Joe - Part of that stability comes from it being bolted to the ground.

I recently moved shop and had it sitting loose. I tried to do some forging that way, and it just was bouncing around too much to really get much done. I wouldn't expect to be able to run any mechanical power hammer that wasn't secured to the ground. I have seen some self-contained hammers that were transported to blacksmithing demonstrations that did fine sitting on the ground loose, but mechanical hammers tend to have rotating parts that rock things back and forth.
I wouldn't figure any part of the hammer as part of the anvil weight that wasn't directly under the anvil. The heavier the baseplate you use, the better it'll run. I have 1.5" plate on mine, and it was flexing until I added a couple more anchor points in front of the anvil to tie it to the slab. Nice and solid now.
Check out the Power Hammer page over at Anvilfire.com and the hammer subforum at Iforgeiron.com. Great resources. There's a fellow who goes by Ptree (Jeff Rheinhart) whose rendition of the Rusty design was very helpful when I was in the planning phase of mine. He's at both sites and his hammer is one of the ones displayed on the Anvilfire.com page.
Will5211 - Was this a Rusty that you built, or one that you took over from someone else and modified? I haven't run a Spencer-style hammer, but I have used a 50 lb. Little Giant a fair amount. The Little Giant hits faster, but is harder to control and hits a lot softer (of course mine has a heavier ram weight, but initially it was 88 lbs and not 100 and that was still the case). It's also a lot less adjustable.
I wouldn't say the Rusty is comparable to a treadle hammer. I can get single strikes out of mine, but it's not the easiest thing to do. I'm forging up to about 2" square with it, sometimes more complex shapes than a blade. It's built with blacksmithing in mind, with the capability of using tooling, but I end up forging blades the most.
I haven't heard anything bad about the Spencer hammers, but I don't think that they necessarily outperform the Rusty design. Each has its strengths and each has its weaknesses. I really like and take advantage of the flexibility of Gunnhilda in working with different tooling and adjustability, and she does just dandy drawing out. She hits at two or three beats a second.
JAWilder - If you're looking for portability, you might look at variations on the Depew hammer. It uses the acceleration part of F=ma to get a lot of work out of a small ram weight. Like 10 lbs or less.
One version built from junk is the lamentably late Grant Sarver's Original Junkyard Hammer.
[video=youtube;-tPTLwmxsWc]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tPTLwmxsWc&feature=related[/video]
I like the idea of using the crankshaft as your eccentric, but I think that using the piston as the linkage complicated things unnecessarily. It'd make more sense to me to turn the crankshaft 90 degrees and then link directly from the crankshaft to the spring. A tire clutch would probably add better control, too. The results that they got out of this hammer is still quite impressive, and would be right dandy with the right dies for forging knives.