I too would personally loathe to sell something like that, but we're all different in many ways. I'm not sure if I'm buying that one though, I feel his father would have at least indicated in some way as to the value of the knife at some point....who knows though ? I'm not in a position to say anything either way.
Exactly. I'm doubting the father hand-me-down bit too, which is all the more reason to snatch the deal up. Let's face it, if the knife is stolen, chances of the original owner getting it back are slim. Much slimmer than the guy selling it to someone else who has no clue what the knife is worth. Either way, the guy is gonna sell the knife to someone. Now, if the knife really did belong to his dad, then he deserves to get ripped just for selling it in the first place.
For me, if my dad gave me a knife he had used for 15 years, I don't care if it was a $10 Winchester or a $1000 custom, I'm not gonna be selling it, simply because of sentimental value. This guy is obviously/apparently just trying to turn a quick buck on cheap knives he either bought or acquired. I would have gladly relieved him of that Sebenza for $25. I probably would have even been nice enough to give him an appraisal after I received it. The OP shot himself in the foot by trying to be the "good guy" and inform him that his knife was worth a good bit more than he wanted.
I wonder, if he were to go to a garage sale and find some potentially very valuable antique, relic, whatever, for a ridiculously low price, would he offer up the true value to the person selling? Not me. If you're selling something, you had every opportunity to find out the value first. If you weren't motivated enough to properly value an item when the resources were available to you, well, your loss is my gain... We're not talking about someone who said, make an offer, and the OP seeing the Sebbie and offering $25, we're talking about someone who put the price on the knife, obviously having no clue what it was.