Newbie. Looking for an easy opening, medium (< 4 inch) length, EDC, with "class"

Samtheeagle, you've received a ton of suggestions on this thread, some excellent and some that apparently misread your question entirely.

My personal favorites for carry are Chris Reeve knives but they are way out of the "entry level" price range so I won't belabor you with their virtues. Instead I'll concentrate on basics.

I think you're wise to avoid many of the more extreme or tactical looking knives currently available; pull that out to open a box in the office . . . women will swoon and men blanch in fear and weapons policies will not be far behind. So, less threatening is better.

If you are going to carry in your pocket not via a clip, my recommendation would be to go for something closer to a classic pocketknife with a blade that is very unlikely to open in your pocket. Most liner or axis lock folders are held closed with very little pressure so they can be easily flipped open and no one wants an open knife in their pocket.

I also avoid knives with large opening loops, extended kickers or other items that protrude beyond the basic dimensions of the handle - these not only add size and weight to the knife but I find them unattractive.

That said, I keep a Kershaw Chive as a desk knife and really like it's blade shape for opening things so I expect the Leek would be good choice. If you use ceramic stick sharpeners, the recurve shape isn't too difficult to sharpen.

Honestly, one of two things will happen, either you'll be satisfied with your purchase and only look for another blade when that one dies or you will become one of those pitiful people who spend their lives searching for the "perfect knife." I know, I spent a year and a dozen knives before I was really satisfied with my EDC knives and I'm still in the loop here looking for something new that strikes my eye.

Hmmm, does this apply to most of us here on this forum?????
 
First of all, let me say thanks again for all of the recommendations. There have been a bunch of posts lately that I've only just now read (I forgot to subscribe to my own thread :-( )

I really am not in the market to spend anything over $125, as I'm looking for something to use and carry and I'd cry if I lost a knife that cost so much. Someday when I'm rich, I suppose I might indulge and get a knife that costs more. But for now, it can't cost too much money.

I looked at Al Mar knives ... very pretty! I'm adding them to my "someday" list. As well as Seki Cut. And now I'm thinking that a knife makes a pretty cool travel souvenir (go to Germany, buy a German-made knife, etc).

Case knives are also starting to appeal quite a lot. I like buck knives a lot, but they seem to be a little heavier than my ideal.


Look what Mister Mailman brought me a couple days ago:

Kershaw Splinter: very nice weight. A lot easier to open than I imagined.

1285488901_0941b7e11b.jpg


Kershaw Leek: nice. this is the knife that started me looking into buying an edc. nice weight. love the assisted open.

1286351756_3dfd57e8ae.jpg


Kershaw Mini Cyclone: i love the shape of the blade on this knife, which rectifies the fear i have about breaking the tip off of a leek. this knife is very heavy, though.

1285498043_910d3d1542.jpg


Spyderco Mini Persian: very cool. a tad heavy and large.

1286374938_b9f2b2788f.jpg


Spyderco Viele II: speaks to me. great size. it presses my "unusual" button in a perfect way (i don't expect to ever meet someone carrying this knife). i dig the viele stamp of uniqueness. i love the smaller opening hole and the viele signatures (3 holes + viele symbol). a tad on the heavy side. worried about the pointy blade shape. really like the un-locking action.

1286369956_e1ccd3d210.jpg


Spyderco Kopa: very nice. maybe a little too small and costly. but it feels right in a lot of ways.

1286365418_e7a5ea03c2.jpg


Benchmade Opportunisit: very light! perfect size. not really a one-handed opener. pretty expensive for such a minimalist item.

1286454108_4eb3886847.jpg


Benchmade Mini Grip: this was a last minute add-on to the order. i was expecting to be ho-hummed by this thing. it does not press any of my "classy" buttons. too tactical and everyday looking. but wait a minute: the axis lock is awesome! it's one of the lightest knives of the bunch. it's pocket clip is understated enough that i might consider actually using the clip. feels like it's build like a tank. blade shape is perfect. this thing is clearly a tool that is meant to be used every day, and i would enjoy using this every day.

1286466774_6187b7282b.jpg


Class Photo #1

1285616475_945fe15c6a.jpg


Class Photo #2

1286479744_025ece552e.jpg



I can only keep one of these babies. Which one will it be? Hmmmm. Decisions, decisions.

- Sam the Eagle
 
Benchmade Mini Grip: this was a last minute add-on to the order. i was expecting to be ho-hummed by this thing. it does not press any of my "classy" buttons. too tactical and everyday looking. but wait a minute: the axis lock is awesome! it's one of the lightest knives of the bunch. it's pocket clip is understated enough that i might consider actually using the clip. feels like it's build like a tank. blade shape is perfect. this thing is clearly a tool that is meant to be used every day, and i would enjoy using this every day.

That would be my vote.
 
First of all, let me say thanks again for all of the recommendations. There have been a bunch of posts lately that I've only just now read (I forgot to subscribe to my own thread :-( )

I really am not in the market to spend anything over $125, as I'm looking for something to use and carry and I'd cry if I lost a knife that cost so much. Someday when I'm rich, I suppose I might indulge and get a knife that costs more. But for now, it can't cost too much money.

I looked at Al Mar knives ... very pretty! I'm adding them to my "someday" list. As well as Seki Cut. And now I'm thinking that a knife makes a pretty cool travel souvenir (go to Germany, buy a German-made knife, etc).

Case knives are also starting to appeal quite a lot. I like buck knives a lot, but they seem to be a little heavier than my ideal.


Look what Mister Mailman brought me a couple days ago:

Kershaw Splinter: very nice weight. A lot easier to open than I imagined.

1285488901_0941b7e11b.jpg


Kershaw Leek: nice. this is the knife that started me looking into buying an edc. nice weight. love the assisted open.

1286351756_3dfd57e8ae.jpg


Kershaw Mini Cyclone: i love the shape of the blade on this knife, which rectifies the fear i have about breaking the tip off of a leek. this knife is very heavy, though.

1285498043_910d3d1542.jpg


Spyderco Mini Persian: very cool. a tad heavy and large.

1286374938_b9f2b2788f.jpg


Spyderco Viele II: speaks to me. great size. it presses my "unusual" button in a perfect way (i don't expect to ever meet someone carrying this knife). i dig the viele stamp of uniqueness. i love the smaller opening hole and the viele signatures (3 holes + viele symbol). a tad on the heavy side. worried about the pointy blade shape. really like the un-locking action.

1286369956_e1ccd3d210.jpg


Spyderco Kopa: very nice. maybe a little too small and costly. but it feels right in a lot of ways.

1286365418_e7a5ea03c2.jpg


Benchmade Opportunisit: very light! perfect size. not really a one-handed opener. pretty expensive for such a minimalist item.

1286454108_4eb3886847.jpg


Benchmade Mini Grip: this was a last minute add-on to the order. i was expecting to be ho-hummed by this thing. it does not press any of my "classy" buttons. too tactical and everyday looking. but wait a minute: the axis lock is awesome! it's one of the lightest knives of the bunch. it's pocket clip is understated enough that i might consider actually using the clip. feels like it's build like a tank. blade shape is perfect. this thing is clearly a tool that is meant to be used every day, and i would enjoy using this every day.

1286466774_6187b7282b.jpg


Class Photo #1

1285616475_945fe15c6a.jpg


Class Photo #2

1286479744_025ece552e.jpg



I can only keep one of these babies. Which one will it be? Hmmmm. Decisions, decisions.

- Sam the Eagle


What are you going to do with the rest of them?
 
Kept the Splinter.

Returned the others to the good folks on the internet.

I love the Splinter. Very nice and lightweight. I can carry it loose in my pocket and it doesn't particularly stick out too badly. Surprisingly easy to flick open ... I've never had a nice thumbstud opener before. And it looks like a nice classy piece, doesn't scream out "MALL NINJA!". I can see this being a nice thing to give to my kids someday (okay ... they'll have to pry it from my cold dead hands). It would be nice if it had assisted open, but it's really no big deal.

Yay!

- Sam
 
Stick with a kershaw of your liking.
Thumb stud opening assists take time getting used to, so you're really not missing out otherwise.
 
Those are terrible choices. You should immediately send them all to me and start over . . . ;)

The Spyderco Kopa is my favorite of your lot for elegant, gentleman's carry in an office environment. My own "whitecollar" knife is a traditional Boker copperhead pattern slipjoint in smooth redbone.
 
Sog Twitch is a great knife I had one but forgot it was in my suitcase and had to give it up at the airport. I have one on order now
 
Just saw some Al Mar knives at the local Stoddard's Cutlery shop over the weekend. Pricey but they made me drool and they would be excellent gentlemen's knives. Lightweight, elegant, would not freak people out.
 
I think you'll find even 3" is pushing what can be carried in the pocket of a pair of khakis without looking odd or standing out like a sore thumb. Points I'd suggest you consider.

Thickness - The thicker the knife (blade + liners + scales) the bulkier and more obtrusive it will be.

Clip position - With the slanted pockets on slacks I think you'll want a knife that sits as deep in your pocket as possible.

Width - Blade and handle width determine how "full" your pocket seems. This is why I'm not a Spyderco fan, their blades are too wide for my taste.

Wear factor - Many knives have aggressively checkered scales or roughly knurled screws, stude, etc. that can eat up a pair of slacks in just a few wearings. Look for something that won't eat your pants.
 
:thumbup: CRK Sebenza. (that's all you need to know)

That is much more than the $100 he wants to spend.

Also, the maximum blade length for Boston is 2 1/2 inches. You CAN NOT carry anything over 2 1/2 in Boston. You NEED to keep that inmind.
 
Back
Top