Karambit Maybe it's a bad choice for cold weather climate

The question seems about moot to me. Whoever it is that would be wearing such clothing would probably shoot you or have several friends along for a beatdown. Maybe I'm giving the criminals too much credit, but I don't expect them to try and cut you when they're wearing those kinds of layered and cumbersome clothes. Any knife is going to be inferior to their numbers/weapons.
 
Originally posted by hardheart
The question seems about moot to me. Whoever it is that would be wearing such clothing would probably shoot you or have several friends along for a beatdown. Maybe I'm giving the criminals too much credit, but I don't expect them to try and cut you when they're wearing those kinds of layered and cumbersome clothes. Any knife is going to be inferior to their numbers/weapons.

True.

A handgun(for those with a CCW) would be your best defense against an armed attacker. But there's always that chance of a firing pin breaking. Then your down to your blade. At that point it's fight don't expect mercy from a mercyless attacker.

The Karambit is one the most popular knives right now. In thumbing through the knife magazines at Books-a-Million I've never seen it mentioned about it's performance piercing through heavy winter clothing. Looking at the blade design it can cut ugly wounds against open skin. The knife was developed in a country with a tropical climate. Thing is for the next few month there will be less open skin. People will bundle up including those of the criminal element.

Looking at the knife design that could be a weakness. I any weapon I employ SWAT. Strenghts Weaknesses Attributes and Threats. Be sure you look at the tool in the environment it will be carried.


Training techniques that would work for Summer may not work for Winter time. Think of how the Martial Arts evolved in China. In the northern colder part forms were developed around people having to wear heavy coats. In the southern tropical part they centered around keeping good footing in wet conditions.

Same with blades.

Annoying

Tourist comments made no reference to my subject. "First off, You'll never be in a knife fight." What's up with that? He must have called Jean Dixon or that Jamacian lady. He needs to make a list of the 99.999% of the people on this board that will never need their blades. Their "tactical" knives will be much safer at home in a safe.

West Side Story = Gay

And yes I'm old enough to remember that old Jim Croce song, "You don't tug on Superman's cape, you don't spit into the wind, ya don't pull the mask off the ole Lone Ranger, and you don't mess around with Jim."
 
Originally posted by Boink
The REAL question is, what knife would increase my reading comprehension?
Repeat after me, A-T-S 3-4
A-U-S 8-A K-E-R-S-H-A-W G-E-R-B-E-R K-N-I-V-E-S
WOW :eek: I feel smarter already.
 
Karambit folders for the most part have around a two inch blade and would technically be consider legal even under the most draconian knife laws. Is this partly fueling the popularity?

Maybe.

Are Karambits becoming popular simply because of the Knife Laws in the U.S. ?

Maybe.

There are people who make knives that advocate a 9mm Glock instead of a knife. There are people who regard folders to be "broken" and not worthy to use in a fight. There are people who build concept knives that build on the fact that it can be used closed or open depending on the situation.

Everyone has an opinion and try to explain why but you only want to fight. At least that´s what it seems like to me. Don´t buy a Kerambit, Karambit, whatever if it doesn´t suit your way of fighting.

Have a nice evening :)

/Colinz
 
The kerambit creates a zipper of a wound immediatley upon contact and has great penetrating abilities.

I've used the folding Tarani models for a few months now, having reviewed both for the website earlier this year.

I have bought the tapes from Steve Tarani as well. Understand how it is used in it's original configuration [ straight blade ], and understand how it should be used in folder guise.

Past experience with knives and practical experience from using the folding kerambits has shown me that I can use the knife as Steve Tarani explains in the video sets; train specifically to that blades historically correct set of movements as he demonstrates and trains others; or what I have come to understand for me, that I can use the knife like any other conventional folding knife [ or straight blade ] with few exceptions. The one most obvious is that the tip is not aligned in this blade configuration to be of much use in a conventional #5, 6, 7, stab position using a conventioal saber grip.

That leaves the rest of the 12 lines I know to attack/defend with the kerambit for me in sabre grip. The 1-4 lines all use a slashing motion, as well, the 8-12. Thats quite a few lines to be able to move on with such a knife. The point here is only that the knife will work well with 75% of the 12 lines I have available to me to defend/attack on.

Here is where I found it got interesting while handling these in drills and ipsc targets hung in the garage, a few with old sweatshirts over them. In the 1-4 lines, a conventional knife will be slicing through whatever it touches. The edge does all the work, the tip useless at this point.

With the Tarani kerambit, these same lines of attack will show the tip penetrates/stabs into the target first, as it is naturally aligned to do. Upon entry, [ keep in mind this move is the same as a conventional folder on saber grip on the 1-4 lines ] the inside sharpened edge slices through the target as an ordinary folder would be.

The advantage that the kerambit enjoys at this point is the tip is continuously penetrating, being pushed by the line of attack ever point forward while the edge is slicing. This will continue until the tip runs out of, say a forearm, or wrist or you retract the attacking arm which then allows the blade to slice out of the target.

These lines of attack with the kerambit produce zippers. The only question that remains when the blade makes contact is how deep you can intially sink the tip into the target before it continues on the line. The zipper can be minor and only skin deep or up to 2 1/8 " of penetration on the Tarani models, all on the 1-4 normal lines of attack/defend.

Big heavy clothes on bangers and the effectiveness or lack thereof of the kerambit design--my thoughts

My normal knives in 1-4 lines may get 2-4 inches into a torso, or perhaps the range was such I got skin layers only. If the folder is 4" in blade length, I'm likely to get the first couple inches on average if I make contact.

The wound will be a clean slash, having sliced everything in it's path, seperating muscle, tissue,tendons and creating a good amount of damage.

The kerambits wound will be different for the same range/distance if the depth of penetration remained the same. It will be different as it will have ripped through with the point leading the edge all the way, tearing and then the edge following to slice.

I think they can be more effective in saber grip than a conventional knife given the same circumstances during slashing lines. It gives up the normal stabbing lines but I have also found that you can adapt your lines to stab to the midsection.

I'm not going to consider that in my training regimen with the kerambit however. I'm going to concentrate on it's strengths. With 75% of the available lines I have, I believe it is at least as effective on heavy clothing. The tip will sink in as far as you can get it on the slashing lines. That may be more than the conventional knives get in as they are "riding" the material as they are slicing. It may even be found that the harder the material is to penetrate, the better the kerambit will outperform the conventional folder.

The bowie knife is most effective and at it's most devastating when the backcut technique is used. The tip then leads the inside edge [ the swedge ] through the target, ripping out material and causing better disabling wounds.

Now look at the kerambit and the swedged tip of a bowie knife, see the similiarities? Same principles are being applied with the same exceptional results.


I am not going to get into the reverse retracted grip of the kerambit here now.

One more mention, then I'll let you folks go. Through all of the above mentioned, remember that the kerambit is being held in a clenched fist whose pinky finger through the ring. It will be harder to have the knife knocked from your hand in a struggle.

I've seen enough knives fly across the floor to know that retention is always an issue. The kerambit excels over conventional folders where retention is concerned.

So you don't need specific training to use the kerambit, I prefer the above which is based on years of blade training conventionally and will become proficient with them through training with Steve in their intended historical usage when he gets up my way.

Hope that at least answers part of the original question anyway.

Brownie
 
Originally posted by Cross_Steel2
Enlighten us oh Massad Ayoob wanna be.

You wish to be enlightened? Okay, two "enlightenments" for you, Number One, take the chip off your shoulder, you'll feel much lighter. Number Two, stop acting like a spoiled little prick and actually listen to what your betters tell you, you will learn much from this, grasshopper.
Actually, third free piece of enlightenment, he who have head up ass cannot see or hear good, will not learn much.

Have a lovely day :)
 
You talkin' to me? You talkin' to me? You talkin' to me? Then who the hell else are you talkin' to? You talkin' to me? Well I'm the only one here. Who do you think you're talking to? Oh yeah? Huh? O.K.
 
Thank you for your explanation Brownie. I think I’m starting to get idea behind the Karambit. :)









:eek:
 
These are some interesting posts, though it seems a bit too bad that there've been so many side tracks by people (more than one) either missing the original query, or taking things waaay too seriously.

Anyhow, I'll throw in my opinion, which is ONLY that until I get into a tangle with an over-dressed gang-banger. In my training, and in the couple of altercations I've found myself wrapped up in (neither of them knife fights, thankfully), I've always preferred tight, clinched in-fighting. Also, I might want to mention that if said alleged gang banger were steppin' to you, Snoop, they'd be extending themselves...and the hands and wrists are under-armored relative to the rest of his gear. The kerambit (or however you spell the damned thing) might be great in this situation, because you could tangle and tear into his wrists very quickly and easily, and if you think fast and follow through with this sudden shift in advantage, you could continue with a lot of damage to the groin, forehead, face, and neck...or you could use the opportunity to get the hell out of there, whichever is more appropriate in the given situation.

That said, I can't rightly deny the initial supposition of this thread -- if 'squared off' with someone wearing 3 or 4 inches of padding, even if that padding isn't particularly heavy-duty, the kerambit might not be the best option...then again, no small-bladed knife would seem ideal in such a situation, irrelevant of its configuration. Conversely, as the West Side Story guy tried to illustrate, how many times do you really 'square off' with anyone anymore? There aren't many people who would be a threat to one's life in American culture who would respect the code of the duel, anyhow.

Besides, I don't know how to say, "If your blade be as sharp as your tongue, varlet, I'd gladly meet you at dawn, behind the courtyard at St. Katherine's," in Ebonics.
 
threads like these make me laugh. sometimes i'm embarrassed that i share this hobby with some people.

the best thing to do is to continue contributing to this thread because that means more time is spent in front of the computer in the safety of your own home, which equates to less time out in the 'hood.

on a semi-serious note, no one has mentioned that the attacker's mobility will be greatly hindered with all that clothing.
 
You're absolutely right, s.c., that Kenny guy from South Park is always wearing that thick parka, and look how he always ends up.
 
Originally posted by brownie0486
The kerambit creates a zipper of a wound immediatley upon contact and has great penetrating abilities.

I've used the folding Tarani models for a few months now, having reviewed both for the website earlier this year.

I have bought the tapes from Steve Tarani as well. Understand how it is used in it's original configuration [ straight blade ], and understand how it should be used in folder guise.

Past experience with knives and practical experience from using the folding kerambits has shown me that I can use the knife as Steve Tarani explains in the video sets; train specifically to that blades historically correct set of movements as he demonstrates and trains others; or what I have come to understand for me, that I can use the knife like any other conventional folding knife [ or straight blade ] with few exceptions. The one most obvious is that the tip is not aligned in this blade configuration to be of much use in a conventional #5, 6, 7, stab position using a conventioal saber grip.

That leaves the rest of the 12 lines I know to attack/defend with the kerambit for me in sabre grip. The 1-4 lines all use a slashing motion, as well, the 8-12. Thats quite a few lines to be able to move on with such a knife. The point here is only that the knife will work well with 75% of the 12 lines I have available to me to defend/attack on.

Here is where I found it got interesting while handling these in drills and ipsc targets hung in the garage, a few with old sweatshirts over them. In the 1-4 lines, a conventional knife will be slicing through whatever it touches. The edge does all the work, the tip useless at this point.

With the Tarani kerambit, these same lines of attack will show the tip penetrates/stabs into the target first, as it is naturally aligned to do. Upon entry, [ keep in mind this move is the same as a conventional folder on saber grip on the 1-4 lines ] the inside sharpened edge slices through the target as an ordinary folder would be.

The advantage that the kerambit enjoys at this point is the tip is continuously penetrating, being pushed by the line of attack ever point forward while the edge is slicing. This will continue until the tip runs out of, say a forearm, or wrist or you retract the attacking arm which then allows the blade to slice out of the target.

These lines of attack with the kerambit produce zippers. The only question that remains when the blade makes contact is how deep you can intially sink the tip into the target before it continues on the line. The zipper can be minor and only skin deep or up to 2 1/8 " of penetration on the Tarani models, all on the 1-4 normal lines of attack/defend.

Big heavy clothes on bangers and the effectiveness or lack thereof of the kerambit design--my thoughts

My normal knives in 1-4 lines may get 2-4 inches into a torso, or perhaps the range was such I got skin layers only. If the folder is 4" in blade length, I'm likely to get the first couple inches on average if I make contact.

The wound will be a clean slash, having sliced everything in it's path, seperating muscle, tissue,tendons and creating a good amount of damage.

The kerambits wound will be different for the same range/distance if the depth of penetration remained the same. It will be different as it will have ripped through with the point leading the edge all the way, tearing and then the edge following to slice.

I think they can be more effective in saber grip than a conventional knife given the same circumstances during slashing lines. It gives up the normal stabbing lines but I have also found that you can adapt your lines to stab to the midsection.

I'm not going to consider that in my training regimen with the kerambit however. I'm going to concentrate on it's strengths. With 75% of the available lines I have, I believe it is at least as effective on heavy clothing. The tip will sink in as far as you can get it on the slashing lines. That may be more than the conventional knives get in as they are "riding" the material as they are slicing. It may even be found that the harder the material is to penetrate, the better the kerambit will outperform the conventional folder.

The bowie knife is most effective and at it's most devastating when the backcut technique is used. The tip then leads the inside edge [ the swedge ] through the target, ripping out material and causing better disabling wounds.

Now look at the kerambit and the swedged tip of a bowie knife, see the similiarities? Same principles are being applied with the same exceptional results.


I am not going to get into the reverse retracted grip of the kerambit here now.

One more mention, then I'll let you folks go. Through all of the above mentioned, remember that the kerambit is being held in a clenched fist whose pinky finger through the ring. It will be harder to have the knife knocked from your hand in a struggle.

I've seen enough knives fly across the floor to know that retention is always an issue. The kerambit excels over conventional folders where retention is concerned.

So you don't need specific training to use the kerambit, I prefer the above which is based on years of blade training conventionally and will become proficient with them through training with Steve in their intended historical usage when he gets up my way.

Hope that at least answers part of the original question anyway.

Brownie

NOW THAT'S SOME GOOD STUFF!!!! THANK YOU!!!!
 
Originally posted by satin
You wish to be enlightened? Okay, two "enlightenments" for you, Number One, take the chip off your shoulder, you'll feel much lighter. Number Two, stop acting like a spoiled little prick and actually listen to what your betters tell you, you will learn much from this, grasshopper.
Actually, third free piece of enlightenment, he who have head up ass cannot see or hear good, will not learn much.

Have a lovely day :)

Your opinion really doesn't matter to me. If Tourist has something to take up with me I'm sure he's capable of doing it. I know that you and Phil were always appointed by your Elementary School teachers to write down names on the board and that affected you for life.

Besides that Tourist comments go against everthing on www.themartialist.com. You wouldn't want to put Phil out of a job would you?
 
Originally posted by s.c.
on a semi-serious note, no one has mentioned that the attacker's mobility will be greatly hindered with all that clothing.

I've watched kids play basketball with all that stuff on and it doesn't seem to hinder their mobility.
 
ok, at the risk of bringing myself onto the line of fire, if it's so cold out, wouldn't you be wearing gloves? My fingers barely fir through ernies' kerambit now, let alone with winter gloves on..--Joe
 
Back
Top