I think starting your own thread is a great idea. It will add to the number of threads about this situation and bring more attention to it. Looking forward to what you post!
It is a problem when other members come in and comment on a situation like it just happened, not noting the date on the OP. If you will notice those comments have been edited out. Starting a new thread helps keep the focus on the current on going situation and it adds to more people seeing multiple threads on the subject.
craytab - first of all, I have nothing personal against you, so my comments include others, not just you. I don't think that there's anything contained herein that is serious enough to take offense to nor to feel solely targeted.
Your 2 above quotes makes sense and are constructive and it seems that your main emphasis throughout most of this thread was to show 'boondocks45' why starting a new thread would be beneficial ('bring more attention to it', 'add to the # of threads', etc.) to his cause and our well being as fellow BF members. I couldn't agree more as to being supportive and giving constructive help to any member so willing to accept such.
My only thought having read this entire thread is that 'boondocks45's' first post elicited several subsequent comments that weren't nearly as constructive and amicable as these most recent posts. Had the earlier more negative posts started out as constructive, helpful and as courteous as these last few posts, he would never have needed to have felt guilty/chagrined enough to have openly apologized for his initial post. That he now has felt pressured enough to comply with the desires of a few and has stated that he will start yet another thread concerning this same 'seller/maker', should make it rather obvious that the more helpful, constructive approach would have had the same exact effect, without making this member feel like he'd done something 'wrong'......'wrong' enough to feel that he needed to apologize to 'whomever'.
I'm hoping that these last constructive posts would have ocurred without mine and others intervention, but if one's main emphasis and goal all along was to help guide a less knowlegable member in the 'right' direction (suggesting that he start a new thread), why couldn't that have been the content of the more senior, knowledgable members very first response and post to the inquiring member, rather than the comments made which were totally void of any constructive 'guidance'......?
New and old members alike have this in common......we're always learnin'........