BrownBear said:
Now, if this is a knife just for SD, and for nothing else - get whatever you want within legal boundaries in your area, that feels convenient to you, the only limitation - it should not have a name like "SupperKiller" but have a nice innocent name. All this "what steel is that" thing matters only if you use your knife on a daily basis.
I agree with BrownBear on this. Choosing not to repeat the rest of his statement, as he said it well enough, you don't want something that makes you look like you carried it with intent to kill. Nothing with "Death blade" or crazy 2 inch saw teeth. You want to be able to tell a jury you carry it for work and pulled it in self-defense as a last resort, not look like you were , for lack of a better term, 'asking for it.'
The blade should always be perfectly sharp, because if it’s for SD, you never use it for anything else. This knife shouldn’t be the one you open boxes with, no one should even know you have it.
Another point to think of is you want something with a guard or a choil; something to keep your fingers from slipping onto the blade if your thrust hits a solid object (bone, belt buckle, etc.)
Note that these are the opinions of someone who has never actually used a knife in SD, nor has had any formal training. I have however spoken with people who have, and done informal sparring with them.
Also, some recommended reading:
The Logic of Steel by James LaFond. This deals with the reality of blade and shank encounters, author is not a martial artist, he is a kind of rough character who has studied violence extensively, both first and second hand. A quote illustrating one of the reasons I like him:
“My opinion about the best way to defend against a blade is worth about as much as your opinion. And if your opinion was all you needed to base your self-defense study on, you wouldn’t have bothered to read this book.”
Also,
Street Steel by Michael Janich. This deals with the practicalities and technicalities of knife carry for SD. Can be a little heavy on the ‘author as hero’ bit, but offers another viewpoint with some potentially valid experience.
I am suggesting both of these not as some kind of bibles or such, but as starting places to form your own opinions, and potential places to learn angles on the concept that you may not have thought of. They’re just to get the juices flowin’
Good luck. Hope you never use your blade, and it’s for a damn good reason if you do.
May your juries always be BF members.
