My 3 knife experiment.

Experiment update. I am still on course and "the 3" handle any and all duties easily. BUT, as much as I adore my #66 Ebony Jack, I'm getting an itch to slide an old bone scaled jack in the pocket (VOOS, or Robeson jumping for attention the most, but even the Queen and H&R are getting antsy). Noting quite like an old knife with character. Although the #66's high class cousin, a Stag #66, came out to play the other day and almost ruined the experiment for me.

Still hangin' in though. ;)
 
I am still hanging in there as well but I have lost some of my enthusiasm for the experiment. My chosen three handle my chores well but I do miss my other knives. While I miss my slippies a lot I think I miss a full sized sak the most. They are just so handy.
How about the rest of the gang? Still on track? No shame if your not.

Jim
 
I have somewhere north of $30K tied up in sharps. No way am I going to limit myself to just three. For a year? :eek:
 
I have somewhere north of $30K tied up in sharps. No way am I going to limit myself to just three. For a year? :eek:

I don't want to try a year either. I and a few others are just trying to stick to three for 2 1/2 months. Started October 15th, trying to stick to it till January 1st.
It's getting harder the longer I go. I guess that's what makes me a knife-nut.

Jim
 
Of my three (boker congress, queen small stockman, case peanut cv) the peanut has seen the most use. I'm happy to stick to the three. I am also very happy that I stipulated the right, at the beginning, to carry the new BF knife when it arrives. After seeing the finished article, I'm so glad I promised myself that. :)
 
Im game!!! Just was going to start doing this myself. Is this just limited to edc or are we talking woods carry? I was going to finally leave my GB SFA at home and go with my customized BK9 instead. Trade out my Spyderco Bushcraft or BRKT Aurora and go with a Marttiini Arctic Circle Puuko and as always keep my Large 6375 Case Amber bone Stockman in my pocket. I could "Dundee" rig my BK9 for an edc but I think its a little much.:D

BK9
Puuko
Stockman
 
Update.

Just got home for the first time since October 14th. About five weeks on the road, stops to visit family in Georga, Texas, California, and some sight seeing in New Mexico at White Sands and Carlsbad Caverns. Sone hiking in the Cleveland National wilderness area in the Elsinore Mountains in California. Through it all, the only knives I had used, where the ones I left hone with, the Vic classic on my keyring, and the peanut in my pocket.

There were tons of food packages to open, all of the almost tooth and nail proof plastic. Then there was the food in those packages that needed to be sliced up and eaten in locations like the top of a mountain in the Blue Jay camp ground in California, a picnic on the beach at Malibu, some cheese and crackers in the shade of a dune at White Sands, salad sliced and diced at Aunt Jane's in Atlanta. Aunt Jane is a very dear old lady, but the knives in her kitchen were butter knife like in edge. Bell pepper, radish, Avocado, fresh dill, and tomato all fell prey to the peanut. The tomato's were a bit big, so instead of slicing in a convention way, they were sliced in a wedge pattern which was within the parameters of the 2 inch peanut blade.

Some rope needed to be cut in Texas. Old dirty, grimy rope. No problemo.

Two jugs of the Rain-x windshield washer fluid got used. Hey, I like a clean windshield, and I prefer the orange stuff. Makes running in the rain lots easier. But the foil seal had to cut out, and the classic did the deed without problem. The classic kept nails trimmed well for the month and some days on the road. The SD tip of the classic came in handy for replacing the batteries in grand daughter Briana's toys. Bree became a devout fan of the little classic, and went looking for things to do with the classic. She loved using the little scissors for the magnet school projects.

So far, from high mountain lakes like Lake Arrowhead at 5,000 feet in the San Bernadino mountains to the desert terrain of New Mexico, to the Texas brush country, the peanut and classic did all I needed.

So far, so good.

The minimum bulk of the peanut left room for other things that were very important for one being thousands of miles from home, like small flashlights, extra bandana. It was surprising how much you come to depend on a tiny flashlight like the Fenix E01 when you spend nights in strange places, and don't know the layout if you have to get up in the night. Or getting up at 5AM to get an early start on the road.

Carl, Grand High Muckba Of The Cult.
 
Update....

Jackknife, your updates read like a knife lover's 'fear and loathing' :) Thanks for giving us fresh reading material. As for myself, I'm trudging along still, I've managed to stay faithful, although I must say I've just shifted my focus over to watches to keep myself entertained :rolleyes:
 
I've been thinking about trying this experiment, or a variation of it at least. Three knives wouldn't be ideal since my collection is small, smaller now that I've given a couple more away to friends, and I already only carry the same three most often anyways. So I might carry one only. I can't start yet as I'm still waiting on my GEC 15 Electrictians Knife to arrive. I would have to try that out once it arrived so I can't start going one knife only yet. But when it gets here I might pick it up, put the others away, and use only that knife for a couple of months. We'll see.
 
Update.

Just got home for the first time since October 14th. About five weeks on the road, stops to visit family in Georga, Texas, California, and some sight seeing in New Mexico at White Sands and Carlsbad Caverns. Sone hiking in the Cleveland National wilderness area in the Elsinore Mountains in California. Through it all, the only knives I had used, where the ones I left hone with, the Vic classic on my keyring, and the peanut in my pocket.

There were tons of food packages to open, all of the almost tooth and nail proof plastic. Then there was the food in those packages that needed to be sliced up and eaten in locations like the top of a mountain in the Blue Jay camp ground in California, a picnic on the beach at Malibu, some cheese and crackers in the shade of a dune at White Sands, salad sliced and diced at Aunt Jane's in Atlanta. Aunt Jane is a very dear old lady, but the knives in her kitchen were butter knife like in edge. Bell pepper, radish, Avocado, fresh dill, and tomato all fell prey to the peanut. The tomato's were a bit big, so instead of slicing in a convention way, they were sliced in a wedge pattern which was within the parameters of the 2 inch peanut blade.

Some rope needed to be cut in Texas. Old dirty, grimy rope. No problemo.

Two jugs of the Rain-x windshield washer fluid got used. Hey, I like a clean windshield, and I prefer the orange stuff. Makes running in the rain lots easier. But the foil seal had to cut out, and the classic did the deed without problem. The classic kept nails trimmed well for the month and some days on the road. The SD tip of the classic came in handy for replacing the batteries in grand daughter Briana's toys. Bree became a devout fan of the little classic, and went looking for things to do with the classic. She loved using the little scissors for the magnet school projects.

So far, from high mountain lakes like Lake Arrowhead at 5,000 feet in the San Bernadino mountains to the desert terrain of New Mexico, to the Texas brush country, the peanut and classic did all I needed.

So far, so good.

The minimum bulk of the peanut left room for other things that were very important for one being thousands of miles from home, like small flashlights, extra bandana. It was surprising how much you come to depend on a tiny flashlight like the Fenix E01 when you spend nights in strange places, and don't know the layout if you have to get up in the night. Or getting up at 5AM to get an early start on the road.

Carl, Grand High Muckba Of The Cult.

Sounds like you had a great trip! Those little Fenix flashlights are awesome, aren't they? I keep the LD01 in my pocket and put the EO1 in my wife's purse.

I had my Damascus Peanut in pocket today. Didn't do anything with it other than cut the rubber band off the newspaper.

Some days I'm tired of doing this little experiment, and others I don't even think about knives at all.
 
It has been a long time coming...but, I have failed. I was doing really well, even putting off carrying some new blades that I just couldn't pass by. In all honesty my 3 knives were more than capable of carrying me through to the end of the year, and probably the rest of life (if I didn't have any options). My weakness began when I got a package in the mail that contained 6 knives that belonged to my uncle that passed over the summer. The thoughtful gift from my family included 3 Old Timers, which I have been wanting to try out. But, I stayed strong. I simply cleaned them up and put them on display with the knives that I inherited from my grandfathers (a group shot is definitely in order). While I started to weaken, I had resolve. But then today...today...I woke up to Jackknifes tale of a neglected peanut...and well, it was the straw that broke the camels back. I just had to carry my peanut today. So, I swapped out my stockman for the peanut and felt that was good enough. I was already for work and headed out the door when I got a nagging feeling. If my peanut felt bad, then surely my Burnside Jack did as well. The next thing i knew my pockets were full of neglected steel, 4 knives to be exact!

So there you have it. I made it all of 5 weeks into a 10 week experiment. i certainly learned a lot about what I require from day to day, but I also reaffirmed why I love traditionals: the feeling they give you.

Thanks Grateful for starting this experiment, but I feel I have returned to my lustful ways ;)
 
It has been a long time coming...but, I have failed. I was doing really well, even putting off carrying some new blades that I just couldn't pass by. In all honesty my 3 knives were more than capable of carrying me through to the end of the year, and probably the rest of life (if I didn't have any options). My weakness began when I got a package in the mail that contained 6 knives that belonged to my uncle that passed over the summer. The thoughtful gift from my family included 3 Old Timers, which I have been wanting to try out. But, I stayed strong. I simply cleaned them up and put them on display with the knives that I inherited from my grandfathers (a group shot is definitely in order). While I started to weaken, I had resolve. But then today...today...I woke up to Jackknifes tale of a neglected peanut...and well, it was the straw that broke the camels back. I just had to carry my peanut today. So, I swapped out my stockman for the peanut and felt that was good enough. I was already for work and headed out the door when I got a nagging feeling. If my peanut felt bad, then surely my Burnside Jack did as well. The next thing i knew my pockets were full of neglected steel, 4 knives to be exact!

So there you have it. I made it all of 5 weeks into a 10 week experiment. i certainly learned a lot about what I require from day to day, but I also reaffirmed why I love traditionals: the feeling they give you.

Thanks Grateful for starting this experiment, but I feel I have returned to my lustful ways ;)

Don't feel bad, Todd, I would have caved, maybe, when I was out in California. I was in the kitchen, making a chicken and broccoli casserole, and while slicing up the chicken breast and broccoli crowns, I had a huge hankering for my Sardinian resolza. But the resolza was 3,000 miles away on the opposite coast. I kept on that afternoon with the peanut, but I can only wonder if the other knife had been in my duffle bag, would I have had the will to resist the "other precious"?

At some point, we have to face and admit we're cursed with the 'afliction', knife knutitis!

Carl.
 
At some point, we have to face and admit we're cursed with the 'afliction', knife knutitis!

Carl.

Very, very true, the best I can do lately is alternate between my #15 clip/pen in ebony (my own precious for almost a year now) and my stag 73 in my pocket everyday, switching on out for the other depending on what mood I'm in that day, with my Opinel 6 always in my tool pouch for at work. This is my routine and it still involves three knives. Every now and then my GEC Bullnose gets tossed in (getting carried, at least to work in the pouch with the Opinel) a lot more often lately as I remember how tough that knife is and how effortlessly it cuts. And now my GEC electrician's knife that will see aloooooot of carry and use. That's quite a few knives considering one is enough for everything I need to do. And I have a few others That only sometimes get carried, and more I eye for the future, even if I don't buy a lot of knives or that often realistically compared to most knife knuts. It's still a sickness, a ruthless affliction:D
 
...At some point, we have to face and admit we're cursed with the 'afliction', knife knutitis! ...
This is why I wished you well but didn't think twice about signing on. I'm too far gone to limit myself to three, at least in the way this challenge was posed. Heck I can barely limit myself to having 3 ON me at the same time.
 
An update. I think I will be glad to get back to using some other knives after the first of the year, but unlike some others above, it has been getting easier as I go to stick with the three I picked. It's a good experiment; I don't think I will continue it after the first of the year unless I decide on at least a couple other knives to substitute in. I just like too many of my knives to leave them "forever".

Ed J
 
Hi Folks,

Yes, still using my GEC 72. Of course, I don't work and frankly pretty much hang out at my house. When I do leave the 72 goes with me.

Used it for the normal stuff; however, surprised this knife did a great job cutting a loaf of Italian bread. Many knives just sort of squish the bread down, but this knife did a great job of slicing.

Got in a Buck stockman, took a look at it but haven't used it. Not sure if this "contest" or whatever it's called did it, but there was at least one knife I knew I was going to buy and didn't. The recently released GEC large stockman.

Anyway, this has been interesting.

Regards,

George
 
I am still chugging along with my classic and Opinel. I am getting along fine and they cover my daily needs pretty well. I don 't really think about reaching for anything else in the morning.i do however miss my other knives and realize that my pocket knife affliction is more about want than the search for a 'better' knife.
I use a knife everyday. I can easily justify owning three. I have all that I have because I enjoy using different knives and I collect them. This might seem obvious to most people but I guess I wasn't sure some times why I kept buying them.
I am browsing the internet now looking for another one. Just for fun and I won't spend more than I can afford so it will be just fine. I think I can even wait until January 1st to use it. The hunt continues.

Jim
 
I was feeling a little tempted after we got back from our odyssey around the country. I'm not sure if I would have grabbed my number 15 or resolza, so I put all my other pocket knives in a bag and told my better half to put them someplace. Now, Karen won't tell me where they are, so that's a bite in the butt. So I guess I'm going to keep on keeping on with my peanut and classic.

Hmmm, what drawer did I put those pipe cleaners in?
 
Back
Top