Just got my KA-BAR / John Ek Commando knife today. Within five minutes I'm sold. The knife, the blade, the handle, guard ... even the sheath, all are awesome. This is definitely a 21st century evolution of a World War II classic.
I'm no expert, but I am experienced and have an lifelong appreciation for nice knives. Among my double edged blades, I've an old Fairbairn Sykes, a 1970s Gerber Mk I and a Mk II, plus the Boker version of the V-42. I've even got an Effingham Ek Model 5 (cord wrapped version). This new collaboration may not be as elegant as the F-B Sykes or the V-42 or look as pretty as the Model 5, but it has a style all its own. It's not polished like the old Model 5, but the black finish and etched John Ek signature, iconic Ek symbol and "commando knife" logo are subtle and classy.
The blade's grind and edge geometry -- in 1095 Cro-Van -- lend it to stabbing and slashing. The F-B and V-42 are not known for their slashing abilities. The edge of my EK44 easily shaved my arm clean. The blade is so stout, I wager you could even chop a 2x4 with it. The tip looks strong enough to stab into a 2x4 and pry away. Once I get past the newness of the knife and mix it up, I'll let you know.
The handle's ergos are versatile and feel great in hand; the full tang evokes confidence. Some will complain about the "S" shaped guard. Get over it. Instead, appreciate the smooth fit and finish of the glass filled nylon scales and lack of burrs or rough edges where they shouldn't be. How many knives do you own that you've had to go over the handles with sandpaper so you don't get blisters or abrasions? Yes, the handle is a little long, but after playing with it I realize the added length adds to its versatility; the singular handle design geometry allows for tight, close to the guard grip, middle or long distance.
The pommel is classic Ek. In this case a solid protrusion of 1095 Cro-Van. You can crush skulls, jaws, pound nails, pry and otherwise amuse yourself with it.
The sheath is near perfect. It holds the knife tight, there's no rattle, movement or anything. There are plenty of grommets suitable for lashing and stashing. The back of the belt loops features a small label with the John Ek / Commando Knife logo. Again, subtle and classy.
Releasing the knife from the sheath took me a moment to figure out. In addition to a retention strap around the handle, it's got a snap lock feature near the mouth of the sheath that grabs the guard. Pulling straight up, it's difficult to near impossible to release the knife. HINT: Pull the handle slightly AWAY from the belt loop as you pull out the knife and "snick!" it works! Or if that confuses you, pull the belt loop away from the knife as you pull and it works. Either way.
I have two complaints about the sheath. First is the retention strap snap. My example is so loose as to be worthless. If this was the sole retention devise it would be worst than useless because you might be tricked into depending on it. As it is, the sheath locks in the knife at the guard, so that's not really an issue. Still, if I keep the knife -- and I think I will -- I'll replace the snap with one of greater quality. Probably a Pull-The-Dot.
Second is the belt loop: what if you don't wanna carry your cool new commando knife on the belt? What if you want molle? What if you wanna carry it inside your waist band? That could be a problem, considering the unique release mechanism. A little judicious filing/sanding of the locking bumps might be in order, as would be a little surgery on the belt loop interface. Best suggestion: Invest in quality kydex. I predict if this blade takes off -- and it should! -- there will be a lot of creative kydex available.
Overall, I'm a fan. I'm pretty picky after all these years of buying, trading, collecting and using my blades. I've been on the lookout for a good double edged knife for some time and this fits the bill. Sharp, stout, good blade material and geometry, ergonomic and great handle design ... it's worth my time and money.
I know, no pics, no fun. I'll post a couple when I get the chance.
Have fun and be safe.