Kershaw Storm II

Quiet Storm said:
What's the deal with everyone's disdain for steel liners?

Sure, titanium liners are lightweight and can be anodized, but steel is more abrasion-resistant, ain't it? Correct me if I'm wrong.
So from a functional viewpoint, I just don't see why ti would be preferable in liners.

I feel the same on this issue. I have 2 Storms, 1 '04 and 1 '05 (black) and I love these knives. I noticed on my Buck/Mayo the Ti lock bar had started to "round" where it rubs the tang. Not a problem mind you, but my steel lock bars don't show near as much wear even on older knives. I kinda like 50% contact on the tang, leaves room for wear.
 
tungsten said:
Doesn't Ti keep the tension better than steel?

It probably does, but all that does is facilitate building a ti-linered folder (compared to a model with steel liners).
Or have you ever had a liner/frame lock fail because the lock bar lost its tension?
IMO the most common reason for these locks to fail is abrasion on top of the bar - and steel liners are more abrasion-resistant (AFAIK).
 
[snip] Lockup is the key to crosslock stability, not crosslock thickness, as best I can tell. Clearly crosslocks have bowed for others before, but I don't know which knives....definitely not the ones I've used.

Furthermore, what's the problem with lock wear? My M16 has worn through to the other side and...it's still tougher than most my knives' locks...It engages and disengages better than new (really). I was concerned with it getting trapped inbetween the tang and handle, so I figured I'd go ahead and find out if that was going to happen in a worst case scenario by trying to pry it over with a flat head screwdriver. Noting that I didn't go full out with the flathead (because I think that's just ridiculously unlikely), it wouldn't go all the way over. The ball bearing just doesn't give it enough space.

However, an m16 owner repeating my tests had previously lost the ball bearing from the crosslock and he was able to jam it inbetween the tang and the handle. But the result was complete seizing of the blade--not catastrophic lock failure. He had to take his knife apart to fix it, but again, it would not close on his hand. [snip]


Problem is, many people just look at possibility, not probability. They think up all kinds of scenarios to scare the hell out of themselves.
 
Back
Top