Knife recommendation for Utah Work Crew

I too live in Utah. I just don't see how the view a folding knife carried in a backpack, is somehow more acceptable than a fixed blade carried in a backpack.

However, I certainly don't claim to be omniscient. It's just that I would most definitely go fixed blade if possible; and I'm hoping the OP was misinformed somewhere along the way, so he can go fixed blade.

Either way, lots of great recommendations for folding knives so far.

I’m a little skeptical of a group being led into wilderness without carrying fixed blades as well. I assume they are a far left (read: mainstream) group to whom the sight of a fixed blade would be offensive. I think the op wants something to carry in the pocket, though, not the backpack. I assume fixed blades would be available at camp, though, for food prep and kindling. I wonder what they will be using to remove unwanted vegetation though, and if they will respect the rights of the trees.
 
Last edited:
Thanks - yes I meant Vantage Force Pro - glad you reminded me, I corrected my post.

Buck vantage pro (larger blade) would be closer to $60. Unless you mean the vantage pro force. I have 2 of the vantage pro 347, both had problems with washer, which is easy fix, so I paid $40 for 1and $50 for the other. I don’t have a force pro, but I really dig their open season folders in s30v.
 
I'm confused as to why you think fixed blades are banned?

https://www.akti.org/state-knife-laws/utah/
My program bans them. The only blades they allow are pocket knives. Now, I don't know what constitutes a pocket knife but to me it means a folding knife that can be put in a pocket. Otherwise I'd definitely bring a fixed blade.

I forgot to tell you guys- I already own a CS Recon 1 (AUS 8 version) and a Spyderco PM2. A lot of you guys recommended me those two and I think that either of those options would be good, and that I honestly am just looking for an excuse to buy another knife.
 
My program bans them. The only blades they allow are pocket knives. Now, I don't know what constitutes a pocket knife but to me it means a folding knife that can be put in a pocket. Otherwise I'd definitely bring a fixed blade.

I forgot to tell you guys- I already own a CS Recon 1 (AUS 8 version) and a Spyderco PM2. A lot of you guys recommended me those two and I think that either of those options would be good, and that I honestly am just looking for an excuse to buy another knife.

Careful using it in front of the group leaders. Their idea of a pocketknife might be a non-locking Swiss Army knife! Imagine a situation where they asked you to hand over your $150 folder because it frightens them!
 
I have to say if they won’t allow a fixed blade then a Cold Steel of some sort woth a Triad lock is probably the best alternative.

With that said maybe you could bring a smaller foxed blade like an esee izula or something? Are they paying you to help out or is it voulenteer work?

If it is voulenteer I would politely bring a small fixed blade and tell them “this was all I could afford.” Not to be insulting but what kind of person going into the woods would say “no fixed blades”

That is like saying bow drill fire stating only, lighters and matches are only for arsonists.
 
That's some true talk right there. I do find it kind of strange that they only allow pocket knives for multiple week long back country jobs. I'm going to be working as part of Americorp but am also considering bringing a small fixed blade like a BK11 and stowing it in my backpack as a backup.
 
Op wanted quick one handed opening

He could get a "quick-draw" belt sheath for it. Love mine. Drawing from the sheath opens the knife, then with practice, the knife is closed and put back in the sheath with one hand as well.

Personally I prefer the 112; it just feels like a handier size for most chores for me. My choice would be a 112 with s30V blade and Walnut scales ($96.50 direct from Buck) and a quick sheath (mine was $40); just within the OP's budget. Nothing wrong with the 110 though, if the extra size doesn't bother you.

Either way, anything goes wrong with that knife, Buck'll fix it. I have my dad's 112 that's over 40 years old (and has seen some hard use). It's on its second blade; he had to have it replaced when it snapped while we were using it as an emergency tire bead lever in the middle of nowhere, before the days of cell phones (I know you're all rolling your eyes at us treating a good knife that way, but it got us home in an emergency, which is the most you can ask of any tool). Told Buck we voided the warranty and would pay for the repairs. They still fixed it up like new for free.

The only caveat I can come up with is that neither one is a knife that's comfortable to carry in a pocket. If OP absolutely doesn't want it on his belt, or if his organization will get scared by a leather pouch, then it might not be the best option.
 
I have to say if they won’t allow a fixed blade then a Cold Steel of some sort woth a Triad lock is probably the best alternative.

With that said maybe you could bring a smaller foxed blade like an esee izula or something? Are they paying you to help out or is it voulenteer work?

If it is voulenteer I would politely bring a small fixed blade and tell them “this was all I could afford.” Not to be insulting but what kind of person going into the woods would say “no fixed blades”

That is like saying bow drill fire stating only, lighters and matches are only for arsonists.


I like lapedog’s thinking, it could be a chance to turn on some influential non-knife people into opponents of the belief that “knives kill people,”; for example, nobody else is able to prepare the fire or the food because they have only brought saks. You become the hero, and change the minds of people who may one day be in a position to say to someone “banning fixed blade knives is just stupid.”
 
He could get a "quick-draw" belt sheath for it. Love mine. Drawing from the sheath opens the knife, then with practice, the knife is closed and put back in the sheath with one hand as well.

Personally I prefer the 112; it just feels like a handier size for most chores for me. My choice would be a 112 with s30V blade and Walnut scales ($96.50 direct from Buck) and a quick sheath (mine was $40); just within the OP's budget. Nothing wrong with the 110 though, if the extra size doesn't bother you.

Either way, anything goes wrong with that knife, Buck'll fix it. I have my dad's 112 that's over 40 years old (and has seen some hard use). It's on its second blade; he had to have it replaced when it snapped while we were using it as an emergency tire bead lever in the middle of nowhere, before the days of cell phones (I know you're all rolling your eyes at us treating a good knife that way, but it got us home in an emergency, which is the most you can ask of any tool). Told Buck we voided the warranty and would pay for the repairs. They still fixed it up like new for free.

The only caveat I can come up with is that neither one is a knife that's comfortable to carry in a pocket. If OP absolutely doesn't want it on his belt, or if his organization will get scared by a leather pouch, then it might not be the best option.

Have you tried the open season folder in s30v? I love mine, and the leather sheath horizontal belt carry option is awesome! I heard there were qc problems, but mine were fantastic, ntm good looking. It opens one-handed and has a removable pocket clip. I like the idea of the 112 in s30v with a quick draw sheath. Will look into getting one for myself!
 
Maybe I'm the minority here ... but just from the work you described and the area ... I cannot understand why in the world they would not allow fixed blades ... a folder of any kind won't come close to performing the work you described ...

it must be one more misguided and unrealistic rules someone sat at home up all night to solve an issue that's not an issue.
 
Hey folks,
I'm going to be in a conservation work crew in Utah this summer for about 12 weeks. I will mainly be doing trail maintenance, construction, and invasive species removal in the backcountry.

I'm looking for a folding knife to carry in my pocket, as fixed blades are banned. The blade should be at least 3.25 inches and the locking system robust. It should also be able to be opened quickly with one hand and provide a good grip. Bonus points if it is made in America!

Hoping that you guys could help me. Thanks!
Spyderco Manix 2 back lock (or CBBL lock is okay) as the spine is thicker and the lock strong. It is linerless G10, also. Very rugged.
 
When I spotted the opening post, the first thing that crossed my mind was Cold Steel. So, I guess I would have to suggest my favorite CS knife, the American Lawman.
 
I sure wouldn’t want to work with a crew that doesn’t allow fixed blades to be used at work. Fixed blades are much more safer than folding knives.
 
You didn't specify price.
Quick to open, exactly 3.25", excellent quality.
ZT 0450
 
I suppose there's always a mora companion too. If they give you crap you could leave it behind. If you get one of the "non-tactical" colors you may be able to convince them it's a tool... because it is. It's also a god option all-around for a medium-small fixed blade that carries very light.
 
Lots of good suggestions here. I would pick a ZT 350, or better yet if you need a larger blade and can find it still on closeout the ZT909.
 
Have you tried the open season folder in s30v? I love mine, and the leather sheath horizontal belt carry option is awesome! I heard there were qc problems, but mine were fantastic, ntm good looking. It opens one-handed and has a removable pocket clip. I like the idea of the 112 in s30v with a quick draw sheath. Will look into getting one for myself!

Here's the one I have:
https://www.etsy.com/listing/260173...ick-draw-knife-sheath?ref=shop_home_active_18

It's very well-made. There's a video on his page demonstrating how it works. If you don't want it to automatically open for whatever reason, it works perfectly well as a normal horizontal sheath too.

Hadn't seen the Open Season yet, but it looks like a nice knife!
 
Back
Top