How about one of these for the absolute novice that freqent this section but have nothing more than a file, hacksaw, hand drill and wet & Dry?
We could stipulate the material as
File
Any hardwood from Home Depot
Etc
Anyone interested that is too scared to enter this one?
We could post questions to help with HT or one of the smiths here could say 'make this' and we could send it in. Once the blades have been judged, the makers names will be thrown in a hat and you get the guys knife that came out after your name.
This way, its cheap, there is little shame and you get to judge in your own mind how well you have done after receiving one of your peers blades.