Thanks guys! Your comments are really more than I could have expected, and make me feel a lot better about how they came out.
Mikel 24: To tell you the truth, I found this great tutorial before I made them and it helped tremendously.
I already had in mind to do a design nearly identical to what he does so I just kept his, but you kinda have to figure out at what point to do changes. For instance, I added the firesteel loop, and my belt loops aren't one piece with the sheath like his. I also used an adjustable groover to kinda dig a trench where the stitches will go so when it's finished the stitches lay level with the leather and not on top of it, like his.
I would just check it out and follow his instructions, and then make whatever changes you want from there, like the overal shape, your belt loops, etc. Oh, and yes I wet formed them, but I just used a modified chopstick instead of buying the forming tool.
All the other tools though are a must have, the overstitch wheel (I use 6, but 5 would be just as good if not better), the edger(I used a 3), and the adjustable groover(He doesn't use one, but I find it makes it easier to get the stitching straight, and makes for a nicer finished product).
Another thing I didn't do was die and finish mine like his. I just finished the raw leather with a beeswax/pinesap mixture. If you want more details on the finish let me know.
Anyways, here is the tutorial. Click "Tutorials" then scroll down for the western/pouch style sheath:
http://www.mamut.net/gjknives/