I got the last one (at the store) on a gift card. There were tons of the Gerber sets, a two-pack of Buck classic designs, and SOG Magnadots left. My opinions are pretty much what they were before, but I've had a few days to use the items this time...
The Knife: The Brawler is good. Not great. Not poor. I took it apart and tried to remove the black finish, and leave a polished satin finish. Not a good idea. It looks horribly scratched up and used now, but that's fine for an inexpensive user. That coating really doesn't want to come off! The blade centering is bad in mine; it rubs the non-locking liner just after the edge goes in. I tried all of the tried-and-true blade centering techniques, even replacing the bushings, but it didn't work. I find the pocket clip too stiff, and it has a rough run of FRN underneath it. With some sandpaper it's fine, but out of the box, it's a pain to get out of your pocket. There's no lanyard hole. The thumb studs act as the blade stop pins, but they're useless (for me) as an opening method. The linerlock has no jimping on it, and I noticed that with my larger hands, my thumb slides down sometimes when unlocking. The blade came sharp and I like the shape. It's easy to resharpen. There's no blade play in any direction. Would I buy the Brawler by itself for the $20 this pack was? No. When I think of good (or better) $20 knives, I think of Kabar Doziers, Byrds, Kershaw Chill, and Bucklite Max.
The Flashlight: It's the $2 Harbor Freight flashlight, but with thicker metal. Nine 5mm white LEDs in a showerhead fromation. I'm guessing about 25 lumens total on fresh batteries. It runs on three AAA batteries in a carrier, and three no-name alkalines are included. Single-mode reverse clicky switch. A simple lanyard is attached. Honestly, it's your run-of-the-mill cheap flashlight. It's fine for a glove box, car trunk, or toolbox. My daughter uses it when she walks the dog at night poo-searching.
The Pen: This one is both good and bad. Why bad? Well, I thought there was a way to get the actual pen insert back into the body when not in use. Click it or twist it, or put a cap on it. Nope. It's either in there or it isn't. This is fine I guess, but I'm wondering how much gunk and lint will clog up the pen when put in a pocket or bag. Also, changing the ink refill can be tricky. do it wrong, and you'll have two halves of the pen that just slide together. Sithus1966 gave a great tip with this:
"Sithus1966: The easy fix to this is to unscrew the end with the clip and push the threaded insert that is inside back down where it belongs. Actually push it all the way out and put the ink cartridge back in and screw the insert to the end of the pen, then push the whole thing back together. Then screw the clip end back in."
The knurling is good, but too aggressive for casual writing. This is a tactical pen, so write with it only when you think you might have to shank somebody with it. I guess. The knurling shreds pockets, so I used a medium grit sharpening stone to make a smooth, flat portion. Then the clip will sit on it, and you can tighten the cap down to keep the clip's position. The pen writes in black ink and will take a few common refills. The ink in mine is fine; it's not chunky or uneven. I don't know what else to say about a tactical pen. It works. It writes, and it feels tough. That's all I can ask of it.
So, is the set worth $20? Yes. It's a good gift or stocking stuffer, and almost any knife person will appreciate it.