if you have a metal lathe find a steel supplier and get steel round stock, Turning aluminum sucks. Let me revise that, doing anything with aluminum other than spinning or casting sucks, it gums up tools, bonds itself to the surface of cutters, tears, it's just nasty unpleasant stuff, I did aluminum fab for 6 months and hate the stuff. Steel turns nicely, finishes cleanly, and if you use apropriate feeds and cutters will make nice strong wheels that will hold their shape and not fly apart. your mileage may vary, but if I have to turn any metal steel is my first choice (caveat, I have a 5 horsepower 15"x 52" leblond lathe)
-Page