High value fixed blade survival knife

Joined
Dec 31, 2009
Messages
22
Best Value Fixed Blade Survival Knife for $40 or less.

I want to know what your top picks are for a do anything survival knife for a retail price, not suggested retail price, of under $40. My actual budget is higher, but I already have a knife picked out, and this is what is left over.

My next knife purchase is upon me, and much like everything else, I love finding things that punch well above their weight so to speak, be it wine, tech gadgets, firearms, whatever.

I already own a Frosts Mora 780 (love it)

I'm looking at the following seriously:

- Condor Tool & Knife Rodan
- Cold Steel Bushman
- Becker Necker

Are there any others I should consider?

Many many thanks,

GM
 
Buck Nighthawk if you can find one without serrations.I have two ,great knife kinda thick(1/4") they have good ergos holds an edge well and the tips so strong I stabbed mine though a quarter and it didn`t hurt it (when I was younger and slightly dumber).Sheath is junk but I mostly just make new ones for every knife.
 
Good question - I've never read about the Condor nor 1075 steel
Condor Tool & Knife Rodan
# Blade Detail: Plain
# Blade Length (inches): 5.50
# Blade Material: 1075 Carbon Steel, Black
# Carry System: Leather Sheath
# Handle Material: Polypropylene
# Overall Length (inches): 10.50
# Special Features: Lanyard H
 
USAF Pilots Survival Knife. You cant beat the price,good sheath and with a little modding they make a great hard use survival/woods knife. I ground the top guard off and shortened the bottom one. Convexed the edge and took the blade coating off. Strapped some fire goodies on it with a 550 cord wrap. It rides in my BOB now.--KV
 
Nice knife and very durable. Excellent high carbon steel, with a nice coating. The single piece construction is great! And for the price, you can't beat it. (FYI, I have a new one I'm interested in trading, if you're interested:) )
 
jimh0220,

Re: Trade
My collection thus far is rather small, <10 knives. All of which I use and really like, so I'm not interested in trading yet. But thanks for the offer!

Re: Bushman
I've read very positive reviews of the bushman, all except the handle. But then I've seen people para-cord wrap their handles very nicely. Nothing says survival than a no fuss knife that has an extra 15' of cordage should you need it.

kvaughn,
Do you mean the Ontario SP-2? That's a nice looking knife! 1095 steel, too! That's my favorite non-stainless non-super steel. I've seen a D2 knife chip while batoning so it's not quite as tough as I'd like and I haven't tried A2 yet. I'm strongly leaning to that knife now, thanks!

thebrain,
I looked at those, but on the financial model that I built on excel for my life gives me exactly $40 to work with after my other "hobby" purchases for the month. I can't find them for lower than $44.

Any other gems I should be aware of?

Thanks for the replies so far!
 
I would have to say after getting mine yesterday, yup, just yesterday.

A condor Golok. just under $40.
 
I'm one of those that has wrapped the handle. Much nicer to hold with the cord instead of the bare metal.
 
Id throw in a vote for the rodan i dont think ive heard a negative thing about them. good knife great price.
 
Over your price range but for 75$ consider the Spyderco Aqua Salt.

It's very light, comes with a great (Rather than "usable") sheath, is 100% rust proof, the steel is damn tough and will sharpen up quickly, comfortable and secure handle and a useful blade shape. It will handle everything short of chopping (Holds up to chopping just not nearly enough mass for it to be useful as a chopper).
 
rodan and bushman were the first 2 names that came to mind when i saw the thread title.
 
Just bought a couple Schrade Extreme Survival SCHF9 knives.

$38 each and solid as heck. Really nice blade for the money.
 
I had today off, and I spent most of it considering which knife would be the very best survival knife. I'm fortunate unough to have a lot of knives collected over many years. Even in hand, it's tough to choose. Theres so much to consider, and good arguments on all sides. I guess it comes down to a personal choice based on each persons skill level, geographic location, and expectations. I tested a Becker BK-2, and I found it to be a very solid knife, but an inch too short for my big hands for batoning. In my section of the Northwoods, I expect to be able to limb pine trees for shelter, pry up rocks for a fire ring and reflector, cut poles, clean fish, cut rope, shave tinder, and carve snare pieces. There are wolves and mountain lions where I hunt, and I feel better with a larger blade, even though it may not really help me in that scenario. In the woods, I now carry a vintage 10" Western W-36 in a cord-wrapped sheath, a nearly weightless 10" retractable Fiscars saw, a Victorinox Classic, and a Leatherman Supertool. Overkill? Time will tell.
 
If you are considering a Becker Necker, then you might also look at an Izula. You said you like knives that "punch above their weight". Can't think of a better example than the Izula.
 
i like the bushman, i put a a 15" wooden handle on mine, more leverage, longer reach.
 
Review I wrote for the Bushman:

Best all-around knife for the money, October 21, 2010
By Brace Negron "Brazilla" (New York, New York)

This review is from: Cold Steel Bushman Black SK-5 Steel Cordura Survival Sheath (Sports)
Title says it all: this is the best all-around knife I've ever seen. I have 400 dollar custom knives, hand forged, etc so I speak from experience of using high performance knives. This is all the knife you'll ever need for 90% of your outdoor applications and it even fulfills some unusual ones too.

This knife was made to use and the balance of price, materials, durability, size shape etc make it an everything knife; it's even a very sweet thrower. It comes out of the box with an excellent edge that, if you are so inclined, can make razor sharp. I tend to keep field knives just under razor sharp as I don't want to roll the edge under heavy use. Bought two of these knives and have beat the hell out of them, from heavy amounts of throwing with occasionally missing and hitting cinder blocks, to chopping, whittling this knife keeps bouncing back. The steel is extremely tough and the temper making it springy so the knife doesn't break; at worst the edge will roll and even when the edge around the tip suffered serious damage getting slammed into a cinder block numerous times, it took ten minutes with a bastard file to re-shape and then re-sharpen it. 5 min more with my ceramic stone and it was razor sharp again. The fact that it is a one piece knife (thus very strong AND chef grade), can be mounted on a spear pole, has excellent belly, good weight for chopping, can store goodies in the handle as well as in the sheath, can take 100s of throws and is razor sharp, makes this knife the last word as a survival knife.

For those with such an inclination: it stabs well too. I tested it against wood and my hand didnt slip onto the blade, but you DO have to really grip it. One hint if u might have to stab with it: get some thick leather cord or paracord, thread it thru the hole and make a very short layard, just wide enough for your pinky and ring finger to slip thru and i guarantee u won't slip on the blade after a heavy thrust into a tough object. It isn't a combat knife so if that is what you are looking for head to Ka-bar land and find a knife there.

BTW: usue ballistol. Seems to lock in well with the finish on this knife and ballistol goes with the "do everything" attitude this knife has. Look ballistol up if you don't know what I am talking about: the stuff literally has dozens of uses as well as being an excellent oil for knives.

The sheath is good. Nice little pocket for mini flint and steel, a small Swiss army knife, mini flashlight, a mini lighter and small sharpening stone. I would say if Cold Steel came up with a bomb-proof rock-solid leather sheath WITH a small pouch like the nylon version of the sheath, this would be the perfect knife/sheath combo.

Get this knife: best deal in the knife world. trust me. The only other knives that rival it in price and quality for what you are paying are the Mora knives and that is saying something for those in the know.
 
Best Value Fixed Blade Survival Knife for $40 or less.
...
I'm looking at the following seriously:

- Condor Tool & Knife Rodan
- Cold Steel Bushman
- Becker Necker

Are there any others I should consider?

I'd take either the Becker Necker (BK11) or the Eskabar (BK14) - whichever is more comfortable for you. Both outstanding.

---

Beckerhead #42
 
Back
Top