Lovely and well chosen piece(s) of fancy-figured Hard Maple, and even more wonderful to see that not everybody on here is into impersonal/inert 'machine-made/machine-formed plastics' Not to throw water on the fire but if you look closely the scales have ever-so-slightly shrunk, and warped, over top the frame ever since they were fitted. A custom gunstock maker/fitter would have been severely reprimanded or fired for this. It truly is an art to choose, prepare and then shape wood knowing how it will behave in the long run.
In this particular instance the pretty wood does not impart any function other than grip and appearance. So: IMO looks have it, and you win! .
Ummm. Wow. I guess I need to be fired? Good thing these were a gift, free of charge from me to Cryptyc then. To be fair, I ground these out by eye using my BK5, not his BK2, and mine has seen a little wear. These were ground out entirely by eye (and I use no jigs when I grind blades either). A custom gunstock maker would have had the actual gun in hand to get perfect fit. I didn't have that luxury. A custom gunstock maker would also have been able to choose the wood, rather than using a free block of wood sent from another forumite, and also probably would be charging for the services rendered. None of which was the case here. About all the choosing I did was to say that curly maple would match the sheath well, and granitestateofmind was generous enough to donate some to the cause. I also chose the dye I used to match it more closely to the sheath.
And, the screws I sent are slightly smaller diameter than the stock ones, so it may just not be perfectly fitted before the screws got tightened down. Cryptyc, if you do decide to adjust the fit, be aware that the heads strip out pretty easily on those screws. I recommend using a flathead screwdriver instead of the Phillips you might think would be better. I don't really think that the wood has shrunk at all. It looked to be a pretty well-aged piece, although granite would know better than I, since the wood came from him. I'm also not a custom gunstock maker, and don't have all the fancy tools one of those would have. I used a belt grinder, an angle grinder!, and some sandpaper and a whole lot of elbow grease to shape these. Hopefully Cryptyc is pleased with the result.
I don't sell scales. Most every set of Becker scales I've made have been gifts from me to other Beckerheads. I, personally, think these are among the best ones I've been able to make. I hope to get better at making them, but frankly, without the knife, or the gun, for that matter, I'd bet your "custom gunstock maker" would be hard-pressed to get perfect fit. Under similar circumstances, I might have left them slightly large so that the new owner could fit it to his knife himself, but the whole point of this endeavor was that Cryptyc didn't feel confident in his woodworking skills. Critiques are all very well and good, and I welcome them for my work. But you might need a LITTLE more perspective than just some pictures posted on the internet to make your judgments actually accurate.
For my part, as long as Cryptyc is happy with the end result, I'm pleased. I chose a weather resistant finish (it's got about 15 coats of danish oil, a fair amount of paste wax melted into the grain of the wood, and a 5 layer CA finish over all that, with a couple more layers of danish on top). It's not stabilized, but it's also not raw wood. I chose this style of wood treatment and finish because it's a little more forgiving to climate differences (colorado being very arid), and to people who may not regularly maintain their wood.