- Joined
- May 16, 2010
- Messages
- 9,347
On the right knife, choils absolutely rock.
On other knives, not so much.
This works for me (YMMV):
On other knives, not so much.
This works for me (YMMV):
I dont agree.Finger choils are a waste of blade real estate.
If the handle doesn't give satisfactory holding options, then the handle is a bad design.
JMHO
Check out post #27.So, my opinion on finger choils stems from the fact that I consider the end of the cutting edge to be the end of blade. I prefer handles that go right to the end of the cutting edge (lower guards, and sharpening choils/notches are acceptable, as long as they aren't crazy).
So how I see it, a finger choil is this awkward middle ground where the edge has already ended, but the handle is still ~0.5-2in away, and you end up holding half handle, half bare steel. Hence my personal viewpoint on them.
Out of curiosity, those that prefer finger choils, do you believe/find that you'd prefer the finger choil to a handle that ended at the same place as a finger choil? I mean, in my mind (and personal experience) it seems that a full girth handle is/would be easier to control for fine work, and more secure for powerful cuts. But clearly others have different preferences, and I'm curious about it.
Check out post #27.
Not neccesarily referring to the above quote/forum member but I have a hunch, that many posters in this thread have folders in mind, when they judge choils.
IMO there ia s a big difference between choils on a small to medium folder and that of a heavy duty/camp fixed blade.
Caveat: Perfectly willing to admit, that I may be barking up the wong tree.
I usually don't prefer prefer a choil on a knife but after seeing GooberBoober `s photo of his Junglas , a choil on a large fixed blade seems like a nice addition , it gives you the option to use a large knife for finer cutting tasks