Need opinion on my design?

skillgannon said:

This is a similar blade shape that was done well in my opinion. Just for reference . Your knife looks really close to something that I would really love.
Click to expand...
I like shape of knife , but that blade is thick like axe behind edge...He use to much force tu cut that rope ...................
 
gudspelr said:
I think blanket statements can be dangerous, because it can lead to assumptions. You make a point to those asking for suggestions on their designs not to take blanket statements from others giving advice (study other people’s work, go with tried and true designs, etc). However, you make a blanket statement that anyone charging $1,000.00 + for a knife is smoking crack and EXTREMELY narcissistic. If figured woods on knives are a crazy notion to you, that’s fine. But don’t put others in a box or imply such negative things about a person for liking something different than you-that happens to cost a lot of money. I’ve had the good fortune to see and hold knives that I’m sure cost that amount and more. The knives were IMPRESSIVE! What should a guy charge when he’s spent hundreds of dollars alone in fine mammoth that still has to be worked? What about mosaic Damascus that the maker spent hours and hours making over days because of all the manipulation required for the pattern? How about the forged integrals like some are doing? The bizarre amount of skill along with the time and finish work to make so many of these knives come from some of the best people I’ve met who have nothing to do with drugs, nor are they on the spectrum of narcissists.

I don’t want to derail the thread for the OP, I just wanted to address something that seems to be inconsistent in your advice. People can all make what they want and follow that path for the people that use their knives. That should include my measly attempts as much as it should for an incredibly accomplished maker who uses very high end materials.

To the OP, you’ve gotten some good advice. Your knife looks well finished. I can understand liking the tip being higher to allow for more belly when skinning. I was once told to make each knife the best one I’ve ever made. You seem to have a great attitude to go along with your skills. I look forward to seeing your future knives.


Jeremy
Click to expand...


Go back and read right before I made that statement.... yeah, right there, see where it says "I THINK"???? Yeah, that flushes your entire jab at me down the bowl!!;) You see, saying that "one thinks" is stating an opinion, not giving a statement of fact which you're accusing me of. So, good to have YOUR FACTS in order before doing that! K, chief? Thanks.
 
Remind us what you think of the board ownership while you're at it.
 
I apologize if I came off as insulting/negative. I’m glad different folks have different points of view and am equally as glad different makers make different knives of various styles. Something I don’t like, someone else will love and vice versa. I guess I’m saying that I feel like there’s room for all at the “knife table”. I don’t disagree that you said you “think” and therefore it’s your opinion, not “fact”. I guess where I disagree is that stating an opinion can be just as much of a blanket statement as anything else, which can lead to misunderstanding, at a minimum. You have seemed to take exception (please correct me if I’m perceiving things incorrectly) in other’s posts regarding advice to the OP. I think it’s generally accepted that advice given is a combination of someone’s opinions and experiences and not fact. Even so, you’ve pointed out your strong feelings against those opinions and then stated some of your own. I’m not sure how my thoughts on your post differs to a point that leaves them completely unreasonable?

I’m not a “chief” and perhaps you meant that as an endearing term? I know written word leaves much to be desired when it comes to communication. I sincerely don’t wish to cause a problem or derail this thread. It just happens that a few design threads came up and you made some similar comments in each that (in my opinion), made me want to provide a different perspective to a potential newer person reading. Knife design is absolutely a subjective thing and I choose to believe you have a sincere desire to positively impact those with whom you write to in your encouragement to make what they like. I don’t always get what I say right (just ask my wife), but when I disagree meaningfully with someone, I try to convey my opinion in a way that is respectful. Even if I thought the same as you regarding price, I just couldn’t bring myself to tell some of the amazing makers on here that they’re EXTREMELY narcissistic and smoking crack.

Jeremy

One Armed said:
Go back and read right before I made that statement.... yeah, right there, see where it says "I THINK"???? Yeah, that flushes your entire jab at me down the bowl!!;) You see, saying that "one thinks" is stating an opinion, not giving a statement of fact which you're accusing me of. So, good to have YOUR FACTS in order before doing that! K, chief? Thanks.
Click to expand...
 
I will gladly give $1000 for the Warenski Tut Dagger as well as just about any Michael Walker custom folder
 
No need to apologize Jeremy. I took no offense. Was trying to respond in an overly sarcastic, "duh" kinda way. (Thought the smile/wink guy would help).

But I promise you, I don't get angry, bear a grudge, then stalk the person to oppose every post from that person. Just to be some type of "Forum Justice Warrior"! Sad really.

And nothing meant by ending in chief. I use that, or sport, champ, boss, meng. Goes with the haha "lighten up and have a beer" kinda attitude. But not meant to rebuke.
 
Last edited:
There's a lot of knives I'd pay $1000 for (if I had it). Then again, there are a lot of knives out there that will bring those prices (or more) that do have me scratching my head from time to time. Saw a maker that's only been at it for a year get $1500 for one of his pieces the other day. Had the OP posted a picture of said knife, it would have probably had many of the same criticisms (or worse) in my opinion.
Then again, you just can't get around the laws of supply and demand, and as long as people are willing to pay those prices, good for the makers who can get them... Gotta pay for those TW-90s and Moen platens somehow! ;)
 
gudspelr said:
I think blanket statements can be dangerous, because it can lead to assumptions. You make a point to those asking for suggestions on their designs not to take blanket statements from others giving advice (study other people’s work, go with tried and true designs, etc). However, you make a blanket statement that anyone charging $1,000.00 + for a knife is smoking crack and EXTREMELY narcissistic. If figured woods on knives are a crazy notion to you, that’s fine. But don’t put others in a box or imply such negative things about a person for liking something different than you-that happens to cost a lot of money. I’ve had the good fortune to see and hold knives that I’m sure cost that amount and more. The knives were IMPRESSIVE! What should a guy charge when he’s spent hundreds of dollars alone in fine mammoth that still has to be worked? What about mosaic Damascus that the maker spent hours and hours making over days because of all the manipulation required for the pattern? How about the forged integrals like some are doing? The bizarre amount of skill along with the time and finish work to make so many of these knives come from some of the best people I’ve met who have nothing to do with drugs, nor are they on the spectrum of narcissists.

I don’t want to derail the thread for the OP, I just wanted to address something that seems to be inconsistent in your advice. People can all make what they want and follow that path for the people that use their knives. That should include my measly attempts as much as it should for an incredibly accomplished maker who uses very high end materials.

To the OP, you’ve gotten some good advice. Your knife looks well finished. I can understand liking the tip being higher to allow for more belly when skinning. I was once told to make each knife the best one I’ve ever made. You seem to have a great attitude to go along with your skills. I look forward to seeing your future knives.


Jeremy
Click to expand...
Thank you Jeremy!
 
knife to a gunfight said:
First off, I think you did a great job on the fit and finish. I would agree that the rear pin is a little too far back. I'd personally replace it with a lanyard tube at that location. I don't think there's anything wrong with curves, in and of themselves, though I think the point may be a little high to be used comfortably in many applications. If using it as a skinner that's one thing, but then I think the blade may be a bit longer than it would need to be, thereby sacrificing some control.

As for the swedge, I think it's a matter of personal preference and more of a visual appeal than anything. I personally don't mind it.
Click to expand...
Thank you for the review! I do test my knives form time to time and this is version 4. I agree with your points. It sure is not easy : )
 
knife to a gunfight said:
There's a lot of knives I'd pay $1000 for (if I had it). Then again, there are a lot of knives out there that will bring those prices (or more) that do have me scratching my head from time to time. Saw a maker that's only been at it for a year get $1500 for one of his pieces the other day. Had the OP posted a picture of said knife, it would have probably had many of the same criticisms (or worse) in my opinion.
Then again, you just can't get around the laws of supply and demand, and as long as people are willing to pay those prices, good for the makers who can get them... Gotta pay for those TW-90s and Moen platens somehow! ;)
Click to expand...
Making knives sure is not cheap! Thank God for people, who support us...
 
Hi all,

I had some time today to do a sketch of the knife and have added changes as you suggested:

Chpn7AW.jpg


The knife above is an old mark 2.

1. I start with the tip:

The tip is in line with the thumb well. I think this helps with indexing, at least for me. It is something i find natural. I tried to bring the tip lower, but it did not speak to me. The bulge after the tip i find apealing, but i also found, it gives the tip great strenght in piercing.

2. The belly:

It is all belly, i agree. Again this is my personal choice. It does not push cut great, but slices quite deacent. The balde is full flat grind with 0.3 mm cutting edge.

3. The ricasso:

I have pushed the ricasso back in order to have more cutting edge. I have found that this overall dimension has more cutting edge then most knives i have held. The bow has 145mm or 5.6 inches of cutting edge. This also dictates the shape above.

4. The handle:

I still heve a lot of work here. I have added bigear ''bird beak'' at the back and lowered the guard. I will add soldered bolsters and maybe bolsters at the back end. I also added a 5mm tube for a lanyard.


Thank you all for the interest in this! Your comments are greatly appriciated!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top