- Joined
- Jan 3, 2013
- Messages
- 5,713
I used to think little of the .30-30, but I was wrong. The .30-30 will be plenty of rifle for what the OP is asking. They do a fine job blowing holes clean through deer. They are also pretty light weight and great for lugging around. If you sight it in for 200 yards, there will be some drop towards 250, but it's doable if you use the same loads and become familiar with them. The bonus is that there are tons of .30-30 rifles for sale cheap. Marlins can be had with a scope for around $300 around here. Winchesters pull a little more.
I don't load for .30-30 yet because I haven't saved up enough brass. I've been using Federal Power Shok 150 grain bullets. This one here: http://www.federalpremium.com/products/details/rifle.aspx?id=28
Here is my Winchester 1894. It was my old mans.

The .45-70 is really fine for deer too. Just put the bullet in the right place. IMO, it's a little more versatile with big game, but the guns are usually a little heavier. I have some seasons that require I use a muzzle loader or a single shot, external hammer, breech loading rifle in calibers .35 or bigger. The .45-70 is pretty popular for that. Here's my H&R Buffalo Classic:

I don't load for .30-30 yet because I haven't saved up enough brass. I've been using Federal Power Shok 150 grain bullets. This one here: http://www.federalpremium.com/products/details/rifle.aspx?id=28
Here is my Winchester 1894. It was my old mans.

The .45-70 is really fine for deer too. Just put the bullet in the right place. IMO, it's a little more versatile with big game, but the guns are usually a little heavier. I have some seasons that require I use a muzzle loader or a single shot, external hammer, breech loading rifle in calibers .35 or bigger. The .45-70 is pretty popular for that. Here's my H&R Buffalo Classic:
