usually carry a large fixed blade 9” plus. Different makes from time to time.
So I decided to look for a smaller knife this time around and give it a try.

I liked the SRK for my needs but I don’t like AUS 8A steel very much at all.
After reading all the great comments on Fallkniven I decided to give the A1 a try. I have never owned any of their knives.

The SRK and the A1 are close in design. Whomever was first, I don’t care.

I received my A1 today and took it out into the shop and performed some tests.I started with chopping a 2x4. I am very impressed with this knife. It is not the best design for a heavy chopper but it is very effective giving it size and weigh.Much better then buck Nighthawk I tested a while back. I got through the 2x4 fairly quickly. The A1 takes some large bites for it’s size and weight.

I will have to say it is the most solid feeling knife I have ever held.

I then cut some 14 gauge 3 wire outdoor Romex . I was able to cut through it
pretty easy. Not bad so far.

I have a Buck Intrepid out in the shop and I have used it to hack the wire before. Cutting it when I couldn’t find my side cutters once. The edge took on dents from the 3 wires. So I decided to try this with the A1 and fantastic it chopped through it instantly with very little force. There was no edge denting at all.

After all of this I was still able to cut cardboard easily for a very thick knife,better then I expected.

The handle is very nice and tacky insuring a good grip.

The one disappointment I had is the black finish is not durable at all. I removed a lot the first 2x4 it just almost rubs off. I worked the tip in wood and the finish came off. I would expect a more durable finish for the price of the knife.

I also don’t like the Zytel sheath it came with. So I will use Strider BT sheath instead. Since my Strider no longer needs it.

Overall so far I like it a lot. I can live with the finish wearing off.

I went back out tonight and recreated the same tests and Video taped them for everyone to see.

There is no Destruction this time around. However I will defiantly put one to the full test soon.

Videos are posted at www.knifetests.com

ENJOY THE VIDEOS. They were made for you.:thumbup:


obj370geo386pg24p9.jpg
 
Hey Noss,

Thanks for putting this out here! I am the proud owner of a Fallkniven A2 (the A1's slightly bigger brother) myself, I find it very interesting to see how it holds up to your testing. My testing has only taken place in the kitchen, pulverising a coconut:) (Which did take a few tiny dents out of the edge...)Look forward to seeing some more!

Gijs
 
Your welcome. I would like to get the A2 As well. Extra chopping power. Don't worry about kitchen testing Coconut is tough stuff. That would make a good addition to my tests Thanks for the idea.
 
Any time! Should you do any testing with coconuts: be careful with them! If you don't hold on to them very tightly when hacking, you'll have them flying all over the place, wear a helmet :) !

Oh, I'd like to make clear, I didn't get my A2 just for kitchen use (it's just that I really wanted to it try out as soon as I got it...)!
 
good news so far.... interesting coz IIRC the steel in the A1 is laminated VG10 (with 420J2 on the sides)......and i'm guessing that "toughness" is not supposed to be VG-10's forte....
 
I have cut open soup cans with my S1 and not damaged the edge.VG-10 is pretty tough stuff.Holds a good edge too.
 
jgkort: I have never tried to chop a coconut but I can see how it would get away from you. thanks for the advice.


jaislandboy: According Fallknivens website it is just Laminated VG-10 it doesn't say 420J2 is used on the sides. For the Northern Light Series it shows it using this combination of steels. The A2 also shows this combination as well.
 
jgkort: I have never tried to chop a coconut but I can see how it would get away from you. thanks for the advice.


jaislandboy: According Fallknivens website it is just Laminated VG-10 it doesn't say 420J2 is used on the sides. For the Northern Light Series it shows it using this combination of steels. The A2 also shows this combination as well.

hi noss4
i believe what is described as "Rust-resistant special steel" on the last page of their catalog here: http://www.fallkniven.com/eng_fallkniven_2007.pdf
is what the Laminated vg-10 consists of....
 
jaislandboy: Ok.. I looked at it..That clears up my confusion. Thanks for the link.
 
I have been doing a lot with the knife around the house. Chopping and cutting
shaving sticks and hard wood dowels. The edge is still very sharp. I'm going to the wilderness tomorrow. So far this knife has been very good. The Finish continues to wear off but as long as the knife is a good performer It doesn't matter to me.
 
Hey Noss,

Enjoy your trip into the woods! I agree with you on the finish-issue: both the A1 and the A2 are, IMO, knives to be used for what they're made for, and not for looking at. Well, not for looking at in the first place that is... Also aesthetically, these knives are very well designed.

@ Slayer: I agree totally with you that VG 10 holds an edge very well! But it also takes an edge very easily. After the coconut-incident, I had a few dents in the edge of my A2 that were about 0.3 mm deep (yes, I had gone nuts on those nuts:) ). Even though I'm no expert at sharpening, the dents were gone after 10 minutes of stropping on some coarse (220 grit) sandpaper. Great stuff, this VG 10!

Take care everyone!

Gijs
 
jgkort: Thanks, I should have fun with this knife out there.

After hacking on an off all night about 5 2x4s the edge needed a touch up
a few quick passes on my DMT fine. It went back to razor sharp. a little sharper
than out of the box. Looks like some great steel so far. :thumbup:
 
Hey Noss,

Enjoy your trip into the woods! I agree with you on the finish-issue: both the A1 and the A2 are, IMO, knives to be used for what they're made for, and not for looking at. Well, not for looking at in the first place that is... Also aesthetically, these knives are very well designed.

@ Slayer: I agree totally with you that VG 10 holds an edge very well! But it also takes an edge very easily. After the coconut-incident, I had a few dents in the edge of my A2 that were about 0.3 mm deep (yes, I had gone nuts on those nuts:) ). Even though I'm no expert at sharpening, the dents were gone after 10 minutes of stropping on some coarse (220 grit) sandpaper. Great stuff, this VG 10!

Take care everyone!

Gijs

How deos the A2 perform as a stand alone chopper/work knife?I'm debating on getting one but the cost is keeping me from commiting to the buy.All of Fallkniven's knives are beautyful workers and awsome to look at too.I can't say enough good things about them.
 
Hey slayer,

To answer your question: the A2 make an excellent chopper! About 200 pages of phonebook (including the cover) with no real effort, and I'm only halfway resharpening it! This resharpening I also do for making more of a stand-alone all-rounder: I'm giving both the first 1.25" (the tip) and the last 2" of the edge a nice and sharp edge, the recurve I'm trying to keep at a greater angle, so it won't roll too easily when chopping hard.
Initially, I decided on getting an A2 to make it pair with my Hellkniven puuko (4" blade). For a long time, I'd been hesitating between getting an A1 or an A2. After reading a comment by Nemo somewhere, I decided to go for the A2. What he said was something like " it's a big blade, and it'll take some more time getting used to its size, but it has the advantage of more chopping power over the A1". IMO, he had a very good point. I haven't regretted my purchase for one moment! Should you decide on getting one, I'd say you give it a try in shop somewhere, just to know what it feels like. Good luck & keep us informed !

@ Mmmotorcycle: the A1 has a 6" blade, the A2 a full 8".

All the best,

Gijs
 
I arrived back from my trip. The A1 did a fantastic job in the field for it's
smaller size. I was able to do all your basic camp chores just as with a larger knife.

Fallkniven A-1 splitting a log
obj520geo409pg25p9.jpg

obj521geo410pg25p9.jpg


Visitor to my Campsite ( Creepy )
obj519geo408pg25p9.jpg



Fallkniven A-1 used to chisel a square notch.
obj522geo393pg25p9.jpg

obj523geo394pg25p9.jpg


Fallkniven A-1 provided all the cut fire wood I needed.
obj524geo395pg25p9.jpg


A great knife so far.
 
Back
Top