If it's possible . . .

[joeradza]

For a long time it was a GEC stag 73 but then I started collecting Schrade wire jacks. The simplicity yet strength makes them the ideal knife for me. The clip point is in such beautiful condition for its age that it’s in consideration but the large spear point is clearly the winner.

 

[Steven65]

For me the Case 92 and 75 pattern Stockman's are my favourite aesthetically.

 

[Bigfattyt]

My "favorite" was a Queen Gunboat. Full reprofile of the primary grind into a zone zero edge. I also had to squeeze the bolsters and peen the pins to take out gaps, and firm up wiggle.



But the spring on the coping blade broke.....so it is not carried currently.

 

[waverave]

Someone once challenged me to list my top 10 favorite albums of all time. I thought it would be relatively easy. I came up with 50 in no time and couldn't decide on the top 10...it was impossible. I can't imagine picking just one.
Same thing here...I can't pick just one Top 10 traditional knives is the best I can do

The 2019 BF 86 is up there though.

 

[redsparrow]

After thinking today long and hard about my possible choices, all I can say is,
yesterday, my favorite brand was Case. Specifically the Texas Jack...

...today, it's the Waynorth Black Jack.

Tomorrow who knows ???!!!

I do have more GEC 15s and 74s then any other models if that's any indication,
but if I'm expected to work this hard very often... I'm gonna be needing a raise.

sparerow​

 

[Old Hunter]

Pleasant evening in Bogue NC, sitting in a rocking chair listening to a local gospel group and thinking about your question. I own at least twelve brands (mostly vintage, some current) of quality pocketknives. I only own one representative of my favorite; this Fight’nRooster Premium Stockman has been my favorite since acquiring it years ago (and I’ve never even carried it!). It’s the most perfect knife I own and it gives me joy just to look at it and work the blades. OH

 

[black mamba]

James, I assume you chose the Blackjack after some in-depth "reflection."

Bruce, that Rooster has always been a favorite of mine as well.

 

[HEMI 49]

If I had one knife from my traditional collection it would be a Maserin Plow..... It's affordable ($50), very well made, nicely sized, laser sharp (D2), and does everything I want a traditional knife to do.....

If I were a whittler, or other specific user, I might choose differently..... But the Plow checks off many of the boxes on my list.

 

[Markeologist]

Yea

For me it is GEC. This is for a number of reasons. Their knives developed my enthusiasm for traditional slip joint knives. The obvious quality. Additionally, their creativity beyond cover materials makes collecting fun. I also like their use of model names I.e “beer scout” “calf roper” etc go beyond the traditional “sleeve board” “serpentine” etc.
That said I cannot pick a favorite knife, but I do have a favorite pattern seen below.
View attachment 1567253

yeah, can’t argue against a GEC 15, though a 48 or 77 is nice too...anything from Mr CC floats my boat.

 

[Old Engineer]

Well Jeff black mamba , as I understand it , you asked what is our favorite knife if we have 6 different brands . I easily have more than 6 different brands and you know my Favorite Knife is one of my GEC 73s in Stag .


Harry

 

[Jon0385]

Yea

yeah, can’t argue against a GEC 15, though a 48 or 77 is nice too...anything from Mr CC floats my boat.View attachment 1567870

I’m lucky to even have one CC knife. That’s quite an amazing assortment of knives you have for sure. Those would be too nice for me to want to use.

 

[Will Power]

No it's not!

BUT if somebody were pointing a gun (Traditional Wheelgun/or Lever of course ) at me and demanded an answer...then this might push its way into my hand.

But then, all the Stockman, Laguioles, single blades, Penknife types et al. left behind ... Coercion is never right

 

[Old Hunter]

Will Power - Here Will, per your order, a levergun and a wheel gun (with a selection of knives) to help you choose! OH
Ps. You already did fine!
Pps. All the knives shown are favorites, just not my “most favorite”.

 

[mcc850]

Well Jeff black mamba , as I understand it , you asked what is our favorite knife if we have 6 different brands . I easily have more than 6 different brands and you know my Favorite Knife is one of my GEC 73s in Stag .


Harry

Easy to see why this would be your favorite. Really doesn't get any better than that!

 

[Old Hunter]

Bruce, that Rooster has always been a favorite of mine as well.

Thanks Jeff! Appreciate that coming from a fellow traveler on the Stockman path.

 

[Un-Chained]

Old Hunter
What a shot Bruce... mesmerizing

Will Power
That is a wonderful piece isn’t it

 

[Chief]

GEC 15 single blade clips. Small enough yet large enough. Most pinchable GEC 15 blade style. More comfortable to use than multiblade slipjoints as there is no secondary tang to cut into your grip. Rounded edges don't tear up your pockets. GEC executes this pattern well.

SS versions have slightly more pull, wonderful walk and talk.

 

[Un-Chained]

Chief
Thanks for the dizzy spell John

 

[euroken]

GEC 15 single blade clips. Small enough yet large enough. Most pinchable GEC 15 blade style. More comfortable to use than multiblade slipjoints as there is no secondary tang to cut into your grip. Rounded edges don't tear up your pockets. GEC executes this pattern well.

SS versions have slightly more pull, wonderful walk and talk.

So that's where they all went

 

[Old Hunter]

What a shot Bruce... mesmerizing

Thank you sir!