Just saw this.....Bark River is no more?

Status
Not open for further replies.
V-1 said:
So Jim Sterwart, the Production and Operations Manager, claims he did not know what was going on with the Chinese blade blank fraud in his shop? The shop that he manages the operation of and production in. That shop. OK, yeah right, sure he didn't, he was blissfully unaware.

The lack of honesty and integrity with the Stewart's is unreal.
Click to expand...
Actually he has admitted to knowing, but then went on to say that his father had the final say in those business decisions and they were just following his orders. And then further justified it claiming they did it to keep the business afloat, and he has a family with 5 kids to support, blah blah blah. The problem is, there’s so much more to the story leading up to them being in that financial position at all that he also had to be a contributing part of going back many years. So I take this as just so much horseshit.
 
So is there going to be a go to source if we want to send in a knife for verification?

If my Bravo 1 is really 3V then I'll still enjoy it but if it's 8cr or whatever then it will join the beater knife pile.
 
somber said:
At 19:00 you can watch him testing both knives with the XRF.

Don’t use your ears, use your eyes and literally watch it happen 😆
Click to expand...
Those are two Bark River knives. And the compositions shown on the screen are totally different than what he reported in the AI readout. For example, it says tungsten was not detected, the element you asked about before.
 
Sadly the cost to verify your BRK knife steel will exceed the value of the knife (with shipping costs and charge for steel testing). Bark River’s are what they are to whom ever owns or buys one. The unsavory reputation is now set in stone.
 
Larrin said:
Those are two Bark River knives. And the compositions shown on the screen are totally different than what he reported in the AI readout. For example, it says tungsten was not detected, the element you asked about before.
Click to expand...
After reading this, I went back and watched again and you're right. Tungsten is shown in the "Not Detected" category for both readings. I've asked the author if he's cross-checked the screen-shown amounts against the Excel file he got from the tech, as something is fishy there.
 
chevyrulez1 said:
Most of this thread has focused on the ethics surrounding BR and others, but there is another aspect of all this that I want to mention. The root cause of all of this mischief was that the company got in financial trouble. This goes back to comments I have made in other threads about the sustainability of the current knife market, pricing, etc. Sounds like to me (regardless of the unethical way they handled it) the law of supply and demand caught up with them and Bark River's business model failed.
I am afraid there are going to be more knife makers falling by the wayside soon due to economic factors. As fuel and everything else gets more expensive, I suspect many of these "premium" companies are going to find their revenues suffering as demand for premium/luxury knives will start to decline.
People only have so much money, and sometimes they have to make hard decisions about how they are going to spend it. I personally have never purchased a Bark River knife because I couldn't justify the price for what I was getting. Apparently I was not the only one.
Click to expand...
I strongly disagree. Chicken or the egg? I believe the root cause of the business failure is his financial wrong doing and his unethical business practices not the market going sour on him. If he had run the business in an ethical manner he wouldn’t have the problems that caused all this mayhem in the first place.

As you can see just in this thread, he has a long history of sketchy dealings.
 
StuntDouble said:
The depressing thing isn’t that it’s happened, it’s that I’m seeing people actually justify what he did and continue to support him.
Click to expand...
It's been that way the entire time, before this whole debacle broke public, bringing up what Mike Stewart had done to Brian or the steels being "mislabeled" would illicit fans to come out the woodwork to defend him aggressively. They don't even want you bringing it up at all. Like it's a myth an we're slandering a legend.

This is an epic I told you so, but one that I don't get any joy in, it's sad it went on for as long as it did, that Mike was able to stay open as long as he did, that all the people he screwed over through the decades just slinked away without recourse, that all the other things we won't go into depth were taking place. Because people kept supporting him from dealers to fans who he could do no wrong in their eyes.
 
toker said:
"Each one of us, to a man, to a woman, I can say with absolute certainty, have also done things that are inconsistent with character."

I've never seen his videos before, but I'm positive that I won't be watching any of his other videos.
Click to expand...
Same. Could only watch a few minutes, skipping here and there. Not gonna watch a gotdang crybaby rooting for a shyster.
 
Mitchell Knives said:
I'd normally be shocked at this kind of revelation, but he has a history of scamming people going back at least 2 decades.

It's amazing the levels of dishonesty people will stoop to.
Click to expand...
Agree, I remember even back probably around 2006 how sketchy mike and his company was. I never got near the things since finding out. This isn’t a shock to me, and really shouldn’t be for anyone else who was paying attention.
 
jlauffer said:
Check post #838...he says he knew.
Click to expand...

Danny Linguini said:
Actually he has admitted to knowing, but then went on to say that his father had the final say in those business decisions and they were just following his orders. And then further justified it claiming they did it to keep the business afloat, and he has a family with 5 kids to support, blah blah blah. The problem is, there’s so much more to the story leading up to them being in that financial position at all that he also had to be a contributing part of going back many years. So I take this as just so much horseshit.
Click to expand...
Wow. That's just as bad or worse.
Thank you both for the clarification.
 
Last edited:
somber somber

Do you happen to know *IF* and to what extent Jaquie was involved in this?...or had she left?
 
FoxholeAtheist said:
After reading this, I went back and watched again and you're right. Tungsten is shown in the "Not Detected" category for both readings. I've asked the author if he's cross-checked the screen-shown amounts against the Excel file he got from the tech, as something is fishy there.
Click to expand...
Or if the AI misread or hallucinated its own values.
 
Danny Linguini said:
From his perspective as a long time friend, I can understand his sentiments and desire to continue to support him, though he’s being quite selective in what he’s choosing to support and conveniently ignoring a LOT. But just a couple of qualifying thoughts on that: #1, I’d be a little more judicious in picking my friends to begin with; and #2, if a close friend of mine escaped my judicious eye and found themself in similarly deep doodoo, I admit I’d probably go on quietly supporting them, but I certainly wouldn’t be quite so public about it. However, I’m pretty sure I’d start keeping my distance at the first sign of such serious character flaws and never get to this point.
Click to expand...

I don't understand this take. As a close friend, or even a family member, your responsibility is even greater to hold them to account. I do not care who you are, whether you are a brother, a close friend, a professional partner; if you are engaged in immoral and unethical behavior, I am 100% going to be calling you out on it and will not be supporting you, quietly or otherwise.

To cite an example (not knife related so my apologies): One of my best friends had a tumultuous relationship with his then wife. The pressure got to him and he stepped out on her. I called him out on it and dressed him down pretty good. We didn't speak for a long, long time. I acknowledged that the relationship with his partner was unhealthy but there is a right way and wrong way to go about addressing such things. He chose the wrong way and I didn't mince words.

The point being, just because you are friends or family with someone who is out of line, it doesn't warrant tossing your integrity aside when it's inconvenient and uncomfortable. Hold them accountable until they change their ways for the better.
 
WedgeAntilles said:
And this is part of the reason I'm such a fan of Chris Reeve Knives. Despite all the complaining about availability online, they've taken a carefully measured approach to growth, fully aware of the ebbs and flows of this industry and the economy at large.

Unscrupulous people do unscrupulous things. It's why those that saw Mike Stewart lacking scruples weren't surprised when this happened. Quite often, people show you their propensity for douchebaggery long before they get caught.
Click to expand...
I've read that Chris Reeves is the reason why Mike Stewart never went to Blade or other Knife/Outdoor shows. Stewart screwed over Chris Reeves like he's screwed over many other Knife Makers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top