Kleen Kanteen/Cold Steel Shovel

Joined
Aug 26, 2006
Messages
3,799
the Kleen Kanteen:
i had wanted one of these stainless bottles since i saw them a while ago...the idea of having a water container that you can also use to boil water in really appeals to me for some reason. when i saw Kevin E using his 27 oz one at WAR in the fall i wanted one even more...

on the 20th i finally ordered one for myself, but i was told that they were out, so i had to reorder a couple of days later from a different store. i got it on the day after christmas, and was impressed. mine is the 40 oz (1182 ml) version. i wanted the larger capacity, because i feel like less than 1 litre isn't quite enough for me in a single bottle.

i filled it up and took a drink out of it, and i liked it.

the major things that seperate this from other bottles i've seen:
-the mouth is narrower than a nalgene, but bigger than a standard disposable bottle. this makes it easier to drink out of in a car (or at all!) but still allows easy access for icecubes or pouring drink mixes into it.
-the cap goes inside the neck of the bottle, instead of outside. this means that you won't get a dribble from the threads like a nalgene or other similar bottles.
-it is stainless steel! you can stick it in the fire and boil water in it, then dust it off and toss it in the pack.

i took it out back for a little fire the other day, to boil some water in it and make some cocoa the hard way. how would i handle it without burning myself though? :confused: this had me confused for a minute, but i figured out a pretty good solution...

i used some 20 guage steel wire and made a slipknot out of it with a loop in the end, that i slip over the neck of the bottle. it hangs onto the rolled lip of the opening, allowing me to manuever it nicely in and out of the fire with the help of a stick.

i also took it on an overnighter with me last night, and it was nice to just stick the bottle in the fire to boil it, then cap it and take it into my blanket with me to keep my feet cozy. the pine pitch got stuck to the side, but i scraped most of it off with a stick and put up with the rest.

this morning when it was time for cocoa, i just put the bottle back on the fire, and then directed the stream of boiling water into my cup to mix with some chocolately goodness :thumbup::D

overall i'm pleased with this bottle, i think it will work well for my various adventures. i really like the slightly narrow neck and the way the cap works, both make this bottle easier to drink out of and open (a stick can be put through the loop cap to apply enough leverage to break apart any ice that forms in cold weather). the narrowed neck also makes it more efficient for boiling water, by trapping more heat inside the bottle than a guyot style bottle.

i'm glad i bought this bottle, and i'm glad i went for the larger size. i also like that it is the same diameter as a standard nalgene, because it allows me to use regular water bottle pouches and carriers, as well as various nesting cups if i feel the need.

some pics:
IMG_1126.jpg


IMG_1128.jpg


IMG_1160.jpg


cocoa!!!
IMG_1127.jpg


the Cold Steel shovel:
like the KK, this has also appealed to me for some reason since i first saw them a few years ago. there was always other gear that i wanted more though, or i convinced myself that i really have no use for one...

well, i finally decided to go ahead and buy one, and it came a couple days ago.

first impressions were that it is a little smaller than i expected, and the "utility edge" that it comes with is laughable as far as cutting anything goes. the handle is large, good for a strong grip. the varnish is a bit slick in the cold and wet.

i took it out back with me to make cocoa. i split some wood with it, but it doesn't really work that great. the curve of the blade that makes it a good shovel makes it akward to use as a splitting or chopping tool.

it came in handy for moving coals around, and for supporting the base of my KK while i poured my water into the bowl.

i also dug a small hole, perfect for a cat hole :barf: through the frozen top layer of soil and into the softer but gravel mixed soil. it worked pretty well, especially for the size. it digs far better than a trowel, but at a weight penalty when it comes time to pack them.

it also fans the fire pretty well, which was neat.

i took it on the overnighter with me, along with my 19" wetterlings. i actually used the shovel more than the wetterlings! :eek: i used the shovel to smash the lower limbs off of pine trees, which it worked well for. i also used it to create weak spots on the green branches to snap them off more easily. it also pounded stakes nicely, including the longer support pole for Andrew's tarp.

overall, a pretty cool tool that i think would be most at home in a longer term camp where you might need to dig out a latrine pit or small runoff ditches around a shelter or tent. it could also be handy for stealth camping, to dig deeper fire pits or other construction projects.
 
Last edited:
i don't know how often i'm going to be using this shovel, but its a pretty cool tool and i'm glad i bought it.

some pics:
IMG_1125.jpg


IMG_1129.jpg


IMG_1124.jpg


it stayed right at the foot of my tarp, ready for action whenever i needed it
IMG_1151.jpg
 
Nice review. I find I use the CS shovel a fair bit for cat holes, etc... Not optimal for chopping but it can in a pinch. I took a file to one edge of mine to improve it's cutting abilities and that helped some. I always keep one in my car during winter travel.
 
i just cleaned up the kleen kanteen with something like watered down oven cleaner...its looking much spiffier now. i'm not sure if the etching wearing off is a factor of the solvent in the cleaner or of the heat from the fire...

IMG_1173.jpg
 
I bought my Brother a KK for Christmas. Now I'm going to have to go out and by myself one.
 
Thanks for the review Simon.

I think that your "snare" for the bottle is pretty darn cool!

I honestly have 2 40oz KK's, just like yours. I really wanted a Guyot when they were unobtainable, so I figured I would settle for these until then. But now, I think I actually prefer them.

I take mine in the woods with me every time I go. I have two because I use them all day, every day as well. I fill one up in the morning, use it all day long, and it sits on my night stand at night (can you tell I drink a lot of water?). The next morning I wash it and stick it in the drying rack and grab the other for the day.

Now that Guyot's are available, I saw one in the store, and decided not to buy it. It seems the lid "leash" is no longer removable. That, and the combination that there is plastic permanently fixed to the bottle, made me think that boiling in it would (or just plain heating) be a much bigger pain in the butt. I like the simpler idea of nothing but stainless.

So far, it has worked great for me to.

I put a GSI stainless cup on the bottom of mine, and it takes up no more space than the bottle alone. I can use the cup for boiling too, but it is nice to have two containers for the woods.

That shovel looks pretty cool too.

Thanks again for the review.
B
 
Are you sure about that???
I think the new ones just don't have that small allen head screw on the orange plastic slip part......the string is snug now and you just have to pull it apart.

No, I am not. Thanks for clearing that up. I pulled it on it, but it didn't seem to go anywhere, so I just might not have play with it enough. Thanks for pointing it out. I will have to check them out again.

B
 
No, I am not. Thanks for clearing that up. I pulled it on it, but it didn't seem to go anywhere, so I just might not have play with it enough. Thanks for pointing it out. I will have to check them out again.

B

Cool....it takes a little effort and a small tool to pry in there would help also! :D Hold the string against the lid to keep it from slipping then pry at the orange piece with your fingernail.
I always thought that allen head screw was probably a weak part and apparently they did too! :thumbup:
 
What kind of provision does the CS shovel have for carrying? Does it have belt loops on a sheath? ALICE/ MOLLE loops?
 
I think it looks better a little smutted up :) I've tried using an Oilcamp cup on my KK, it's so snug that it is a SOB to get off. Same cup fits perfect on the Guyot or standard Nalgene. Do the GSIs have a slightly larger inside diameter? Estela had a post somewhere on making paracord carriers for water bottles, I made one that works perfect with the KK.
 
Cool review Siggy. I've got that shovel, and its a sweet ass camp tool. Chops good enough for camp duty.

I'm liking my guyot bottle. Remember, to improve cleanability after fire cooking, coat the outside of the vessel with soap before putting it in the fire. The soot'll clean right off.
 
Back
Top