Jerry,
You are a MASTER at "Causing" confusion... and you know it.
You probably just got caught up in your own confusion for a moment.
-----------
I can see where a lot of people like the SAR4.
While I personally think the handle is too large and heavy, it does offer a nice feel and versatility. I still don't like the non-functioning choil - and I don't expect I will ever like that type of choil. - sorry.
I am also not sure I am big on the jimping treatment and the cut-out scales.
The blade shape is decent enough, but for a multi-function task/chore type blade, I MUCH prefer a dropped point to semi-spear pointed blade shape more along the lines of the SHBA, AD, and recent S5. :thumbup:
However, the NM treatment feels and looks nice, the scales (outside of the jimping cut-out) are VERY nice looking, and the satin blades are ALWAYS nicer looking.
Pros and cons, but bottom line, I am not a fan of the SAR4. - To each their own.
-----------
But, if you want us to mention other SAR options,
I do , LOVE the SARSquatch - right out of the box! :thumbup: About the only thing I would have changed would have been to eliminate the swedge grind. And that is not a significant issue for me as is.
And the SAR5 is VERY nice to me. Simple and pure function. The SAR5 just needs some butt reduction therapy and a bit of shaping treatment and it will be a winner. :thumbup:
.