Knifehunter is One of the Good Guys

RedbeAR15

RedbeAR15

Platinum Plucker
Feedback: +40 / =0 / -0
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
6,092
I have purchased two great knives from the man and both transactions were flawless. I received all the details before the purchase was finalized, great communication, and prompt shipping

I would not hesitate to purchase from him again :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:
 
This is a very timely thread considering the other one that is in regard to Knife Hunter that is on this forum right now. Could you please give a time line as to when these deals happened? Thanks.

Edit: Sorry, it appears that this is two different members. The similar names had me confused.
 
Keith Montgomery said:
This is a very timely thread considering the other one that is in regard to Knife Hunter that is on this forum right now. Could you please give a time line as to when these deals happened? Thanks.
Click to expand...


I received a black AK47 from the man a little over a week ago. This was the second knife I purchased from KH.


And it IS the same guy
 
Keith, no offense but you should delete the original text from your post and leave the Edit portion only. Your post here was inappropriate.
 
PorcupineMtns66 said:
Keith, no offense but you should delete the original text from your post and leave the Edit portion only. Your post here was inappropriate.
Click to expand...

dobywon said:
I agree 100%!!!
Click to expand...

How in the world is it inappropriate? Redbear verified that it is the same guy and there are certainly current issues, whether his fault or not, with several of his deals here. Ultimately, the purpose of the GB&U forum is to get such issues resolved or at least allow potential buyers to make their decisions for themselves and with as much information as can be provided.
 
roughedges said:
How in the world is it inappropriate? Redbear verified that it is the same guy and there are certainly current issues, whether his fault or not, with several of his deals here. Ultimately, the purpose of the GB&U forum is to get such issues resolved or at least allow potential buyers to make their decisions for themselves and with as much information as can be provided.
Click to expand...

It's inappropriate because this is RedbeAR15's thread for a thumbs up.
You posted in another thread about someone which is your right to do but don't hijack other threads.
 
PorcupineMtns66 said:
It's inappropriate because this is RedbeAR15's thread for a thumbs up.
You posted in another thread about someone which is your right to do but don't hijack other threads.
Click to expand...

I did not post in another thread, at least not about this particular "someone". Nor did I hijack this one.

I would have stayed out of it altogether had I not seen posts accusing Keith Montgomery of inappropriate behavior. Quite frankly, that assertion is absurd and, in my opinion, does more damage to "someone" and "someone else's" credibility than actually serving any useful purpose. Redbear had his say about his positive experience and then, as is rather standard in this forum in such situations, someone else came along and made mention of other, non-positive, experiences. From these things, and the other threads involving Knife Hunter's transactions, potential buyers will make their decisions.

It happens often here. Or should knife hunter get a pass, or be treated differently than anyone else in similar unfortunate circumstance, because he is your friend?
 
Last edited:
The post I made here is the truth -

If either of my transactions with KH had been any different, then my post would be also.

Read into it what you may. It is what it is.

You can PM or email me if you have any specific questions and I will gladly answer those.
 
I don't concern myself with others deals and have remained neutral in my post other than to voice my opinion concerning a post here. I don't see anyones credibility damaged.
There was a thread, it is now closed without anyone seeing the end result. By closing it before the final result, the intentions of the person who started it draw suspicion in my mind. Maybe I'm right, maybe I'm wrong, just my thoughts.

Don't spill that mess into this one. Open your own thread.

I don't see Knifehunter as needing a pass. He sold a clearly used blade. The tip looks intact in the photo's. He offered a refund. A big deal was made by supposedly mature folks.
I buy online often and know that when you return merchandise, your refund comes after the items is received. It's pretty much an accross the internet policy.

You insinuated my intentions here are because Knifehunter is a friend. He is a BF friend and I trust him. I have 4-5 positive purchases in his feedback and 4-5 outside the forum. Never had an issue. I know if there was an issue, he would make it right.
Some of the posts about him speak volumes about the folks that posted them. Credibility is a two way street. Lets all act like adults.
 
PorcupineMtns66 said:
It's inappropriate because this is RedbeAR15's thread for a thumbs up.
You posted in another thread about someone which is your right to do but don't hijack other threads.
Click to expand...

Is it the case, per the rules of this subforum, that when someone starts a positive thread about a member, no one can post anything contrary to that opinion? I must admit I have not read every letter of the rules, so this could very well be the case, but it seems very unlikely to me. Am I wrong?
 
Gentlemen,

I appreciate the kind words and understand the others as well.

I am currently writing responses. It has wasted my entire day but that is fine because we are going to get to the bottom of it all.

My feedback stands for itself. I believe I have more recorded, not including those that arent, than all of my accussers feedbacks combined together.

So, you shall have it all soon.

Very soon.
 
I have no "dog in this fight," so to speak, but would it not stand to reason that both positive and negative comments would be warranted (provided they were stated in a civil fashion) if the intent of this forum is to provide feedback on members' fulfillment of trades and purchases?
 
Sharp Phil said:
I have no "dog in this fight," so to speak, but would it not stand to reason that both positive and negative comments would be warranted (provided they were stated in a civil fashion) if the intent of this forum is to provide feedback on members' fulfillment of trades and purchases?
Click to expand...

Sounds like a question for one of the MOD 's
 
PorcupineMtns66 said:
I don't see Knifehunter as needing a pass. He sold a clearly used blade. The tip looks intact in the photo's. He offered a refund. A big deal was made by supposedly mature folks.
I buy online often and know that when you return merchandise, your refund comes after the items is received. It's pretty much an accross the internet policy.

You insinuated my intentions here are because Knifehunter is a friend. He is a BF friend and I trust him. I have 4-5 positive purchases in his feedback and 4-5 outside the forum. Never had an issue. I know if there was an issue, he would make it right.
Some of the posts about him speak volumes about the folks that posted them. Credibility is a two way street. Lets all act like adults.
Click to expand...

It's hardly insinuation when its said point blank and bluntly. :D As well, your experience with knife hunter, as posted above, will also serve people in making their decisions- as it should be. But, since I first joined this forum, in GB&U people have posted positive experiences in negative threads and negative in postive and this, I think, is how it should be. I make no assumptions about whether anyone is at fault or guilty of underhanded behavior in their transactions but GB&U is a place for issues to be aired publicly and, hopefully, reasonably resolved. So, when someone comes along and wants someone to censor for content in GB&U... well, I think that looks as bad as the example you gave about banditi closing the thread prematurely.


All that being said, I agree with you about the proper protocol for a refund but, in this circumstance, I would be happy to have it in the hands of a mutually trusted 3rd party before sending the money back. And lastly, I wouldn't do a deal with any of the parties directly involved. Not KH, not DOL, not banditti. Not because I decided that any one of them, or all of them, were in the wrong in their transactions or are dishonest or anything like that. In fact, I doubt that this is so for any of them. I just think that all three of them conducted themselves here like babies and life is too short to have to deal with crap like that.
 
RedbeAR15 said:
Sounds like a question for one of the MOD 's
Click to expand...

I agree RedbeAR15.

I originally posted because I saw someone lock his own thread before a resolution. The "overflow" of that locked thread came here. Your thread didn't deserve that regardless of this subforums theme.

The second person to post insinuated that your praise was coincidental to another post. He did not bother to investigate and see that you just made a purchase from him. He then edited it to state it was directed at the wrong person. That makes no sense which is why I posted here.

Here is his text;
"This is a very timely thread considering the other one that is in regard to Knife Hunter that is on this forum right now. Could you please give a time line as to when these deals happened? Thanks.

Edit: Sorry, it appears that this is two different members. The similar names had me confused."

I don't think asking him to further edit his post was unfair.
To everyone other than this threads starter and KH, this is all I have to say on this matter. Show some maturity and integrity and think before you:foot:.
 
PorcupineMtns66 said:
The second person to post insinuated that your praise was coincidental to another post. He did not bother to investigate and see that you just made a purchase from him. He then edited it to state it was directed at the wrong person. That makes no sense which is why I posted here.

Here is his text;
"This is a very timely thread considering the other one that is in regard to Knife Hunter that is on this forum right now. Could you please give a time line as to when these deals happened? Thanks.

Edit: Sorry, it appears that this is two different members. The similar names had me confused."

I don't think asking him to further edit his post was unfair.
To everyone other than this threads starter and KH, this is all I have to say on this matter. Show some maturity and integrity and think before you:foot:.
Click to expand...

I know you don't have anything else to say on the matter but c'mon... once again, this time on Keith Montgomery's part, there is no insinuation involved. He very plainly stated, without drawing any conclusion (you may have inferred one but that does not mean that Keith made one or made anything other than a neutral statement), that this is a timely thread and then went on to ask for more information. All of which is SOP for GB&U.

As for maturity, as far as I'm concerned, the only people showing signs of lacking in that are the 3 that I mentioned in my last post. Although I must admit to some curiousity as to who it is that you are insinuating is lacking in integrity and maturity. :cool:
 
I have read this thread, as well as Keiths comments. Keith made it very clear that he confused the two members. End of discussion.

Only problem I see here is a few of you acting like little kids on the playground.

Cool it, and move on.
 
I've dealt with Trevor several times, never had a problem.

As far as others on this site trying to "assassinate" ones character, my question is why Paul, if you had such a problem with Trevor, did you wait as long as you did to post something? Why is this the second time that you run someones name through the mud.....(GRAVELFACE)?
This time you ran with Banditti, last time you ran with valleytinworks.
Can't you stand on your own? Why do you turn it into a soap opera?
If you have a problem, why do you wait until someone else starts a thread?

Its very troll-like behavior.

And when a person tries to deal with you, its nearly impossible because you change you mind constantly, and try to change the deal mid-way through, adding to the deal, taking away from the deal- its really a pain and no-one knows where they stand with you.

Also, Trevor gave a knife to your cousin Rachel's accident, I'm shocked that you would treat people the way you do when they have given of themselves to help out your family. Grow up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top