Help for a cheap knife

Joined
Dec 28, 2006
Messages
4,520
Alright, first post, so yay for me! Anyway, would like it to be under $80, shipped. Cheaper gets points, but more options are welcome, and maybe even over for a REALLY good deal. The ones I am currently considering are a benchmade Vex, Byrd Cara Cara, and... maybe, if could get cheap, a TSEK, and I saw (is it good?) a Mccusta (http://www.japaneseknifedirect.com/Page4.html) . Criteria is that
-it is easy to open (had a spydie endura, gen 3, PE; good knife, I found it not easy to open, after using a gerber 3.0 AR.
-G-10 handle. When I got the endura, I was just cheaping out on the 710 I really wanted. If some other material gives similar "grippy" properties at this price, I'm all ears, especially the micarta on the Mccusta I mentioned.
-Nominally, at the very least, good at SD. I know a knife is not for SD, and not primary function, maintenance of one, etc.
-not ridiculously huge. I know, I want a huge blade, and not a big footprint. I like length on a blade, but not huge size, that was my big issue with the endura, it seemed to have a bigger handle than necessary. I disliked that there was at least an inch more handle than blade, and it was very wide in my opinion too.
-if possible, low key appearance.
-Finally, I am willing to consider the double knife option, one small SAK or dodo-ish knife, and one backup for bigger, and hairier (perhaps literally:eek: ) tasks. Again, I would need both to be in the price range already named.
A little about my thoughts: I like the spyderco way of thinking, but I want a knife that can perform without worry, but is mostly tucked away, easy and quick access. Maybe a good way to think about it is that I reacted in a visceral (and good) way to the boker fantasy knife's pen-like clip, or to the cold steel spectre (which is too expensive). Like I said, I don't expect a manix from the knife, but I do know quality.
Finally, to contradict myself: Perhaps the best balance of what I am looking for is a waved endura in g-10. Problem is, it comes in Zytel, and customization costs money. Answer me back, sorry for the long post, ask questions, and I can answer, but may take a few days (hence the name). Thanks for the time,
Zero
 
well, on my G10 Cara Cara, the closed length is 4 7/8", open 8 5/8", and 3 1/8" cutting edge. About 11/16" sticks out of the pocket, tip up only.
 
I second the Cara Cara mentioned. I've put mine through hell and back without ill effect and for only 25 bucks it's the best deal in the industry in my opinion.

mmmotorcycle
 
Alright, first post, so yay for me! Anyway, would like it to be under $80, shipped. Thanks for the time,
Zero

For bang for the buck you can’t beat the Byrds. $25-$30 max delivered.


When I got the endura, I was just cheaping out on the 710 I really wanted
Zero

I do this too, spend 80% of what you really want than buy again, its ALWAYS cheaper to get what you want the first time.


-not ridiculously huge. I know, I want a huge blade, and not a big footprint. I like length on a blade, but not huge size, that was my big issue with the endura, it seemed to have a bigger handle than necessary. I disliked that there was at least an inch more handle than blade, and it was very wide in my opinion too.
Zero

You probably wont like the Cara Cara then, try the Meadowlark. The Byrds are wide but thin when closed. For under 30.00 you can beat the snot out of them.


The Mcusta is beautiful and high end feeling compared to the others mentioned, Smooth operating and a great steel with many scale options and at the top of your price limit. It’s a nice piece. If you want a Mcusta like knife in a aluminum colored handle look at the Browning Ice Storm, On sale for 40.00 maybe less. Not as well finished as a Mcusta from JND but a heck of a deal. Remember to buy what you want the next time or you will be buying again soon. Although that is fun too!
 
I do have to ask though: some of the knives being recommended are aluminum, micarta, or zytel: do they have the same grippiness and awesome feel of g-10? Anyway, I'll probably order a byrd and then wait a little, see how I like it, and then maybe go bigger, but I will probably not order within the next couple hours, so other responses are welcome. Thanks for your help!:)
 
G10 can be grippy or smooth, it depends on the finish used. Not all G10 is grippy.
If you want GRIPPY look at the Kershaw Storms. In your price range for sure.
2 sizes 3.0 & 3.5 blades.

Have fun!
 
-not ridiculously huge. I know, I want a huge blade, and not a big footprint. I like length on a blade, but not huge size, that was my big issue with the endura, it seemed to have a bigger handle than necessary. I disliked that there was at least an inch more handle than blade, and it was very wide in my opinion too.

Virtually all Spydercos (except a few like the Native) have way more handle than blade (and even less usable edge). Take the Delica for example...4.25" closed, quite wide, and blade is only 2.8ish inches with a cutting edge of about 2.5". Most Spydercos are wide because of the hole open. The Byrds are some of the best bang for the buck, especially if you want G10 as you won't find another G10 folder that's as good quality for the price. But it sounds like you want something fairly small, which Spydercos just aren't.

The FRN (it's not zytel) of the Delica, Endura, Native, etc. are quite grippy. Especially the Delica/Endura with the texturing. Blade steel is great. If you're just looking for grippiness, you won't be disappointed by Spyderco's FRN (tho, it feels cheap, but still grippy). Aluminum is more slippery, but some anodized handles feel pretty grippy (tho not as grippy as textured G10 or FRN or Zytel). SS is slippery unless it's textured.

Consider a BM Mini-Grip or Full Grip...under $80, grippy (but cheap feeling) FRN handle, small (much smaller than a Delica in virtually all aspects, including feel in your pocket) but with more cutting edge, and smooth AXIS lock. There are other BMs in your price range.

I also personally like the Camillus line of Blaze and Heat. Handle is a bit thick, but it feels really good in the hand and the Zytel feels a lot better (quality wise) than the FRN on Delicas/Enduras/Natives/etc.

Also, many Kershaws available such as Storm (already mentioned), Leek (G10, S30V available for <$80 shipped), Blur, etc.
 
No buy yet, but been mulling it over for the past couple days, and F3X hit the nail on the head. I need to buy something I won't hate. I get edgy :rolleyes: and angry at myself for cheaping, and I will continuously scan the market to waste more money, so: I am probably going to get a 710. Though, now: where do you guys recommend for shopping? I don't mind lightly used knives, if it makes a big price difference. And last question: I have about medium hands, not huge paws, not small. Is the 710 or the 805 a better buy? I pretty much like those two the best. Thanks all!
 
Go for the 710. It's a great classic knife and you know you like the looks of it.

Check out our Exchange forums for trade or sale opportunities, not that the 710 comes up often. But browse them periodically to get an idea of what's available at what price, for when you're ready to buy something else.

There are many online dealers you can turn to for competitive prices and reliable service.
Here's a few I've been happy with:

www.1sks.com
www.knifeworks.com
www.newgraham.com
www.knifecenter.com
 
All the recommendations are great.To answer your question on the Mcusta,real nice. I visited a link that BladePrince left on another post.Japanese knives a alot of blade for the buck.I am looking at a StoneStep fixed blade from Koji Hara.Otherwise,I have always like Kershaw and Spyderco.I also think if you are willing to to spend another $25-$30,you could look at a Al Mar Mini SERE.Kick butt knife built like a tank.

MPE
 
Japanese knives a alot of blade for the buck. ... Otherwise,I have always like Kershaw and Spyderco. ... ,you could look at a Al Mar Mini SERE.

Kershaw is owned by Kai Cutlery, a Japanese company. Many Spyderco knives and the SERE are also made in Japan.

Yes, you do get a lot of blade for the buck. :)
 
Buy a Browning Ice Storm for $29.99 at CDNN. Actually, buy 2. You will be under your $80 budget. They are outstanding knives for the money.
 
Zero Time,
You should get the 710, or the 520, or the mini-Rukus, or another quality BM. If you opt for a cheaper knife, you're going to be kicking yourself in the butt again and wishing you hadn't.

If you must stay below $80, consider the Griptillian folder with Axis.
Good Luck
 
Get the Vex! You won't be sorry. I can have 'bout any knife, I carry the Vex. The quality is just too good for the price!
 
Welcome to the forum

With all your criteria you narrowed it all down to the byrds and vex

G10 - one hand opening - small - poss. self def. - low key (maybe)

If not ...

Can't go wrong with the humble but super performing opinel.
You can buy a couple at once.
Also Fallkniven u2, friendly loocking and super edge.

Well, if you continue visiting these forums you will certainly end up with a LOT of knives
 
I had one of these a few years back, except with half serrations and black handles. I am really tempted to pick another up now that they are so incredibly cheap. Really holds up well and takes one hell of an edge... I just don't miss trying to deburr that chisle edge!

http://www.knifecenter.com/kc_new/store_detail.html?s=JU2019

ju2019j.jpg
 
I ended up considering what f3x said, and I went above my budget that I said, and got a 710. It's a little heavier and thicker than expected, but that's just cuz I'm used to handling other knives. The g-10 and axis by far make it completely worth it... Every hour or two, I end up going into the bathroom, going right if front of the mirror, and flip it open, admire blade, close, flip... it's a little sick, I know, but man... what a great knife. Thanks for all your help guys, and finally making me splurge to the point that I will be satisfied (at least for a good while- I need a good sharpening system next, but I'm going to wait on that one for while).
Zero
 
Consider the Spyderco Sharpmaker. You can't beat it for ease of learning and simplicity of operation. It will make maintenance a snap, as long as you don't wait till the blade is terminally dull. :)
 
Back
Top